a dialogue with a skeptic
"because we can't be sure we're experiencing even without accepting that something experience-like is going on instead, life has no meaning."
"so you're saying if you are not completely experiencing an alternative to experience, and you can't be sure you're experiencing, then life has no meaning."
"yes!"
"by what percentage of uncertainty do you doubt you're experiencing?"
"100%"
"so one full unit of doubt negates all meaning?"
"yes."
"how much does a partial unit of doubt negate meaning?"
"100%"
"then each partial unit of doubt is also doubt. that observation won't help you, though. if you doubted not at all, how much meaning would be restored."
"if i didn't doubt, life would have meaning."
"what would make you stop doubting?"
"nothing."
"then, sir, you believe life has no meaning, you aren't doubting that life has no meaning."
"how does this help me?"
"it doesn't. it means you're ready to go home from treatment."
or alternate ending,
"how does this help me?"
"beliefs change based upon opinions. opinions themselves can change from experience. i will lead you on a journey to believe in the world, and it begins with smoked salmon and cream cheese on a homemade cracker."
"that's disgusting."
"so hope tastes bad for you?"
"no, that's disgusting."
"as i have ascended from gourmand to healer, I demand you eat the cracker to get better, or else go home because you aren't willing to experience the things necessary to believe in the world. you aren't a skeptic unless you've denied everything, at least twice, because otherwise you might have been wrong the first time."
"i'm unwilling to eat your cracker, sir gourmand, and now i also doubt i am a skeptic. I must be a nihilist."
"then you may as well be my slave. i'll treat you better than your beliefs."
"because the burden of proof is on the one requiring proof, i must accept this proposition."
"then eat the cracker."
https://plus.google.com/u/0/+JohnMorrisSorcerer
https://www.facebook.com/john.morris.5099/