to me, "the odds [...]is/are astronomical" means "the probabilities are high"My point is that the odds of what profundo or darthmom seeing an exact representation of a complex visual scene down to the colors, texture, dimensions, that you have never been exposed to, in a dream is astronomical.
vegan said:^^ one of us misunderstood his post
To me it's quite the opposite.to me, "the odds [...]is/are astronomical" means "the probabilities are high"
I have dreamt of shoes before (i'm a bit of a fiend actually) but never with this clarity and in every other shoe dream, i never actually GET the shoes. they're always just out of reach of my hand or money. generally my shoe dreams have been expressing a sense of longing or dissatisfaction.you may even very well have dreamt of such an auction before, but didn't think about it again because nothing reminded you of it
and generally i'd agree, yet in this instance, the detail and the timing tell me otherwise. quite strongly i might add. strong enough to spook me all day and spur this thread.let's say you're 30
30x365=10950 nights
how many dreams is that? a few times 11000 for sure, even though we don't remember most of them
how many elements did those dreams contain?
we'd probably have to count in millions
don't hold the title to this thread too literally. it was for the sake of a bette description. i don't know what it is.how many times did you have a "prophetic" dream?
statistically, don't you think it could just be a coincidence?
however, i'm open to the idea that our dreams may be influenced by external factors
that's worth its own thread
but as far as prophecy goes, my spontaneous reaction is to only see a coincidence
I made a typo on this. I meant to type "the odds against this" happening in the clarity and the degree of detail and the timing are extremely high. That is, what Profundo dreamed of is extremely unlikely to happen exactly the way it did.^^ one of us misunderstood his post
Quote:
My point is that the odds of what profundo or darthmom seeing an exact representation of a complex visual scene down to the colors, texture, dimensions, that you have never been exposed to, in a dream is astronomical.
to me, "the odds [...]is/are astronomical" means "the probabilities are high"
When the dreams are muddy, of a very general nature, and lacking in detail, I agree with you completely. Most dreams seem to fall this category. They are too general and could be interpreted to mean anything. I'll give an example of this kind of meaningless dream. 2 nights ago, I dreamed of riding in a car on a road trip with several other people. The location, highway, kind of car, faces of the people, conversations were all very vague. This kind of dream is too vague and muddy to qualify as being unusual or "prophetic." The people were to vague to match with any body in waking life.if i understand the first part of his post, he's saying exactly what i am thinking (except for the "clarity" aspect. most dreams are not exactly clear) :
that we dream so much that we are bound to eventually dream something that appears in our life
you may even very well have dreamt of such an auction before, but didn't think about it again because nothing reminded you of it
let's say you're 30
30x365=10950 nights
how many dreams is that? a few times 11000 for sure, even though we don't remember most of them
how many elements did those dreams contain?
we'd probably have to count in millions
how many times did you have a "prophetic" dream?
statistically, don't you think it could just be a coincidence?
vegan said:how often do you dream things that don't happen the next day ?
i have flashes of future events when awake too, but not too often. felt an accident before it happened a few yrs back, refused to go through an intersection and there was a semi that hit a pick up about 45 seconds later
my dreams are extremelly twistedi've had other dreams and strange coincidental occurrences which have warned me about certain people before. but none of them were this literal.
i'm open to the laterexternal factors is exactly why i started this thread. what is this, time vision? or was i somehow psychically attuned to someone listing or intending to list the shoes from the other side of the world? in my case, it could've been either one, but the latter doesn't explain darthmom's experience.
i would a priori attribute them to the huge number of dreams we havebut the latter doesn't explain darthmom's experience.
then you don't believe in the existence of coincidencesProfundo's dream has too many details that match up with the real thing to be a coincidence
we were talking about the near future, not something that happens once at a point in your lifeVery rarely. I'm sure there are dreams that I have that I don't remember, but the ones I remember that are so vivid it is rare that I don't come across their story one day.
vegan said:once again, for one time that such a coincidence happened, how many times did it not happen?
you'll agree that it is quite amazing
yet, so many humans have lived on this planet
and they have lived such a number of experiences, that such coincidences are bound to happen by the thousands
in my opinion, out of billions of coincidences that don't happen, still quite a few happen, and a very few of them are striking (such as the plum cake one)but what this thread is about is when the specifics are so detailed and unlikely as to be something more than synchronicity.
the difference here is that some see this as some sort of divine interference and others interpret it as pure coincedence. nothing worth arguing with per se, just an observation to note.vegan said:"The French writer Émile Deschamps claims in his memoires, that in 1805 he was treated to some plum pudding by a stranger named Monsieur de Fontgibu. Ten years later, the writer encountered plum pudding on the menu of a Paris restaurant, and wanted to order some, but the waiter told him the last dish had already been served to another customer, who turned out to be de Fontgibu. Many years later, in 1832, Émile Deschamps was at a diner, and was once again offered plum pudding. He recalled the earlier incident and told his friends that only de Fontgibu was missing to make the setting complete — and in the same instant, the now senile de Fontgibu entered the room."
you'll agree that it is quite amazing
yet, so many humans have lived on this planet
and they have lived such a number of experiences, that such coincidences are bound to happen by the thousands
i said it in one thread so i'll say it again. We create our reality & subconsciously(dreaming) your probably tapping into that & glimpsing the immediate-near future, sometimes even future events that are likely to occur in years from the dream.After a bit of drama with paypal, i scored a pair, and since i've been pondering this stupendous coincidence. Nah, seriously, i don't buy it. This is too unlikely to be just coincidence.
you may even very well have dreamt of such an auction before, but didn't think about it again because nothing reminded you of it
i said it in one thread so i'll say it again. We create our reality & subconsciously(dreaming) your probably tapping into that & glimpsing the immediate-near future, sometimes even future events that are likely to occur in years from the dream.
The following is a true story. Names and dates have been changed to protect the innocent:
Ive always wanted to say that. But seriously, a little background first. My girlfriend and I had been dating for almost 3 years. We met in August of 2005 when we both worked at Subway.
About 2 weeks ago, I had a dream that I was working at Subway again. I was working and suddenly everyone was really scared and nervous. I went outside and joined the rest of the population of earth (the entire population was gathered in the Subway parking lot) to find out what was going on.
Someone said "Its over." I looked up in the sky and could see the asteroid Apophis that astronomers previously thought was going to impact earth in 2029 or 2036. It was enormous in the daylight sky, but it blocked out the sun so everything was really dark.
I started crying and saying "Its over. It really is over." I went looking for my dad and my girlfriend to be with them but I could only find my dad and started freaking out that I couldnt find my girlfriend when we had so little time left on earth.
That morning, I woke up FROM THAT DREAM to a phone call from my girlfriend telling me she was breaking up with me. I didnt know whether to be mad about that or scared because of the dream she had woken me up from. I think the asteroid about to impact the earth was our relationship coming to an end, and the person telling me "its over" and me repeating "its over. it really is over" was in reference to my girlfriend breaking up with me for good.
I dont know if thats prophetic or coincidence, but it sure as fuck freaked me out.
but on occasion i believe we do get strong messages from our dreams
personally, i would not put this down to coincidence