I felt like resurrecting this because I just started FFVII for the first time in probably 4 years.
I know a lot of people who love FFVI(3 here) more than FFVII, but I honestly never got into RPG's before FFVII. Maybe that is why I like it so much, and why I honestly felt the need to start playing it today.
I have played FFVI, and honestly, it's an incredible game and definitely the best RPG I've played besides FFVII. I perfectly understand people say this is their favorite.
I'm not really sure why I love FFVII so much. The only reason I ever played it and got into RPG's at all was because every single one of my friends was absolutely obsessed with FFVII when it came out, even people that never played RPG's! I do recall my friends who were interested in RPG's earlier to be completely engulfed by FFVI, but FFVII seemed to have no limit to whom it could influence.
I do think the story is very good, yet extremely complex. I don't know why people insist that every element of a plot must be completely understood to get any joy from it, but I had no problems accepting some gaps in the information I was given considering the fact that story was so emotionally and conceptual amazing. No game has captivated me in such a complete and involving way emotional and mentally. I just don't know why, but this game got to me in a way I didn't know video games could.