Atlas,
As a friend and former colleague, it's really inspiring to see you take up the torch and stand for what you believe in this thread. Contrary to what some might have said, I think you are exactly the type of person that should be a moderator on a board such as ours - I am proud of the stand you've taken here despite knowing full well that it would most likely bring on at least a few personal attacks.
I've been hearing the word "brainwashing" thrown around so inappropriately on this board as of late - generally by those who wish to label an organizaton or club as being subversive, having malevolent intention or as being evil/criminal in some other way. I firmly believe that there meetings are held so often so that on any given day, there is a place TO GO if it is needed, and yes, there are those who do need to go everyday. Brainwashing implies that someone is made to think something different against there will, a negative connotation. I believe that by the time a person has admitted to having a serious drug problem, they are indeed looking for a way to change the way they think. They realise that they are already a slave to mind control - from the drug that has brought them to the point of loosing there true freedom, and now is the time to de-program these urges and desires. As they are fond of saying at AA/NA, "addicts are not made overnight" so neither should they be expected to change in one night.
Sure some of the literature may seem a bit hokey, as can the strangly para-spiritual nature of NA/AA, but from what I have seen this is a system that can and does work, and it is readily available to most people.
As far as the insinuation that the members who have been clean and a part of NA/AA for many, many years are either addicted to meetings or somehow power hungry and looking to climb some sort of NA/AA orginizational hierarchy sounds just a bit paranoid. True there are those who are probably using meetings as a place to focus there addictive/compulsive personalities but I know for a fact that there are those there who feel that they can truly help. If for no other reason, they provide hope when they stand up and say "Hi my name is FRED and I have been in recovery for 15, 20, 25+ years". You can't discount the impact that such a person (who for all intensive reasons probably could have moved on from NA) might have on someone who is just starting to understand how much they have fucked over themselves and want to know if it is even possible to stay clean for a day, a week or even a month. Role models are potent sources of strength for those who are in those initial stages of accepting the fact that they have a problem - sponsors just the same.
Anyway, I am typing while half asleep right now so I should stop or risk having te edit out more than my usual share of typos when I read this again in the AM. Keep up the constructive conversation, people.
Peace,
SG