The conversation here is mainly focusing on people who have had sexual reassigment surgery (so trans men with fully functioning penises and trans women with fully functioning vaginas)
Some people here are really insistent that they still wouldn't be attracted to people with the genitals they prefer but oddly refuse to specify why beyond "Do I really have to spell it out?" (because they don't want to say the quiet part - transphobia - out loud)
I mean, for me it's more of an intrinsic feeling.
When I was in middle school, I knew I was gay ever since I was a little kid, but I desperately hoped it was some sort of "phase" I would grow out, because I knew that being gay meant my life was going to be more difficult than your average straight person.
So I tried dating a girl. And at first it was fine because there was no intimacy/romance or sexual stuff, but one day she left a letter in my locker & it was a very detailed, intimate letter & I just felt really uncomfortable from it because I wasn't attracted to females. So I finally came clean & told all my chick friends that I was gay. But I wouldn't say that makes me a misogynist or anything.
I would say that some one whose had surgeries is still not quite the same to me. I'm a gay top anyways, so ultimately I'm not too worried about the front parts, but there is still going to be that intrinsic reaction (that I'm not in control of) that comes from knowing the person isn't that biological gender. There's always going to be signs, whether it's the scars from having their breasts removed or whatever. A built, fully functioning penis is a complex surgical procedure (or at least it use to be, I dunno about now a days) and it would still come out looking quite different than a regular one.
But can I strictly say I would NEVER date/sleep with some one who was trans? I'd say no, because it totally depends on the person, context, etc..
I've never been in a situation yet where I've been attracted to a trans man & then found out they were trans, so I can't technically say how I would react. I think if I TRULY was attracted to this person for who they are, then I could probably get passed it. It would be different & need some adjusting to, but a person's personality can go a long ways too.
I mean, I wish I could easily swing those ways with my attractions, cause I tend to be attracted to men who are really douchebaggy, immature & mean to me. If I had any control over that though, I wouldn't choose to be attracted to those types of men since they don't really jive with me being the sensitive person that I am. It just is what it is.
But say I was put into an experiment where I'm in a room with 5 biological males & 1 trans man & I have to sleep with at least 4 of them, I'm most likely going to gravitate toward the biological males. Not because I'm transphobic, but because I am attracted to biological males only. If I'm aware in any way that a person wasn't born male, my intrinsic feelings toward them change, which isn't something I can ultimately control. If I were to have sex with a transman, my mind is going to be constantly telling me "this person was a woman". It doesn't mean I don't like them or wouldn't be good friends with them or anything either. I have no problem using a persons preferred pronouns & referring to them as the gender they identify as, but most trans people are still self-aware enough to know that they're a "trans"-man or a "trans"-woman, rather than just being a "man" or a "woman". And there's nothing wrong with being "trans" anything either to be honest. There's no shame in being trans, so I'm not sure why some people find it offensive to be referred to as such.
I think real transphobia comes from a conscious effort to discriminate towards trans folks, which I refuse to do because I don't have anything against them. But just like that girl that came onto me in middle school, I cannot control my intrinsic reactions towards someone, especially once they are making sexual advances toward me.
And there's plenty of straight/bi men out there who'd happily date a trans women or a trans man, so I don't think me being gay & only into biological males is causing anyone to lose out on anything. Not to mention I'm basically ghetto-married at this point, so I'm not really on the dating market anyway. lol
Not only do I not mind trans people, but I also love me some good drag queens. Not the girly, beauty pageant type though. lol But actors like Divine are a big inspiration for me. I would even consider myself "non-binary" in some ways, although I don't really use that kind of language. I don't consider human behaviors to be "male" or "female" really, I think it's just "human". For example, I have no problem being sensitive, emotional, cleaning the house, wearing nail polish, eye-liner, being a little flamboyant if I feel like it... lol Some people would call those "girly" traits. But to me, I think they're just "human traits". This idea that men need to be strong & not show any emotions has been harmful to mens physical & mental well-being.
Obviously trans people & drag queens are two different things, but my point is just that I'm not bothered by gender bending or people going against cultural norms. In fact I find it inspiring at times, especially when it comes to art, performance art, film & acting, etc..
Anyways, I'll some times lose attraction to men I think are really hot if I find out they've been with someone else that I don't find attractive. Cause then picturing them with that unattractive person makes me uncomfortable. Also not something I can really control.