#2 seems to be a popular item, i think it's the "business in the front" aspect, and i think i can live with that. plus then i'll have some super chunky robert smithy expensive tennis shoes if i like, ever need them. which i could. i very well could.
I *would* say 3, but I bought a very similar pair from eBay and they're just not that comfortable. They do look good though. I quite like 1 as well..
Dunno what your budget is, but Doc Martens make some lovely boots - I wear their Bellissa and Regina a lot! Also Demonia make some gorgeous work shoes, if you like the goth thing.