panic in paradise
Bluelighter
im no where near as educated as you guys on this,,,
but, they are two very different composers, i mean, me as a laymen discern by region and era; the influences/expectancies of/put upon composers was very different from one to the next.
shostakovich is a top example for seeming redundant scales, broken melodies, pointless random fugues... etc. heheh
this scale structure though, i have electronic music; mostly "noise/leftfield" that utilize this structure, as well as indian, middle-eastern, early asian music. lots of jazz begins randomly this way, but the dots and lines slowly do come together; miles davis bitches brew is the best example i can think of for jazz
it is of ones perception though, it is "abstract" to a point.
personally i would have to go with rachmaninoff, for his solo piano composers.
denying chopin though, saying he is lesser then near any composer is crazy, heh, i cant imagine anyone believing that.
i do believe that this "frilly" part of chopins and others music came from the era, and the nobles who wanted to hear how he made music the way they liked/perceived it, plus the instruments were changing, and so the new characteristics of them were being tried.
with shostakovich you, or i rather can feel the cold brick and earth, darkness, & oppression.
but, they are two very different composers, i mean, me as a laymen discern by region and era; the influences/expectancies of/put upon composers was very different from one to the next.
shostakovich is a top example for seeming redundant scales, broken melodies, pointless random fugues... etc. heheh
this scale structure though, i have electronic music; mostly "noise/leftfield" that utilize this structure, as well as indian, middle-eastern, early asian music. lots of jazz begins randomly this way, but the dots and lines slowly do come together; miles davis bitches brew is the best example i can think of for jazz

it is of ones perception though, it is "abstract" to a point.
personally i would have to go with rachmaninoff, for his solo piano composers.
denying chopin though, saying he is lesser then near any composer is crazy, heh, i cant imagine anyone believing that.
i do believe that this "frilly" part of chopins and others music came from the era, and the nobles who wanted to hear how he made music the way they liked/perceived it, plus the instruments were changing, and so the new characteristics of them were being tried.
with shostakovich you, or i rather can feel the cold brick and earth, darkness, & oppression.