dankplantgrower
Bluelighter
The only time Id ever try and talk my way out of a situation like that, is if they were trying to get into my trunk & I actually had something to hide.
given that constitutional rights extend to u.s. citizens, why is the question "are you a u.s. citizen?" considered an invasion? it's a bit of a paradox - i totally respect somebody who wants to stand up for their rights but what is to be gained by not simply confirming that one is a citizen.
i'm not saying they should consent to a search or answer any questions about their business, but why not confirm one is a u.s. citizen.
alasdair
given that constitutional rights extend to u.s. citizens, why is the question "are you a u.s. citizen?" considered an invasion? it's a bit of a paradox - i totally respect somebody who wants to stand up for their rights but what is to be gained by not simply confirming that one is a citizen.
i'm not saying they should consent to a search or answer any questions about their business, but why not confirm one is a u.s. citizen.
alasdair
^ if you confirm you are a u.s. citizen and refuse to answer any further questions (as is your constitutional right) then there's no "dialogue that will lead to increasingly invasive questions".
also, if they want to "do whatever the hell they want", then they'll do it. it's not going to hinge on you confirming that you are, indeed, a u.s. citizen...
alasdair
I'm just curious, will this work for me, a non American citizen on the roads there?
^^^ you forgot "you are as free as we tell you you are."
The worst part about it is we pay taxes to be "protected and served"
More like harassed and served with tickets and beatings.
I got every excuse for being pulled over...ie failing to wait long enough at a stop sign. Not signaling for a turn soon enough...and my personal favorite. My licence plate lights being too dim. Freaking incredible.