Ximot
Bluelighter
- Joined
- Dec 5, 2003
- Messages
- 3,446
zophen said:^If your family member loved one tried to kill themselves would you just say "oh well it's what they wanted" ?
that's a different situation - we are then related and it all matters very much. I was merely trying to point out that your focus on the benefit of BL's interference for the family is beside the point in your argument, as you are in no way connected to that family (well, somehow yes, in the DMT way in which we're all connected, and perhaps since one family member is part of this community, of which you are also a part).
Apart from that, point taken, zoph. And I am glad he's still here and I know that people did indeed do the right thing, because what they did was done with right intent (benevolence) based on the amount of understanding the person has at this time. I am impressed, actually, by the amount of involvement and dedication to a faceless (anonymous) poster's welfare demonstrated by, say, KITD (I don't know who else as I haven't been following this in too much detail). That really is a sign of nobility.
This is not to say that someone like Ravr, who may not have done this, would have based his decision not to act on mere indifference or malevolence. He, too, would have acted with right intent (benevolence) based on the amount of understanding he has at that time - even by choosing to let him go.
I think any "right" and "wrong" comes from intent in a case like that... can we really know what goes on in another person's mind? Can we really judge whether his life is worth living? I believe it probably is, but who am I to say that and impose it upon him? I thereby force someone back into a realm he had consciously chosen to leave, whether wisely or unwisely. I act against their will if I bring them back... I am aware that my philosophy here is quite brutal if you look at it from a "must-save-lives-at-any-cost" perspective though. And I do not know how I would have reacted. I really don't. Instinctively I would have had a desire to save him as well, I guess. All I am suggesting is that there is more to this issue than simply saving lives being a good thing regardless of all other factors.