Language has a scientific basis tho - this is simply some guys opinion about a subjective experience. And the knowledge he's basing his ideas on is pretty limited and he's taking money for it which perverts it even more.
I remember seeing the Piers Gibbon documentary where he went to the "wise" shaman and this shaman really got into the role - he was saying "Oh you need to take ayahuasca every night for the next 40 days and take tobacco juice on top of it" like some strict schoolteacher. As if he was more important than the ayahuasca itself. That's the role you force these people into by going to them on bended knee. I don't know why people need the "wise master" in something like psychedelics. To me the psychedelic is about you and the drug - nothing else matters.
has nothing to do with their level of wisdom.
What wisdom can he offer tho? If I'm deep in an emotion remembering someone I loved who died is the shaman going to come over and start talking in my ear? I don't want anyones wisdom, that's never healed me. The only thing that healed me was crying while high on mushrooms and feeling the comfort and peace of mind that gives you. The mushrooms healed me all by themselves - I never needed anything but them. If anybody else feels the need for a talking therapy with a shaman then that's fine but it's not for me. I like it one on one with the psychedelic.
Nothing is black and white. I agree that the industry of western ayahuasca shaman "tourism" is rife with people just trying to make money. Although I don't think that it's always true, I'm sure there are legitimately well-intentioned shamans offering the service who also need to make a living, who are actually trying to help people. Besides that though, it's not like that's the only way it happens. True, for a westerner to seek out a shaman for an ayahuasca ceremony, they'll have a hard time finding such a person (I would guess), because what do we know of these people really? But say you were invited to a ceremony by someone connected to it? And it wasn't part of that whole industry? In my mind, you can't just throw it all out because there is a vein of corruption going through it from some.
As for what wisdom a shaman could potentially offer, well, they have been practicing and refining techniques passed down over millenia. They have an intimate knowledge of recipes to make it (there can be many plants added as adjuncts), they understand ways to guide people through that particular experience, they understand how to induce different trance states through chanting/drumming/etc, and so on. We discovered ayahuasca recently, while they've been using it since time immemorial. I think it's rather short-sighted to dismiss them as potentially having something to offer. Surely all that time and tradition has not resulted in nothing gained in terms of knowledge and understanding of the state it produces.
I'm not going to try to seek out a shaman-guided experience, and I doubt I'll ever have one. I don't need a guide to a psychedelic experience, I am my own guide. But if it were to fall upon me organically, I would probably do it. Like I said before, I think there is certainly potential value even for a westerner, because of the exposure to an entirely different cultural context for the experience... this will greatly influence set and is by definition a vastly different setting. And we all know that set and setting influence a trip as much as or more than anything else.
Perhaps this explains how even my difficult trips are positive. My thoughts on psychedelics are mingled with the good vibes of the
Grateful Dead and the idea difficult trips could be the most beneficial. After all I have enjoyed every experience with classical psychedelics I have had. Could this be the result of my comforting cultural set?
It certainly could be. I find the same to be true. If I had lived in the dark ages in Europe, in a time full of fear of god and satan, without a cultural context for psychedelics at all, and I had eaten a handful of mushrooms and started tripping unexpectedly, I bet I'd freak out and think I was possessed or something. Instead I read endlessly about them on Erowid and heard about many positive reports... I also heard about them by word of mouth as something that could be fun. I've had really terrifying experiences but I have enjoyed those too, and they've been valuable to me.