I voted for my 2nd favorite film EVER (behind only The Shawshank Redemption), Pulp Fiction.
While Reservoir Dogs will always have a special place in my heart (it's my 11th favorite film EVER - and my 2nd favorite QT film ever - the specificity of Mr. Orange practicing his "pitch" was remarkable, and Buscemi should have won the Oscar that year for Best Supporting Actor, hands down) . . .
. . . Pulp Fiction, to me, possesses the exact same strengths that Dogs possesses (OFF-THE-CHARTS dialogue, acting, casting, non-linear presentation) PLUS it's SEXY.
And, in this QT-lover's opinion, Pulp is without peer as THE MOST RE-WATCHABLE FILM EVER.
If I am flipping channels, and Pulp is on (which, thankfully, seems to be a once-a-month occurrence) I will ALWAYS watch it from wherever I picked up until the closing credits.
Always.
Personality certain does go a long way.
And so does re-watchability.
I find both Kill Bill films to be "good" as opposed to "bad," but with that said, I found them to be FAR overrated - while they were certainly enjoyable to watch, neither of them sniffs my personal All Time Top Hundred Films (my brother summed Kill Bill II for me perfectly):
ME: "How was Kill Bill II?"
MY BROTHER: "You'll love it. BOTH lines of dialogue were fantastic."
My third favorite QT piece (behind only Pulp & Dogs) is THE FOURTH ROOM of Four Rooms.
If you haven't seen it, and you love QT - GO SEE IT & THANK ME LATER!!!
Great thread!