?vash445,
Have You Tried
![]()
PINK_COCAINE
1-phenyl-1-carbomethoxy-2-methylaminopropane
Yet?
vash445,
Have You Tried
![]()
PINK_COCAINE
1-phenyl-1-carbomethoxy-2-methylaminopropane
Yet?
Can you tell me how you know for sure it isvash445,
Have You Tried
![]()
PINK_COCAINE
1-phenyl-1-carbomethoxy-2-methylaminopropane
Yet?
The belief that "current methods" inherently skip purification steps also needs backing.First, reductive amination (ahem) is a one-step reduction, so of course it's "one-pot." Maybe you're labelling it this as a demerit and carrying over association with shoddy fly-by-night clandestine operations and shortcuts, but that's a stereotype and I want to discourage it. Safrole vs. PMK is another place where people get the wrong impression. Anyone starting from safrole is still making PMK (read: MDP-2-P) before they ever touch MDMA. That's been standard chemistry for decades. Shulgin was using these routes in PIHKAL long before any of today's designer precursors showed up, and plenty of labs worldwide are still using older methods like Al/Hg amalgam with methylamine and MeOH. So I'm not sure the Australian reports represent the global picture well enough for us to draw big conclusions.
It just feels like you might be trying to make limited or local data fit the idea that there's a single main chemical culprit behind inconsistent effects people report from illicit "MDMA." And I'm not saying you're wrong, just that the pieces don't quite line up for me.
On the meth angle: sure, PMK → MDMA and BMK → MA using similar reductions is basic chemistry. But the jump to mystery side-product X and its 3,4-desmethylenedioxy analog simultaneously degrading both MDMA and meth worldwide is a pretty big leap.
As for the claim that "so much MDMA and MA out there is meh", that's a huge assumption on a global level. What dataset confirms that? From what I see, quality and availability vary regionally like they always have. There's definitely bunk stuff, impurities, and counterfeits floating around, but that's neither new nor uniform. Honestly, it's exactly why legalization and proper oversight would clean up the scene if implemented correctly.
That’s the classic logic trap, cum hoc ergo propter hoc, or "correlation does not imply causation." And anyway if there is evidence, great, but right now it doesn't look settled enough to declare it. Black-market production also isn't centralized enough for one methodological shift to ruin the global supply of two different drugs in parallel. That's not how these networks operate. Some labs adopt newer methods, others don't. Discovery of one trend in one region doesn't mean everyone else abandoned older routes.
The belief that "current methods" inherently skip purification steps also needs backing. Clandestine chemistry has variable quality control. That's not unique to 2025.
We can't prove much about clandestine processes with certainty; we can only make educated guesses. That's why I'm hesitant to treat any single explanation as the definitive answer. Regions differ wildly: people in the UK and Ireland complain a lot about weak MDMA; Germany's patchy but often solid; the Netherlands is still pumping out strong gear; and in the US, both meth and MDMA quality can be excellent depending on who you know. And these are just a handful of markets; many others exist worldwide.
I hope none of this comes across harsh. I get why your theory is appealing, and it's worth discussing. I just think some of the assumptions deserve another look before we pin the global situation on one manufacturing shift.
Have a great week. I genuinely appreciate the thoughtful debate.
Full agreement here.
No, I'm sorry, I have to call this out. The notion somehow that "natural" is better than "man-made" is bullshit. First, it assumes that somehow mankind is unnatural. As if we aren't a natural part of this planet who evolved here. Also, some people claim that mushrooms are better than acid because shrooms are "natural" while LSD is synthetic. But consider: humans have been genetically modifying shrooms through selective reproduction for decades, gatekeeping reproduction for species with higher alkaloid levels. A psychedelic mushroom like P. cubensis "Penis Envy" doesn't have large enough caps or produce enough spores to compete and survive in the wild on its own. And consider how LSD is manufactured from ergot, the fungus that grows on rye.
I used to manufacture MDMA ~25 yrs ago from sassafras oil. The first step is isolating the safrole from the sassafras oil via vacuum distillation. At that point, there's no difference between synthetic safrole and naturally derived safrole. Its chemical name is 3,4-methylenedioxyallylbenzene. There is no entourage effect like we see in cannabis. The safrole is purified. Also, nature produces poisons let's not forget. There are some deadly poisonous fungi out there for example, or white oleander will kill the shit out of someone. You've got poison ivy, poison oak and poison sumac. I could go on. And on the flip, do you have any idea how valuable and important the fully manmade anesthetic, Ketamine, is to the medical world? It doesn't compromise respiration while a person can be fully anesthetized. Prior to its discovery full anesthesia required a person to be on a respirator. That's why it's listed as an essential medicine by the World Health Organization.
The WHO also recognizes fentanyl as an essential medicine. Why? Because it's so potent and cheap to manufacture. Without it, there are scores of underdeveloped nations whose hospitals could not otherwise afford opioid analgesics. It provides real pain relief to countless people worldwide. That's what it's for. Comparing oxycontin to fentanyl for their recreational "warmth" is a subjective opinion and a moot point bc that's not what they're for, not what they're designed to do. And the notion that one is better than the other because it is a semi-synthetic morphine derivative is, frankly, nonsense. Want some more examples of fully synthetic medicines that have immense value?
Well for antibiotics there are Levofloxacin and Ciprofloxacin: broad-spectrum antibiotics used to treat a wide-range of bacterial infections. There's the antiviral drugs, Oseltamivir (Tamiflu), and Acyclovir which is used to treat herpes simplex virus infections. You've got Lisinopril, an ACE inhibitor used to treat high blood pressure and heart failure, plus there's Losartan, an angiotensin II receptor blocker used to treat hypertension. Haloperidol, used to treat schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders, is entirely synthetic, as is Risperidone, an atypical antipsychotic used to treat schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and irritability associated with autism.
How about the anticonvulsants, Carbamazepine—used to treat epilepsy and neuropathic pain—and Lamotrigine for bipolar disorder, also used to treat epilepsy? Or hell, Ibuprofen and Acetaminophen (Paracetamol) are synthetic. There's Claritin and Zyrtec, synthetic antihistamines. Lipitor and Zocor to control cholesterol levels and reduce risks of heart disease. Or how about Prilosec and Nexium, proton pump inhibitors that give ppl relief from gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and peptic ulcers. These synthetic medicines play crucial roles in various medical treatments and have significantly improved healthcare outcomes.
Apologies if it seems like I'm coming down hard on you, @Kushman3000, but I'm compelled to push back against that claim whenever I encounter it… Also, I've seen Tool live seven times now. To me, their shows aren't really MDMA events. That's definitely a show for dropping acid and sneaking in a DMT vape for prying open my third eye!![]()
After adding the acetone, how should the cooling be managed? Just leave to cool in the ambient temperature or continue to heat and gradually reduce temperature over hours/days?With reference to the posts from @vash445 @Didgital and @unodelacosa would it be best to go with IPA and acetone for recrystallisation?
For the first bit of dissolving in IPA, do you set it to a particular temp and then slowly add until the mdma is dissolved, or do you calculate a certain amount of IPA to add and then raise the temperature until it dissolves?
Polymorphs are so rarely achievedFull agreement here.
No, I'm sorry, I have to call this out. The notion somehow that "natural" is better than "man-made" is bullshit. First, it assumes that somehow mankind is unnatural. As if we aren't a natural part of this planet who evolved here. Also, some people claim that mushrooms are better than acid because shrooms are "natural" while LSD is synthetic. But consider: humans have been genetically modifying shrooms through selective reproduction for decades, gatekeeping reproduction for species with higher alkaloid levels. A psychedelic mushroom like P. cubensis "Penis Envy" doesn't have large enough caps or produce enough spores to compete and survive in the wild on its own. And consider how LSD is manufactured from ergot, the fungus that grows on rye.
I used to manufacture MDMA ~25 yrs ago from sassafras oil. The first step is isolating the safrole from the sassafras oil via vacuum distillation. At that point, there's no difference between synthetic safrole and naturally derived safrole. Its chemical name is 3,4-methylenedioxyallylbenzene. There is no entourage effect like we see in cannabis. The safrole is purified. Also, nature produces poisons let's not forget. There are some deadly poisonous fungi out there for example, or white oleander will kill the shit out of someone. You've got poison ivy, poison oak and poison sumac. I could go on. And on the flip, do you have any idea how valuable and important the fully manmade anesthetic, Ketamine, is to the medical world? It doesn't compromise respiration while a person can be fully anesthetized. Prior to its discovery full anesthesia required a person to be on a respirator. That's why it's listed as an essential medicine by the World Health Organization.
The WHO also recognizes fentanyl as an essential medicine. Why? Because it's so potent and cheap to manufacture. Without it, there are scores of underdeveloped nations whose hospitals could not otherwise afford opioid analgesics. It provides real pain relief to countless people worldwide. That's what it's for. Comparing oxycontin to fentanyl for their recreational "warmth" is a subjective opinion and a moot point bc that's not what they're for, not what they're designed to do. And the notion that one is better than the other because it is a semi-synthetic morphine derivative is, frankly, nonsense. Want some more examples of fully synthetic medicines that have immense value?
Well for antibiotics there are Levofloxacin and Ciprofloxacin: broad-spectrum antibiotics used to treat a wide-range of bacterial infections. There's the antiviral drugs, Oseltamivir (Tamiflu), and Acyclovir which is used to treat herpes simplex virus infections. You've got Lisinopril, an ACE inhibitor used to treat high blood pressure and heart failure, plus there's Losartan, an angiotensin II receptor blocker used to treat hypertension. Haloperidol, used to treat schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders, is entirely synthetic, as is Risperidone, an atypical antipsychotic used to treat schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and irritability associated with autism.
How about the anticonvulsants, Carbamazepine—used to treat epilepsy and neuropathic pain—and Lamotrigine for bipolar disorder, also used to treat epilepsy? Or hell, Ibuprofen and Acetaminophen (Paracetamol) are synthetic. There's Claritin and Zyrtec, synthetic antihistamines. Lipitor and Zocor to control cholesterol levels and reduce risks of heart disease. Or how about Prilosec and Nexium, proton pump inhibitors that give ppl relief from gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and peptic ulcers. These synthetic medicines play crucial roles in various medical treatments and have significantly improved healthcare outcomes.
Apologies if it seems like I'm coming down hard on you, @Kushman3000, but I'm compelled to push back against that claim whenever I encounter it… Also, I've seen Tool live seven times now. To me, their shows aren't really MDMA events. That's definitely a show for dropping acid and sneaking in a DMT vape for prying open my third eye!![]()
Have we found what we can't seeFull agreement here.
No, I'm sorry, I have to call this out. The notion somehow that "natural" is better than "man-made" is bullshit. First, it assumes that somehow mankind is unnatural. As if we aren't a natural part of this planet who evolved here. Also, some people claim that mushrooms are better than acid because shrooms are "natural" while LSD is synthetic. But consider: humans have been genetically modifying shrooms through selective reproduction for decades, gatekeeping reproduction for species with higher alkaloid levels. A psychedelic mushroom like P. cubensis "Penis Envy" doesn't have large enough caps or produce enough spores to compete and survive in the wild on its own. And consider how LSD is manufactured from ergot, the fungus that grows on rye.
I used to manufacture MDMA ~25 yrs ago from sassafras oil. The first step is isolating the safrole from the sassafras oil via vacuum distillation. At that point, there's no difference between synthetic safrole and naturally derived safrole. Its chemical name is 3,4-methylenedioxyallylbenzene. There is no entourage effect like we see in cannabis. The safrole is purified. Also, nature produces poisons let's not forget. There are some deadly poisonous fungi out there for example, or white oleander will kill the shit out of someone. You've got poison ivy, poison oak and poison sumac. I could go on. And on the flip, do you have any idea how valuable and important the fully manmade anesthetic, Ketamine, is to the medical world? It doesn't compromise respiration while a person can be fully anesthetized. Prior to its discovery full anesthesia required a person to be on a respirator. That's why it's listed as an essential medicine by the World Health Organization.
The WHO also recognizes fentanyl as an essential medicine. Why? Because it's so potent and cheap to manufacture. Without it, there are scores of underdeveloped nations whose hospitals could not otherwise afford opioid analgesics. It provides real pain relief to countless people worldwide. That's what it's for. Comparing oxycontin to fentanyl for their recreational "warmth" is a subjective opinion and a moot point bc that's not what they're for, not what they're designed to do. And the notion that one is better than the other because it is a semi-synthetic morphine derivative is, frankly, nonsense. Want some more examples of fully synthetic medicines that have immense value?
Well for antibiotics there are Levofloxacin and Ciprofloxacin: broad-spectrum antibiotics used to treat a wide-range of bacterial infections. There's the antiviral drugs, Oseltamivir (Tamiflu), and Acyclovir which is used to treat herpes simplex virus infections. You've got Lisinopril, an ACE inhibitor used to treat high blood pressure and heart failure, plus there's Losartan, an angiotensin II receptor blocker used to treat hypertension. Haloperidol, used to treat schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders, is entirely synthetic, as is Risperidone, an atypical antipsychotic used to treat schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and irritability associated with autism.
How about the anticonvulsants, Carbamazepine—used to treat epilepsy and neuropathic pain—and Lamotrigine for bipolar disorder, also used to treat epilepsy? Or hell, Ibuprofen and Acetaminophen (Paracetamol) are synthetic. There's Claritin and Zyrtec, synthetic antihistamines. Lipitor and Zocor to control cholesterol levels and reduce risks of heart disease. Or how about Prilosec and Nexium, proton pump inhibitors that give ppl relief from gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and peptic ulcers. These synthetic medicines play crucial roles in various medical treatments and have significantly improved healthcare outcomes.
Apologies if it seems like I'm coming down hard on you, @Kushman3000, but I'm compelled to push back against that claim whenever I encounter it… Also, I've seen Tool live seven times now. To me, their shows aren't really MDMA events. That's definitely a show for dropping acid and sneaking in a DMT vape for prying open my third eye!![]()
For solubility isopropyl is bestWith reference to the posts from @vash445 @Didgital and @unodelacosa would it be best to go with IPA and acetone for recrystallisation?
For the first bit of dissolving in IPA, do you set it to a particular temp and then slowly add until the mdma is dissolved, or do you calculate a certain amount of IPA to add and then raise the temperature until it dissolves?
After adding the acetone, how should the cooling be managed? Just leave to cool in the ambient temperature or continue to heat and gradually reduce temperature over hours/days?
So honestly it sounds what I expectedChased Kykeon again and got the following response:
"At the moment, the techniques available in our laboratory are HPLC–MS/MS (triple quadrupole) and ¹H-NMR (with ¹³C-NMR when needed), combined with simple solvent-based sample preparation. Although we do not currently have MALDI, high-resolution MS, XRF/XRD to physically isolate the “8%” impurity fraction, we can still perform a meaningful impurity investigation with the tools we have.
Using HPLC–MS/MS, we can design a targeted method to look specifically for known synthesis byproducts, intermediates and structural analogues described in the literature, including possible inhibitory impurities such as 1-(1,3-benzodioxol-5-yl)propan-2-ol. Even without isolating the impurity fraction, MS/MS can detect many low-level components if they ionize under ESI, and we can focus our interpretation on non-MDMA signals.
With NMR, we can perform an impurity-oriented ¹H-NMR scan, which is especially good for identifying certain classes of contaminants (alcohols, aldehydes, amides, unreacted precursors). While very low-concentration impurities may fall below the NMR detection threshold, combining the information from NMR and MS/MS provides a much clearer picture of the impurity profile and can highlight unexpected components.
Based on our experience, a combined HPLC–MS/MS + NMR impurity-focused analysis can still reveal many relevant impurities without needing to physically separate them, and it is the most realistic and technically robust approach we can offer in-house."
Let me know if this fits your needs, and if you have any other questions.
***************
How does that sound?
My suggestion is acetone for recrystallization #1 and recrystallization #2 and avoid ethanol at all costs
I would probably choose acetone vs ethanol, the yield with ethanol is not only is crappy the formation of form 2 and just formed crystals just is overall crap
I would ask them
What is the MHz they run their NMR at...
For the first bit of dissolving in IPA, do you set it to a particular temp and then slowly add until the mdma is dissolved
While I agree to some extent mapsI would use just IPA, and it NEEDS to be anhydrous. 19mL brought to a boil, 1 gram added, solution is stirred until clear. Allow to cool slowly. Slower the cooling = larger crystals. If you stick in freezer when its still hot youll get a ton of mini crystals.
Blah blah blah. Medicine from the earth is the real medicine. In fact, marijuana is the only realFull agreement here.
No, I'm sorry, I have to call this out. The notion somehow that "natural" is better than "man-made" is bullshit. First, it assumes that somehow mankind is unnatural. As if we aren't a natural part of this planet who evolved here. Also, some people claim that mushrooms are better than acid because shrooms are "natural" while LSD is synthetic. But consider: humans have been genetically modifying shrooms through selective reproduction for decades, gatekeeping reproduction for species with higher alkaloid levels. A psychedelic mushroom like P. cubensis "Penis Envy" doesn't have large enough caps or produce enough spores to compete and survive in the wild on its own. And consider how LSD is manufactured from ergot, the fungus that grows on rye.
I used to manufacture MDMA ~25 yrs ago from sassafras oil. The first step is isolating the safrole from the sassafras oil via vacuum distillation. At that point, there's no difference between synthetic safrole and naturally derived safrole. Its chemical name is 3,4-methylenedioxyallylbenzene. There is no entourage effect like we see in cannabis. The safrole is purified. Also, nature produces poisons let's not forget. There are some deadly poisonous fungi out there for example, or white oleander will kill the shit out of someone. You've got poison ivy, poison oak and poison sumac. I could go on. And on the flip, do you have any idea how valuable and important the fully manmade anesthetic, Ketamine, is to the medical world? It doesn't compromise respiration while a person can be fully anesthetized. Prior to its discovery full anesthesia required a person to be on a respirator. That's why it's listed as an essential medicine by the World Health Organization.
The WHO also recognizes fentanyl as an essential medicine. Why? Because it's so potent and cheap to manufacture. Without it, there are scores of underdeveloped nations whose hospitals could not otherwise afford opioid analgesics. It provides real pain relief to countless people worldwide. That's what it's for. Comparing oxycontin to fentanyl for their recreational "warmth" is a subjective opinion and a moot point bc that's not what they're for, not what they're designed to do. And the notion that one is better than the other because it is a semi-synthetic morphine derivative is, frankly, nonsense. Want some more examples of fully synthetic medicines that have immense value?
Well for antibiotics there are Levofloxacin and Ciprofloxacin: broad-spectrum antibiotics used to treat a wide-range of bacterial infections. There's the antiviral drugs, Oseltamivir (Tamiflu), and Acyclovir which is used to treat herpes simplex virus infections. You've got Lisinopril, an ACE inhibitor used to treat high blood pressure and heart failure, plus there's Losartan, an angiotensin II receptor blocker used to treat hypertension. Haloperidol, used to treat schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders, is entirely synthetic, as is Risperidone, an atypical antipsychotic used to treat schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and irritability associated with autism.
How about the anticonvulsants, Carbamazepine—used to treat epilepsy and neuropathic pain—and Lamotrigine for bipolar disorder, also used to treat epilepsy? Or hell, Ibuprofen and Acetaminophen (Paracetamol) are synthetic. There's Claritin and Zyrtec, synthetic antihistamines. Lipitor and Zocor to control cholesterol levels and reduce risks of heart disease. Or how about Prilosec and Nexium, proton pump inhibitors that give ppl relief from gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and peptic ulcers. These synthetic medicines play crucial roles in various medical treatments and have significantly improved healthcare outcomes.
Apologies if it seems like I'm coming down hard on you, @Kushman3000, but I'm compelled to push back against that claim whenever I encounter it… Also, I've seen Tool live seven times now. To me, their shows aren't really MDMA events. That's definitely a show for dropping acid and sneaking in a DMT vape for prying open my third eye!![]()
Tell that to the spray packsBlah blah blah. Medicine from the earth is the real medicine. In fact, marijuana is the only real
All medicine is medicine from the earth. Where else would it be from? Another planet?Medicine from the earth is the real medicine.
Aliens brought the ergotAll medicine is medicine from the earth. Where else would it be from? Another planet?
The procedures from here are pretty simple. The samples are stored for a maximum of 2 months, so you will need to order regular q+q testing and send us new samples. You will need to mention that you specifically need us to "perform full targeted MRM methods on a range of MDMA impurities." If you can even tell us which impurities they want to test for, that’s even better.