jose ribas da silva
Bluelighter
I would have to say I disagree with the bold part.
If you know about not just psychiatry, but also psychology and even philosophy (I studied determinism in college...if you don't know about it you can look it up), you probably realize that everyone is generally a combination of 2 things: 1) genetics and 2) past experiences.
From the way you say that the illnesses come from "the difficulties of the modern world" it sounds like you only believe that our life experiences cause problems but not our genetics, and that is not true cause we already know that bipolar and schizophrenia and alcoholism and things like that can run in families.
I also do believe our brains can literally change from what we face in life. Like, not just like trauma as a psychological thing but maybe that the structures of our brain or amounts of dopamine or serotonin or brain waves can change from things we face, like in PTSD.
I do believe that there ARE real scientific basis to all the conditions people have but that we don't yet have the tools to see what is going on in the brain.
I also do not necessarily agree that most of these conditions are temporary.
I mean, it depends on what you mean by "temporary", but if you mean that they will just go away by themselves if we don't do anything about it, then I don't necessarily believe that is true.
If someone has a true mental health issue I doubt it will just go away if we ignore it.
Yes, I have expressed myself in a very restrictive way. There are certainly genetic predispositions, traumas, and so on. Also, they can remain forever if not treated properly.
Let's imagine someone who had a trauma during the adolescence. If there was trauma, there was a stressful situation, which, at that specific moment of its occurrence, culminated with the releasing of a set of substances, such as neurotransmitters, hormones, small signaling molecules, etc. These substances were released in order to allow the body to respond to the stressful pressure that was imposed on it. As a basis of comparison, if one needs to run because of a danger, adrenaline is released but when adrenaline is no longer present its effects cease. This is not the case with traumas. Once the set of substances released during the moment of the stressful situation was metabolized and was no longer acting, the mental symptoms did not cease as they should, it is a permanent condition.
Which kinds of biochemical changes occur in the brain to generate this posttraumatic symptoms? Apparently, some genes are permanently activated during the traumatic experience and because of that an unnatural pattern of gene expression is established. Does this activation last forever? is there a way to circumvent it or deactivate the genes? These are the questions to be done.
Last edited: