If we're putting a reply button on each post, would it be possible to also add some kind of indicator at the beginning of the post that indicates to whom the post is directed? I'm noticing already that people are clicking the "Reply" button and not mentioning who they are replying to (since it appears to them that the post is directly above or linked somehow), leaving confusing responses. Something like @Cane2theLeft at the beginning of the post if I was replying to the post above by clicking the reply button on the post would work well. The "Post Reply" button or Quick Reply options would be the only things that would give a blank text box for responding to a thread in this case.
ya good point, although i'm not for the @"enter username" idea, as then the people have to scroll up and try to find the post. that's one of the most frustrating things about the youtube comments lol. the way it's set up i think people just get confused/forget that they aren't actually the next post underneath the person above them, since the reply box opens up directly under the post for convenience. hopefully with time people will start to recognize their mistakes, but if not i think maybe the reply button should somehow be removed? or is there maybe a way to add another button to distinguish between the reply options? (i.e., one would just say "reply" and clicking it would bring you to a new page, and then another button could say "post-comparison reply" (of course something that means the same thing but much shorter. its late and cant think atm)).