Firstly, I just want to say its a little unfair to target one specific line of my post when I contributed (what I feel) is some great knowledge on the topic of the original post: that is pharmacological options for treating addiction. I wrote quite a long post about how I feel sub/methadone and Medication Assisted Treatment is the way to go. I also wrote that 12 step is a useful tool as well, but I feel MAT is way better, although both together is probably the strongest front you could put on to fight addiction.
Some questions I have: What "other medical associations" are against 12 step programs in conjuncture with maintenance programs?
That sounds very counter productive, since most maintenance programs recommend you undergo some sort of therapy, group or otherwise. NA meetings could definitely fall under this "realm".
Why would you forgo another tool to assist in recovery? Can you show me any data that shows that "medical associations" are against 12 step programs in combination?
Can I get some info on your claims? I'd honestly love to see it (seriously, no sarcasm at all i'm being 100% genuine), because I'd love to see how these professional medical groups can reason something so retarded from my point of view that it makes me scratch my head. To not have an opinion one way or the other regarding 12 step programs is one thing, to discourage their use? Sounds very iffy to me at best and I would love to hear what these groups use as "logic" to back these claims.
Also, off topic again, but, to your other point: the fact that we built civilization, and are able to sit around and have discussions and debate instead of resorting to violence has proved that we are able to quell these instincts and move on past our violent nature

The fact that we can sit in rooms and discuss opposing ideas and beliefs instead of resorting to smashing the other persons head into a rock shows this. If you believe in that then theres no real point to civilization and existence, is there?
Very bleak outlook, in particular for someone who wants to better their life and get treatment. I can no longer believe in all of that pessimism. Call it vanity, call it ignorance, call it what you want, but these beliefs are long gone from my brain because then well the world is an awful place that I dont want to be a part of. If you wanna break us down to our animalistic evolutions, thats fine, but just remember we did EVOLVE at some point and are capable of more.
Being idealistic is not a bad thing. Its a great thing. Its something to strive for. Otherwise, what the fuck are you reaching for?
Just as people strive for perfection (yet rarely achieve it) is a goal at least (and despite the rarity, achievable!) we can strive to be the "perfection of humanity." Just as people strive for sobriety, so can we strive for bettering our world. Theyre both goals. You work every day at all of these things, its not just some magic button.
If you honestly think that we are all just animals and there is no point to conscious thought having arisen and the human spirit and soul and that we're just another slab of meat being controlled by violent animalistic impulses....then im truly sorry for you, plain and simple.
You cannot convince me this is true. I used to believe it...but then I saw that we are capable of much more by simply looking around at the marvels of humanitys accomplishments when we come together. Just look around you for evidence.
Look at this forum, where we are all coming together to help one another, people we dont even know, help save their own lives and battle addiction.
Sorry, we really gotta take that discussion elsewhere IMO. Mods feel free to chop away the irrelevant discussion
Now I've back on topic: Sobriety-> addiction! This time i'll promise I wont stray. I promise!