Thats a pretty pessimistic outlook man. I cannot accept those things as true, because if so then im resigning myself to a world I do not want to live in.
If those things are true, than mankind cannot and will not go anywhere as a species. And i refuse to accept that humanity cannot go anywhere.
Just because its idealistic doesn't mean we shouldn't strive for it, and give up before its realized. You may think your tough but resigning yourself on humanity and people on such a level is really nothing more than a cowardly excuse for your own violent tendencies imo.
I believe mankind can pull its shit together. Not everyone is as violent and animalistic as you claim. Do you know everyone and everyones thoughts on the whole planet?
Sorry to derail...this is a great thread i've been following it reading everything everyones posted just haven't contributed myself.
Regarding the topic of AA/NA....it shares a key point with all other options: admitting powerlessness. This admission allows the person to (hopefully) accept a different path in life. Maintenance treatment requires a similar step: the admission of powerlessness over the drug allows the person to "submit to a higher power", in these scenarios, Methadone or Bupe treatments (and all that goes along with them).
In addition, as i mentioned in another thread, its thought that AA/NA creates a different mindstate; that is to say, it creates a mindstate in such that endorphins are produced via the social connections and setting of the meeting. The setting and everything there triggers a mindstate in an addicts brain, in something that can almost be argued to be akin to, well, using drugs.
Maintenance meds are simply amazing, and IMO may be required for most opiate addicts on a long term to permanent basis. the brain is severely damaged (and split hairs if you want, but i consider this damage plain and simple) because of the "rewiring" of pathways which lasts on a very long to permanent basis, plain and simple.
And it is these rewired, unnatural, "pathways" in the brains system that the maintenance meds "cast" so to speak....that is to say, without the medication, the brain is not working in the original manner, and will not go back to doing such for a LONG time, if ever. So, which is worse: a "cast" for an "injury", or leaving it "castless" allowing it to become further damaged (further damage in this case is relapse). Opioid dependency is not some short term thing that can be overcome IMHO:
it is I believe, a lifelong, permanent change to your neurobiological functioning, and as such would require lifelong treatment.
Your brain pathways do not just "go back to normal" once you get clean. It takes months upon months, years upon years, for your brain to get even close to normal again. And throwing away medicines that allow you to do things and live your life free from these burdens of addiction...
The maintenance medications remove the "crave", which most feel is the ultimate problem regarding addiction: the crave and inability to control it. The fact that the addict screams that they want to be clean, and yells for help, but cannot treat it on their own, proves this to be
oneproblem where addiction is concerned.
Once this is treated (which bupe/methadone do) well the person is much better off, although this is not the only thing. However, this makes bupe/done very effective tools in treatment; to target addiction at its core...well you'd have to be crazy to pass up that tool in saving your life.
The changing of pathways though is why i find ibogaine (and other drugs such as LSD, mushrooms, etc) a very interesting, novel, wonderful, and possibly (semi-)permanent treatments. Long term studies must be assessed but the fact that these drugs "rewire" your brain and pathways in a way much as they have been "rewired" in the past by drug abuse. Not saying that everytime you trip is gonna cure you, but it is possible.
Ever notice how people have breakthrough trips on LSD/DMT/DXM/Ibogaine and are seemingly 'cured"? or how similarly one has a totally different outlook and lease on life after a nice ol' trip? Rewiring and changes in brain pathways, possibly back to a good state (though not guaranteed by any means)...interesting approaches to be sure.