• Current Events & Politics
    Welcome Guest
    Please read before posting:
    Forum Guidelines Bluelight Rules
  • Current Events & Politics Moderators: deficiT | tryptakid | Foreigner

Israel is under attack

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah in one of my classes in school I read “The Psychology of Socialism”, as well as “Reflections on Violence” by Sorel (who was kind of an admirer and disciple of Le Bon in certain ways). I thought it was interesting how they both predicted how the masses could be harnessed for a reactionary/counterrevolutionary purpose, which pre-WW1 wasn’t a common perspective, as the masses were generally seen by conservatives/the right as threatening, and they wanted to keep the masses as far away from and the power centers as they could. True mass politics was seen as the domain of the left, with the SPD probably being the premier example. But following WW1 and the emergence of fascism, a lot of those predictions by Le Bon/Sorel etc seemed to bear themselves out in certain respects. I’ve heard that other political figures (Mussolini, Lenin, etc) from the interwar period also internalized some of Le Bon’s ideas but that’s just what I’ve heard, dunno if it’s true or not.

Alright I’ll stop derailing the thread now 😜
Mussolini created fascism, so I'm pretty sure he knew the book. It was a must-read for any social scientist or leader.
That and Gabriel Tardes.

I mean Gustave wrote a manual how to mindfuck your people. It's a bit more like a self-fulfilling prophecy
Like throwing food in front of a pig and predicting that it will eat the food :ROFLMAO:
 
never have i said that, never would i say that. please try responding in good faith next time.

my point is that one SHOULD not spread misinfo/ disinfo.

and saying israel is not bombing civilians is PATENT misinfo, potentially disinfo... and shows either bad faith or extreme lack of knowledge on the subject. israel does not even deny that they are bombing the piss out of civilians... they just try to (poorly) justify it.
As of December 30 2023 Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor estimated Gaza Strip deaths as 30,034 total and civilian deaths at 27,681 which would mean about 2,353 militant deaths.

9% military deaths, rest is civilian

edit: sorry 8%
 
Ok haltstop! Before the State of Israel was announced in 1919 and declared in 1948, there were 90% Arabs livin there, 5% Jews and 5% Christians.
In 1948 of around 950,000 Arabs, 800,000 were expelled or decided to leave. Some of them came back later, another 150k or so

Then in the 1948 Arab-Israeli war over 11,000 Palestinian civilians were killed
Countless more in other wars and revolts.

Before 2023 it was 21% Muslim, 74% Jewish, and 5% other Religions

The driving of Palestinians from their land in 1948 is a fact and not a good one, although it was often done less with force and more with coercion (although violence and murder were indeed employed). But something like 800,000 Arabic Jews were expelled or fled from surrounding Arabic countries to Israel in the 1950s and these Jews aren't massacring the citizens of those countries. Clearly, it is possible to face historical injustice with something other than genocidal vengeance. As nearly every other group of people wronged in the past do today, except for some reason, the Palestinians.

It's almost like there is something 'special' in the culture of Palestinians that makes them less willing to moderate the manifestation of their legitimate grievances and more willing to use violence. 🤔
 
But something like 800,000 Arabic Jews were expelled or fled from surrounding Arabic countries to Israel in the 1950s and these Jews aren't massacring the citizens of those countries.
This point has been made several times throughout the course of this thread and it just falls on deaf ears every time - I posted a video of that Israeli tour guide who does a good job of going over some of that history. There's certain pieces of information and history that should perhaps cause one to re-evaluate their position somewhat, but when it comes to the topic of Jews it just falls on deaf ears.
The Jews had taken control over a lot of property in Germany. Banks were owned by them, big businesses, so the people already didn't like them much. Often because as a German in 1930, it was hard to get a job, because many Jewish employees wouldn't employ Germans. Hyperinflation. So the Nazis made full use of the people's dislike and turned it into hate using LeBon's methods. Masses do not think! No matter how intelligent individuals in said masses are.
If you want to understand Muslim pain, you have to understand what we did to them. And not just what happened in the last 70 years. Look at medieval Europe, at Southern Spain and Southern Italy, look at the crusades, our systematic eradication of their fate.

The situation in Israel is so bad, because we are talking about centuries of pain that flow in the Muslim Zeitgeist.
Jew hatred and persecution has been a continuing theme for over 2000 years. Do you want to factor that into your understanding of Jewish pain and why perhaps they might have gravitated naturally towards the idea of Zionism in the first place, as a means to escape being continually shat on by just about everyone?

You can't seriously expect to sell the idea of 'Muslim pain' when Islam has been the direct cause of some 200+ million deaths down through history, as they attempted to spread their religious-political system across the world. What about the all the pain they caused as a result of their stupid religion. Sorry, but I don't have much sympathy at all and you're not going to sell me on that idea - just as any Catholic would fail to sell me any sob story about their bastard religion either.

The irony in all of this is that today it's so easy for people to gravitate towards a Jewish world conspiracy, yet it is the Catholic's and the Muslim's who are the only ones who have actually attempted a global land grab and actually butchered millions of people in the process. Jews have been treated like utter dogshit the entire time, from Rome right up until the present day.
 
I guess this is happening but it seems like it won't amount to much



The most significant aspect of the work of the International Court of Justice is that they have absolutely no enforcement powers other than the ability to negotiate the reparations required for agreement non-compliance
 
Yeah, don't ask silly questions ...
They are all silly questions; just believe ...
You don't have permission to disagree ...

Is this some kind of cynical take on peer pressure? Both teams do that.

No team is the right team. The situation is that simple and that happy. Gotta be ready for when it happens. There's a feast going on.

If you wanna do cynical takes on peer pressure, you cannot take sides in this dumb ass conflict.
 
Is this some kind of cynical take on peer pressure? Both teams do that.

No team is the right team. The situation is that simple and that happy. Gotta be ready for when it happens. There's a feast going on.

If you wanna do cynical takes on peer pressure, you cannot take sides in this dumb ass conflict.
@Mjall has spoken !

We must now all obey !
 
You are absolutely free to believe anything you wish.
Please note that this does not mean it is actually true, however ...

I guess that's an expression of a desire to write vaguely provocative stuff and not have it be exposed to any attempts at interpretation.

But i may be wrong, as always :)
 
I guess that's an expression of a desire to write vaguely provocative stuff and not have it be exposed to any attempts at interpretation.

But i may be wrong, as always :)

If that's what you wish to believe, who am I to stop you?
 
As of December 30 2023 Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor estimated Gaza Strip deaths as 30,034 total and civilian deaths at 27,681 which would mean about 2,353 militant deaths.

9% military deaths, rest is civilian

edit: sorry 8%

and they got their numbers directly from......

wait for it.....

the Hamas controlled Gaza health ministry.

There have been zero independently verified casualty numbers released. We may have some inflated estimate of total death count, but absolutely nothing that resembles a reliable, authenticated delineation of true civilians killed. And to be frank I doubt that we ever will. Because Hamas fighters/ Hamas sympathizers who chose to stay and fight do not carry any inherent markers to identify them as such.

Israel attempted to evacuate as many civilians as they could before the major campaign began. Hamas did everything they could to keep them there, knowing that a high death count hurts Israel on the world stage. It provides them cover in many ways and is an all around net plus for them.
 
It’s clear what’s happened is wrong but people are too committed to their arguments to back down.
Civilian death toll is too high to be accidental or collateral.
Gaza is not going to exist and the humanitarian crisis will worsen.
Sad to see that anyone is t condemning their actions
 
The driving of Palestinians from their land in 1948 is a fact and not a good one, although it was often done less with force and more with coercion (although violence and murder were indeed employed). But something like 800,000 Arabic Jews were expelled or fled from surrounding Arabic countries to Israel in the 1950s and these Jews aren't massacring the citizens of those countries. Clearly, it is possible to face historical injustice with something other than genocidal vengeance. As nearly every other group of people wronged in the past do today, except for some reason, the Palestinians.

It's almost like there is something 'special' in the culture of Palestinians that makes them less willing to moderate the manifestation of their legitimate grievances and more willing to use violence. 🤔
Um yeah that's Muslim culture in general, or what we turned it into:

Never forget that this war has been going on since the first Crusade. Actually even sooner than that

The Palestinians, or Arabs in general, never really had a chance to become more down to earth. We keep murdering them in the tens/hundreds of thousands. So you have to excuse them when they want to kill infidels. Infidels keep killing them and taking their land. Also infidels occupied the fucking Holy Land. Do you not understand how important that is to them? They owned it for 1300-1500 years dude. It's their friggin Holy Land. And they were kicked out of it

It's pretty self-explanatory. And you can't really dumb it down like this. Are we not doing genocides? Did the Americans not slaughter 99% of Native Americans? Did Germany not kill millions of Jews? Am I imagining the Armenian genocide? Did NATO not bomb Yugoslavia? Didn't America attack Iraq, Iran and Afghanistan, killing over half a million civilians? You know just because we don't call what we do genocides, doesn't mean other countries don't think so. As of December 30th, Israel killed 22,000 CIVILIAN Palestinians in 2023. Only 8% of killings were militant deaths. But the West is never going to call it a genocide.

So you see, even us, who pretend to be extremely "just" (what a joke) and want to paint ourselves as the good guys: we kill millions.
So why should anyone else not do the same thing? We lead by example

I'm not sure where your data comes from: but there are genocides everywhere, to this day.


honestly: You seem to have a set opinion, and you already seem to think worse of Arabs.
So I'm not trying to change it. Think whatever, but you're wrong, just saying.

There is nothing different about Arab culture - only that we keep pointing the finger and telling everyone how backwards they are, and how evil they are,
so we wont complain when our governments kill another hundred thousand of them.

And if you think a culture does not develop pure hatred after being buttraped by us for 1300 years, you are absolutely delusional. Sorry.
HOW should they be down to earth? We keep killing them ffs. Or funding terrorists in their countries (thanks for that US)
I can 100% understand Arab hate for us. Also we're talking just extremist Muslims like Hamas. That's a tiny percentile of Arabs, not even 1%.
Yet we keep killing their civilians.

You cannot compare this to Christianity, that has been living in complete safety, protected by the Pontifikat.
But even if you did: O we killed so fucking many people in the name of Jesus. So fucking many people. Mostly Muslims.
Holy Wars we called our Crusades. See we were exactly alike once.

edit: Just as I said in another post. I realize that Arabs are not people to many of us in the West.
We just don't want to understand them, because we feel superior. We feel more just, we feel like we are better people by default.
So every man, every woman, every child of them is evil, and it's fine to kill them and try wiping out their religion.
How are we different dude? Because our governments have to lie to make their genocides happen? So?
We still see it happening, and we've seen it happening for 70 years in the Middle East. Are any of us complaining?
Maybe 5% if we're lucky.

All this talk about inclusion, be nice to everyone: no shit
But Arabs can fucking eat shit apparently. They are inherently evil, or so said God to George Bush
And he wasn't even tested for his sanity, after he received an order from inside his head.
Na people were like "...well if God said so, I guess we just have to attack Iraq.."
How are we different? How do we not kill people over nothing?

Iraq had NOTHING to do with 9/11. Iran had NOTHING to do with 9/11. Afghanistan had NOTHING to do with 9/11.
The money and 9 or 10 of the terrorists for 9/11 came from Saudi. But US doesn't wanna attack Saudi, it's much too influential and powerful in the world.

Did ANYONE say a word that we attacked the wrong Muslims? Or that murdering millions over 3000 people is wrong? Just a very select few. The rest was OK with it, apparently.
How are we different? How do we not kill people over their faith?

We're fucking two-faced, the entire West.

It's no wonder that BRICS' power is rising. It's going to be the entire world against the West in the end. Arab countries are flocking to BRICS, no fucking wonder.
Countries everywhere in the entire World are coming to BRICS. No fucking wonder - do you even know what we DID over the years? We made China addicted to Opium. We occupied a powerful Empire like India. We coerced Jeltzin to dissolve the USSR. In fact we tried destroying every Empire we ever came across. We're in no way innocent in the destruction of the Osmanian Empire either. We split Korea. Vietnam is in a dictatorship. We enslaved people everywhere in the world. We led dozens of Crusades against Muslims and other religions (like Asatru, Paganism everywhere). We had a genocide against Native Americans and stole their lands.
Maybe we will even have parts of the West against the West - never be too sure about Europe as an ally of "the West"/NATO - there's a lot of anger between many European countries and the US too. All this manipulation they've been doing in the EU. Especially the "fuck the EU coup" in Ukraine 2014 by Victoria Nuland and company.

We're the bad guys. I know a lot of us don't want to believe that, but that's what's up.
Yeah we wonder all about how they can be so extremist? Well maybe if we had tried diplomacy instead of backstabbing and murdering over the years, maybe we'd live in an entirely different world.
We will never know, because we rather make China addicted to Opium, and then point the finger that their government is fucked up. We rather split Korea, and then point the finger that North Korea is fucked up. We coerce and promise and backstab to dissolve the USSR, and then we point the finger that Russia is weak.

Weak maybe, but those "weaklings" held and pushed back the German main front, and won WW2 for Europe. They have fucking amazing soldiers.
And they're fucking angry that the US claims they won WW2, which is just a fucking lie, and also that they're seen as enemies even after all this time.
The only country that was thankful towards Russia after they let us unite, was Germany. We still love them for that.

They let us unite for a promise, which NATO broke only 10 years later.

We're 100% the bad guys, no questions about it. Our governments at least.
 
Last edited:
Jew hatred and persecution has been a continuing theme for over 2000 years. Do you want to factor that into your understanding of Jewish pain and why perhaps they might have gravitated naturally towards the idea of Zionism in the first place, as a means to escape being continually shat on by just about everyone?

You can't seriously expect to sell the idea of 'Muslim pain' when Islam has been the direct cause of some 200+ million deaths down through history, as they attempted to spread their religious-political system across the world. What about the all the pain they caused as a result of their stupid religion. Sorry, but I don't have much sympathy at all and you're not going to sell me on that idea - just as any Catholic would fail to sell me any sob story about their bastard religion either.

The irony in all of this is that today it's so easy for people to gravitate towards a Jewish world conspiracy, yet it is the Catholic's and the Muslim's who are the only ones who have actually attempted a global land grab and actually butchered millions of people in the process. Jews have been treated like utter dogshit the entire time, from Rome right up until the present day.
We're not talking about the same Jews here. We're talking about a Jewish tribe of SLAVIC origin, that just converted - because some leader said so in the 1500s or so.
They were never fucking persecuted, as i recall. That's who the Germans killed. Most lived in Poland. They were Polish.

Also Catholicism ate 200 million deaths for breakfast
Seriously. 200 million is nothing. And is that counting our failed crusades to try and take the Holy Land back? And our failed crusades against Southern Spain? And our failed crusades against Sicily?
And our failed crusades against northern African countries? And our failed crusades in the Middle East? Like when is this starting to count? Year 0? We killed more. A lot more.

We were EXACTLY like them in feudal times. And we spread like wildfire. And we took SO MUCH gold. Visit any church in Europe, be it in the SMALLEST fucking 5-house cow village. I promise the church still is filled with tons of gold. That's the only proof you really need to know what our crusades were about and how much we took from other cultures. We sure as fuck don't have goldmines here.

And hands down, the Catholic Church is still in charge to a large degree. It's still spreading in Africa through Missionaries. Because help usually doesn't come without Christians.
Same for any country in need really. I know you want food, but have you heard of Jesus?

Also - you don't know many Muslims huh? You're all talking about extremist Muslims like they're EVERY Muslim alive. That's a fucking lie. These extremist Islamists are just a tiny percentile of Muslims, I'd be surprised if it was much higher than 1% of Muslim people.
I know a shitload of Muslims, especially because so many Turkish people live here, and I've never met one I'd have considered extremist.

They are just people. A big part of their faith is very beautiful. There is a lot of wisdom and beauty in the Quran. And their faith is as stupid as any faith.
It's just what your government tells you, so you don't feel bad about them killing over half a million of their civilians in 20 years. And what did the millions of soldiers that died do exactly?
They didn't do nothing. They didn't cause 9/11. What's anyone in Iraq, Iran and Afghanistan got to do with that exactly?
The money was Saudi. The terrorists were Saudi. O but US does not have the balls to attack Saudi, it's too influential. So they just attack any Muslim country and say God wanted it, hoping their people wont know the difference - and ofc they didn't.

Sure in the end we should all just pray to the sun, because we know it gives us life, and there would be no discussion whether it exists or not.

I also in no word said Israel is in the wrong here. Israel got a gift of their Holy Land. Ofc they accepted.
Israel thought they would have peace there, they didn't do anything - they just tried to do agriculture.
4 countries declared war on them when they moved there. People were killed, fields burned, women raped by a small extremist part of their Arab population.

I'm saying WE the West were in the wrong to decide what happens to the Holy Land.
The situation in Israel/Palestine is gruesome and fucking terrible, and has been for 70 years, but there is no right side or wrong side to pick for us Westerners.

There are two sides that were played against each other. And then there's colonialist asshole side. That's us in the West.

We preach peace and deal in wars

I'm just trying to give people some sympathy for both sides. Because BOTH sides had terrible things happen to them, and BOTH sides DID terrible things. But especially to Arabs because they get 0 love in the West. Most are just normal people ffs. We declare an entire culture as evil because a small percentile of them are extremist - and then are surprised that more of them become extremist after we bomb their countries? We as the collective West always give 2 fucks about Arab culture, and I tell you this is going to bite us in the ass one day. It almost did when ISIS agents came to Europe in 2017
 
and they got their numbers directly from......

wait for it.....

the Hamas controlled Gaza health ministry.

There have been zero independently verified casualty numbers released. We may have some inflated estimate of total death count, but absolutely nothing that resembles a reliable, authenticated delineation of true civilians killed. And to be frank I doubt that we ever will. Because Hamas fighters/ Hamas sympathizers who chose to stay and fight do not carry any inherent markers to identify them as such.

Israel attempted to evacuate as many civilians as they could before the major campaign began. Hamas did everything they could to keep them there, knowing that a high death count hurts Israel on the world stage. It provides them cover in many ways and is an all around net plus for them.
ah yes i forgot they use bombs that cannot harm civilians.

When you bomb an area as small as the Gaza, you can just bomb AROUND the civilians, that must be it.

Since the Gaza health ministry is controlled by Hamas it has not once lied about the casualties.

Not in 2008

not anywhen else. Always pretty much the same number as UN reports. Why should they lie now?

also not even Israel doubts that, where do you get that from? The Israeli official they asked when the Gaza health ministry claimed 15,000 dead said the numbers were "more or less" correct.
 
Last edited:
ah yes i forgot they use bombs that cannot harm civilians.

When you bomb an area as small as the Gaza, you can just bomb AROUND the civilians, that must be it.
Round and round we go in a circle as the goalpost is shifted for the sake of argument. Hamas uses civilians as Human Shields so that they can garner as much support as possible. Don't you remember this discussion ?
Thus we should agree to disagree. You do agree that this thread is extremely unlikely to solve the problem, right? How many times around the hamster wheel do we have to go?
 
When you bomb an area as small as the Gaza, you can just bomb AROUND the civilians, that must be it.

You are deliberately ignoring the fact that I just told you they attempted to evacuate the civilians. If they had all been allowed to leave there would have been far fewer casualties .

not anywhen else. Always pretty much the same number as UN reports. Why should they lie now?

Because this was their biggest attack on Israel yet and they knew it would provoke a huge response. They knew it would dominate the news cycle for months or years, not days as with previous skirmishes. Their primary method of defense is to control the narrative and disseminate propaganda as needed. Both sides do it to some degree, but only Hamas is willing to sacrifice their people to gain a bit of PR.

You can just say "same number" and be done. The number needs details. I want to know exactly how many women and children were killed so that I'll know how many innocent dead to add to Hamas' death count. Then I want to know the ages of the children. Are they counting 17 and 18 year old males as children ? I suspect they start recruiting well before that.

Then finally I want proof that no dead terrorists are being lumped in with the "civilian death counts". But we know there are. If there were actually 23,000 dead women, babies, and innocents Hamas would have released video by now of the bodies piled up. I've seen many videos of tragic deaths that have taken place. But nothing that suggests a rate of death anywhere near the reported numbers.

Also, I want the group doing this analysis to be impartial and do a true accounting of the facts. That means it can't be the UN or most of the other "humanitarian" groups that exist there. I actually just laughed as I typed out humanitarian.
 
I'm just trying to give people some sympathy for both sides. Because BOTH sides had terrible things happen to them, and BOTH sides DID terrible things. But especially to Arabs because they get 0 love in the West. Most are just normal people ffs. We declare an entire culture as evil because a small percentile of them are extremist - and then are surprised that more of them become extremist after we bomb their countries? We as the collective West always give 2 fucks about Arab culture, and I tell you this is going to bite us in the ass one day. It almost did when ISIS agents came to Europe in 2017
No one says they are all evil, no one chooses where they are born. On the same token, don't pretend for one second there aren't multiple Islamic dominated countries that are completely fucking bonkers, we can all see it with our own eyes thank you very much. And they were that way before the Anglo-American establishment started playing games. Long before.

You're trying to paint a disingenuous picture that it is all the West's fault for the way things are in that part of the world, which is just nonsense. Islam has been bonkers long before the Anglo empire even came into being.

And why should we give a fuck about Arab culture? We're not obliged to, and they certainly don't give a fuck about our culture. It's been demonstrated quite clearly in the UK, France, and elsewhere, just what they think of non-Islamic cultures. You give an inch and they take a mile. So stop with the bullshit accusations against the West, these people would have taken the piss regardless of what the West has done. The Islamic religion leaves the door wide open for it, it doesn't need anyone else to push them through it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top