Is New York's supersize soda ban a civil rights issue?

slimvictor

Bluelight Crew
Joined
Dec 29, 2008
Messages
6,477
Location
"Darkness cannot be dissipated with more darkness.
New York City's ban on large-size sodas and other sugary drinks is being challenged by African American and Hispanic groups. How did cola become a civil rights issue?

When Martin Luther King told crowds of idealistic demonstrators he had a dream, it's unlikely that the right to sell soft beverages greater than 16oz (0.5 litre) was part of his vision.

But his heirs in the US minority civil rights movement have taken up opposition to a ban on supersize sodas as their latest crusade.

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg has called for the ban as a way to reduce obesity and its related health problems.

But it is being challenged in court by a coalition of bodies including the New York State wing of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), best known for its battles against segregation and discrimination.

Also supporting the action is the Hispanic Federation, a network of 100 Latino organisations.

Both groups say the ban will disproportionately affect soda sales in bodegas, or independent convenience stores, which tend to be owned and run by minorities.

Supermarkets and many convenience store chains such as 7-Eleven - home of a supersize beverage known as the Big Gulp - are not subject to city health regulations.

Hazel N Dukes, president of the NAACP New York State Conference, said the movement's stand was about "basic economic fairness".

"As the new rules stand, small mom and pop stores in the city, which are disproportionately owned and operated by people of colour, must comply with the law and suffer the financial consequences," she said.

"Meanwhile, national chains like 7-Eleven, which can handle the financial loss, are exempt. You can't be serious about banning big sodas when you have a loophole for Big Gulps."

cont at
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-21201680
 
I did a speech on this for one of my classes right after the ban was voted on. Basically made all the same points.

You can't "cure" obesity by banning large sodas, just like you can't stop drug use by making drugs illegal. You need to educate people. And while I agree that portion sizes are fucking insane in the US (and especially in NYC), that does no harm if people are properly educated. I go to restaurants and only eat half my meal because I'm educated. Some people aren't and that's unfortunate, but telling them "no large sodas" does nothing to solve the problem. They can still buy a 16 oz soda and get as many free refills as they want.
 
^ Isn't the problem that some people are being educated by the portion sizes?

I agree that education, not legislation, is the solution to a problem like this. That said, people's perceptions of what is normal are influenced by what they see every day. A store that sells sodas in 8 oz, 12 oz, and 16 oz sizes is sending a different message than a store that sells 8 oz, 12 oz, 16 oz, and 20 oz sodas. Just by offering the larger size, the store says "It's okay to drink this much, and even to get a refill."

Of course the measure does fuck all if 7-11 is exempt.
 
Top