There's nothing like a sense of humor. This doesn't mean be an ass to others to try to get a laugh at their expense. Finding the irony in situations, self-deprecation (NOT to be confused with self-pity). This, combined with a dose of humility...greatness
+1 this... a thousand times, this!
Believe me, brother, I'm not the best-looking guy in the world -- not the worst-looking guy either, but, you know, pretty average. Anyway, I can get women, and I don't mean to sound too full of myself or cocky because, in truth, I actually have very low self-esteem, but it's the truth. I can get women, all kinds of women, women with boyfriends, even, and women with fiancés.
I would say that, to get women, you've got to be slick, suave, witty, and
funny. It shouldn't come across as being forced, contrived, or as though you're trying too hard. If you've got nothing witty or clever to say, then don't say anything as you'll more than likely say something stupid (has happened to me on more than one occasion and I
hate foot-in-mouth moments); but if you
do think of something, then go ahead and say it!
You might have a different sense of humor than others, and I can understand that, but give it a try. My sense of humor is basically this: leave no stone unturned. My sense of humor can be dry, it can be sarcastic, it can be real quirky and silly, or it can be real dirty, offensive and dark. Throw in a bit of everything, and see what the girls seem to respond to.
I've never been a pickup line sort of guy, but I used to joke with girls by telling them that they look tired of standing and I'd clear them a seat (then I'd take off my glasses, stick out my face and sort of brush away the invisible crumbs with my fingers) Give that a try lol