I know it's a religious thing for male circumsision in particular but given my views on religion that really doesn't make much difference to me. Just another example of why religion is backwards and barbaric..
Erm, I think you've misunderstood my post entirely. My argument is actually that it's
not always purely religious or cultural in nature. I think the majority of circumcisions aren't done on religious grounds; check out America, for example. Or even the UK, where it's been standard procedure in some hospitals before, regardless of religion.
What I'm saying is that female genital mutilation ('circumcision' is a complete misnomer and perpetuates people equating the two very distinct practices) is entirely motivated by a desire to suppress female sexuality and has no other benefits. Granted, the modern popularity of the male procedure may hark back to nineteenth century sexual puritanism, but it's essentially a harmless operation if everything goes to plan.
Male circumcision, when properly carried out, reduces the likelihood of prostate cancer and a whole host of infections. Crucially, it leaves the penis entirely intact and functional. In many cases the operation is performed to overcome health complications rather than in any religious context. I should know - I had it done because of inflammation of the glans.
I can see why men might find it a frightening prospect, and I can see the arguments against coercion of those too young to make a decision. But male and female 'circumcision' being the same, or even remotely similar beyond the fact they're both popularly referred to as 'circumcision'? Big 'nah' I'm afraid.
Smacks of phallus-worship to me, though it's amusing to see how exercised people can get about a (usually smelly) flap of skin.
Shambles said:
Women I've known have always professed to prefer intact todgers... but am guessing there may be a certain amount of tailoring of opinions dependent on state of current penis.
Too right. It's not as if somebody's going to turn to me in the middle of fellatio and announce "I really wish you had a foreskin" is it?
Though I really don't think it's much of a factor with most penis-lovers, as long as it's kept clean.