You guys would all take the methadone? I'd take the suboxone. 40mg of sub vs 130mg of methadone? I feel like 130mg of methadone is not exactly a lot to use to detox, although perhaps thats wrong; ive never use methadone for any purposes (detox, maintenance, high, etc) and have only used suboxone or tapers of other drugs (oxy, morphine, tramadol as well, you all get it).
Anyway, I'd take the sub. I'd do (dosage daily):
8, 8, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, 1, .5, .5, then finally end it all with .25 for 4 days.
I think this would work better than the 'done.
Edit; though to be honest, after reading a bit more, I think your best bet is long term medication assisted therapy. Try and get into a methadone clinic man, or a daily script of suboxone. I think long term this will solve a lot of the problems you are having (staying clean; on sub every day? you got no choice. same w/ 'done for the most part), allow you to save money and move on with your life without having to suffer the withdrawals (yet).
but be warned man everyones gonna have to go through them in some form (mental or physical) before the games over; you dont get to check in without checking out. Everyone else who has kicked has done it, why do you think you are any different? Why think you cant do it? Youre not special, youre just like every other addict who kicks: you got hooked and you can get clean. Youre not just special that you can get hooked but not clean, you can do both
Even the medication assisted treatments you still gotta overcome the mental aspect: you said youve quit the methadone before, correct? But you can overcome that obstacle; you can if for no other reason than like i've said: every other addict whos gone down that road has, why would you be different?