-
DPMC Moderators: tryptakid
Drug users should not go to jail - BBC Question Time - 26/01/11
- Thread starter lynx2051
- Start date
edgarshade
Bluelighter
I've been hearing this line about the success of Portugal being based on a flawed report quite a lot recently. Looks like the audience lapped it up judging by how much they were clapping. Anyone know what the real stats are and how reliable? I can't help thinking that if Portugal has seen such bad results as claimed then why haven't they reversed the law in the last decade?
Edit: I found some background on this...
http://laiglesforum.com/cato-portugal-drug-study-based-on-false-government-data/2602.htm
It seems the "flawed" report is the Cato report. The "flaw" is the perceived libertarian agenda of Cato. Would be good to get a wider picture on this. Are there other reports on Portugal that show the same results as the Cato report?
Edit: I found some background on this...
http://laiglesforum.com/cato-portugal-drug-study-based-on-false-government-data/2602.htm
It seems the "flawed" report is the Cato report. The "flaw" is the perceived libertarian agenda of Cato. Would be good to get a wider picture on this. Are there other reports on Portugal that show the same results as the Cato report?
Last edited:
23536
Bluelight Crew
^I haven't read any of this, but here's another analysis (fairly long PDF):
http://www.beckleyfoundation.org/bib/doc/bf/2010_Caitlin_211621_1.pdf
http://www.beckleyfoundation.org/bib/doc/bf/2010_Caitlin_211621_1.pdf
edgarshade
Bluelighter
That seems to be quite a balanced report from a reputable source. I can see how the figures can be twisted by the DM when the general increase in drug use in the EU isn't taken into account.
As for the rest of that DM reporter's rant. She was saying there is a "trillion dollar" campaign for drug legalisation? Trillion dollars? Someone, somewhere has more money than any organisation or individual in the world and they are clearly not getting their money's worth??? And the usual "someone's been spreading dangerous ideas!", which is kind of rich coming from an industry that supposedly values free speech so highly. The message seems to be that legalisation is so "bonkers" that it's a crime just to mention it.
I still don't know why she got so much applause when most of the questions and statements from the audience were clearly in favour of Richard Branson.
As for the rest of that DM reporter's rant. She was saying there is a "trillion dollar" campaign for drug legalisation? Trillion dollars? Someone, somewhere has more money than any organisation or individual in the world and they are clearly not getting their money's worth??? And the usual "someone's been spreading dangerous ideas!", which is kind of rich coming from an industry that supposedly values free speech so highly. The message seems to be that legalisation is so "bonkers" that it's a crime just to mention it.
I still don't know why she got so much applause when most of the questions and statements from the audience were clearly in favour of Richard Branson.