My experience is that the body can handle very large amounts of paracetamol and ibuprofen over long periods (eg 10,000 mg ibuprofen daily for years), with no significant damage.
Some people take lower doses and do end up with hepatic and/or renal damage, so not exactly sure how that works except that I suspect that if you start low and build up that your liver develops an affinity for dealing with the load, but thats a personal theory.
While the toxicity profile for ibuprofen has a fairly gentle dose response for
most people, and relatively speaking, for those people it's probably not so harmful in doses slightly higher than those recommended, it's still unwise to suggest 10 grams a day may be within a safe theraputic index. It's certainly not IMO.
With paracetamol, unless you have a way of assessing your liver, then you may not know if damage occurs until it's too late. It's also incorrect to think the enzymes involved in 'regular' low dose metabolism of acetaminophen can increase in density to allow large amounts of acetaminophen to be safely metabolised. Increased density of enzymes involved in conjugation (safe metabolic route) is unlikely to occur in response to repeated administration. Glutathione, which must be present if liver damage is to be avoided, is not stored in the liver in sufficient quantities to cope with large doses.
Let's review what happens in low and high dose metabolism of acetaminophen.
Referring to diagram 1; If the dose is within a safe therapeutic index, all the acetaminophen will be metabolised without employing p450 isozymes. The products are either the conjugated sulphate (route 1) or the glucuronide (route 2), both quite "safe" metabolic products. However, these metabolic routes are dependant on, among other things, enzyme availability. The body can't instantly produce more of these enzymes in response to increased demand as seen with high doses of acetaminophen.
If the dose is high, and the enzymes required for conjugation become saturated, p450 (CYP) cytochromes (aka mixed function oxidases) will become involved (route 3). These will produce N-acetyl-beta-benzoquinone imine (NAPBQ), an extremely reactive intermediate. If glutathione (GSH) is not depleted, some of this NAPBQ will end up conjugated with it, which, if the dose is high enough will lead to further GSH depletion. Most importantly, significant amounts of the toxic imine will react with cellular membranes, resulting in the destruction of cells. Other processes also occur (see fig 2) which cause cellular death, including oxidative products resulting from glutathione depletion.
Figure 1:Adapted from Rang et al, Pharmacology 4th Edition
Figure 2: from Rang et al, Pharmacology 4th Edition, p763
E medicine: Excerpt from Toxicity, Acetaminophen
Excerpt from Toxicity, Acetaminophen
Synonyms, Key Words, and Related Terms: paracetamol, N-acetyl-p-aminophenol, APAP
Toxicity, Acetaminophen
Background: Acetaminophen is the most widely used pharmaceutical analgesic and antipyretic agent in the United States and the world; it is contained in more than 100 products. As such, acetaminophen is one of the most common pharmaceuticals associated with both intentional and accidental poisoning.
Acetaminophen-induced hepatotoxicity is well recognized. Acetaminophen also is known as paracetamol and N-acetyl-p-aminophenol (APAP). It is found in the United States as 325-mg and 500-mg immediate-release tablets and as a 650-mg extended-release preparation. Various children's chewable, suspension, and elixir formulations of acetaminophen also are available. Furthermore, acetaminophen is found as a component of combination drugs such as propoxyphene-acetaminophen (eg, Darvocet) and oxycodone-acetaminophen (eg, Percocet).
Pathophysiology: The maximum daily dose of APAP is 4 g in adults and 90 mg/kg in children. The toxic dose of APAP after a single acute ingestion is 150 mg/kg or approximately 7 g in adults, although the at-risk dose may be lower in persons with alcoholism and other susceptible individuals. When dosing recommendations are followed, the risk of hepatotoxicity is extremely small.
Acetaminophen is rapidly absorbed from the stomach and small intestine and metabolized by conjugation in the liver to nontoxic agents, which then are eliminated in the urine.
In acute overdose or when maximum daily dose is exceeded over a prolonged period, the normal pathways of metabolism become saturated. Excess APAP is then metabolized in the liver via the mixed function oxidase P450 system to a toxic metabolite, N-acetyl-p-benzoquinone-imine (NAPQI). NAPQI has an extremely short half-life and is rapidly conjugated with glutathione, a sulfhydryl donor, and removed from the system. Under conditions of excessive NAPQI formation or reduced glutathione stores, NAPQI is free to covalently bind to vital proteins and the lipid bilayer of hepatocytes; this results in hepatocellular death and subsequent centrilobular liver necrosis.
The antidote for APAP poisoning is N-acetylcysteine (NAC). NAC is theorized to work by a number of protective mechanisms. Early after overdose, NAC prevents the formation and accumulation of NAPQI. NAC increases glutathione stores, combines directly with NAPQI as a glutathione substitute, and enhances sulfate conjugation. NAC also functions as an anti-inflammatory and antioxidant and has positive inotropic and vasodilating effects, which improve microcirculatory blood flow and oxygen delivery to tissues. Vasodilating effects decrease morbidity and mortality once hepatotoxicity is well established.
NAC is most effective when administered within 8 hours of ingestion. When indicated, however, NAC should be administered regardless of time since the overdose. Therapy with NAC has been shown to decrease mortality rates in late-presenting patients with fulminant hepatic failure (in the absence of acetaminophen in the serum).
In regards to the extent and degree of reported Acetaminophen poisonings:
From The management of poisoning by Pharmaceutical Agents
- Paracetamol poisoning accounts for 48% of hospital admissions for poisoning and approx 200 deaths every year in the UK (Hawton et al, 1998)
- It is the commonest reason for transplantation for acute liver failure in the UK (Bernal and Wendon 1999)
The E-medicine quote refers to N-acetylcysteine (NAC) as being an antidote for Acetaminophen poisonings, but IMO it would need to be administered shortly after overdose has occurred if damage is to be largely avoided. Iirc it also has to be injected intravenously. Methionine can be taken orally, but I don't know how fast methionine would restore levels of glutathione. However, in identifying these antidotes, pre/post loading should not be seen as a green light to take higher dosages. There are also other toxicity concerns, particularly in regards to the nephrotoxicity (kidneys). It's something that doesn't often get a mention, but it's reported as common in long term user or as a result of overdose. Think very carefully if you use large amounts of paracetamol. That's why, despite the arguable increased risk of addiction, I recommend removal of the acetaminophen via CWE if intent is to take large doses of codeine.