It was definitely not directed at you, I edited my post to prevent this misunderstanding but seems I was too late. I understand your opinion on my general attitude, and I probably would feel the same if I saw someone else do it.
However, let me give you a few reasons why I do it - not necessarily good reasons:
- I honestly am irritated by people trying to give advice when it literally only takes 5 seconds on Google to see that they are saying something that does not make sense.
- Follows from above reason: It is not harm reduction if you give someone crappy advice or come with information that is blatantly wrong, in some situations it is even the opposite.
- I work at an institute were it is accepted to interact with each other in this way. Perhaps it comes off as more violent through the Internet, but we have a good working climate here, were you can point out to someone they should not make decisions on something they don't know anything about.
- Probably, I am just a bit arrogant and need some affirmation that my contribution is valued. I spend a lot of time on the questions I do answer, and though it would be extra karma if it was all altruistic by nature, deep down inside I guess I need some acknowledgement.
- I am hungover from yesterday.
If you have seen the other threads in which I have acted this way, you will probably also have noticed that usually the tone gets better once the discussion is developing. That said, I will work on not doing this anymore when it's not appropriate.
Fair enough?
EDIT: I have read a lot of your contributions too, so I would never start a flame war with you.