Philoscybin said:
He doesn't HAVE TO use anything. Benzos are usually RXed for a short term and the withdrawal effects are a bitch.
He sure as hell doesn't "have to", but regarding the issue of whether or not he should, that question cannot be answered.
However, I am siding with fastandbulbous on this issue; I thought your first remark was simply rude, placing every preceding post into one lump category of idiots crying out "eat mushrooms and feel better! Shoot heroin and feel better!" when this was quite obviously NOT the case. You should have simply stated your message more clearly, and this whole argument would never have arisen, leading to the affair at hand being more acutely addressed. Either way, I can see the issue from both yours and F+B's points of view, but the point of arguing is ultimately moot. The argument is a digression from what, I'm sure, the original poster wanted; that is, a direct and simple answer geared toward recovery. While I'm not sure one exists, fighting amongst other posters doesnt help clear the fog.
While some of the above responses may not be the wisest to grace this particular thread, and you most certainly have the right to point those out specifically, your comment appeared to lump all posts submitted prior to yours in the same category: Ignorant Advisement.
You simply cannot make inferences as to someone's mental past (regarding clinically diagnosed depression, specifically) due to giving bad advice on the subject over the internet, as you do when you say that someone has "clearly never experienced clinical depression if they offer advice such as take mushrooms". Your point would have been more suitable, had it said that the advice given from those over the internet is a far cry from what a professional doctor could give you, instead of lumping a group of contributors into a single mass of proclaimed idiocy. At least, thats what it felt like, and I do hope you respect my stance on this issue.
Regarding benzodiazepine medications, my benzodiazepine recommendation was indeed a temporary solution to his problems. I even mentioned that he should try
not to get addicted to the things; however, Xanax's anxiolytic properties may help his mind calm itself down enough to
rationally support the idea of a future, non drug-induced mental rehabilitation, and it's not an illicit substance, which may be the most important factor in all of this.
Now. Back on the subject... please.
I
do know what this poster is going through, and I wish to help him. Snide remarks do nothing but contribute to the degredation of the support certain other individuals are trying to offer to him - aside from the mere mention of a recreational drug he may or may not find "fun enough" to make him love life a little bit more.
Peace.
And again, best wishes to the original poster. Times can be tough, but with assistance, and with the assistance of fellow human beings primarily, I believe you can and will make it.
PM me if you wish to converse further. This thread itself seems to be leading to disaster.
-Vaya
P.S. - Fastandbulbous - one point of yours I simply must refute is the efficacy of SSRI-based medications. I have had enough experience with them, and have given them enough consideration(time spent on said medications), as well as had the very same conversations with countless acquaintences in the same situations. I believe SSRI's can benefit only a very SELECT few individuals. PM me if you want to discuss this further. - V