I'm totally neutral too
Brady might be better due to SB wins, but I would also say the rest of his team has contributed GREATLY to his successes. when have the Colts ever had a good defense? they did have Mike Doss and Sanders playing safety at the same time, once, but they both were irreverent due to injuries. most of the time, the Colts run game is laughable at best
and I think this Patriots D is bad argument should be thrown out the window. sure, they sucked at first, but now they are pretty good. the unit as a whole is improving every game. sure, it is rookie-laden, but most of these guys were studs in big-name colleges. the Pats defensive unit actually reminds me of the defensive units of the Pats in their first SB season, a lot of lesser known guys who got it together and started playing good team defense
if one would transplant Peyton Manning in a team like... the Pittsburgh Steelers, isn't it scary to think about how many rings the Steelers would have had?
I can't argue with Brady's stats this year. it would be foolish to say that Manning > Brady, when
only taking in account this year. Brady is MVP status while Manning has been throwing Pick 6s all over the place
overall, I would say that Manning is more skilled than Brady. when I watch Manning, I watch a magickal QB play the game truly like never before. he has taken no-name players into superstardom, when they become his WRs
sure, Brady did this to the likes of Deon Branch and now even Randy Moss (lol), but these guys were at least decent even without Brady (Moss doesn't count right now because Tenn is a mess with their QB). Brady's WRs may not be superb, but they are not anywhere close to bad
they're both elite QBs. I would still take Big Ben over them any day
