^if its been civil and on topic then I apologize. People reported it so I addressed it and admittedly didn't read a lot of the exchange between the two of you because you guys post a shitload.
On another note: for god's sakes, there is a huge difference between physical dependence and addiction. When someone is taking a necessary medicine for a medical condition then whether or not it produces dependence should be a non-issue.
I used narcotic analgesics for over 3 years daily, extended release pills with IR pills for BT pain for much of that and barely doubled my dose total in that time. This medication allowed me to work and go to school and lead a normal life after having to quit my job and leave school when the pain became unbearable. I was absolutely physically dependent and would have mild withdrawals if I stopped abruptly but there's no reason you need to stop abruptly when taking medication appropriately and therapeutically. This applies to maintenance medication as well.
Addiction is worlds apart from this... addiction hinders your ability to go to school, hold down a job and in general progress in life. Addiction has psychological and social components that physical dependence does not affect whatsoever.
After a lot of time living with chronic pain, I found other ways to manage it and made the decision to have a little more pain in my life then keep needing larger doses of narcotics for the rest of my life and I tapered off without a problem. Was I an addict? According to diagnostic criteria, absolutely not. My use of painkillers didn't interfere with my life, it allowed me to HAVE a life.
There isn't absolute consensus on why people experience PAWS but the general theory is that it is a combination of the physical and psychological effects that extended drug abuse cause. I was taking an average of 100-150mg of oral morphine or equivalent doses of other opioids daily for over 3 years straight and although not large doses compared to some, didn't have a trace of PAWS symptoms.
I believe that PAWS has more to do with the radical adjustment from numbing all of your problems with drugs to having to live with them daily. Its a major change to go from getting high all the time to trying to live life on LIFE's terms and for this reason I believe that PAWs, although having physical components and some causation, is far more psychological and why I think more than a slow taper off sub is necessary to address and mitigate the symptoms and give people a better chance at living a sober life and not relapsing.