mav3rick
Bluelighter
Volundr! Woahhhhh, that's some serious talent.. I LOVE the skull piece it'd be an amazingly complex tattoo to do haha..
Mav

haven't done anything productive since getting blunty rejected from some shitty pre-uni art course like 6 weeks ago..so yeah thanks a lot!
would anybody in here be interested in a thread to post art, with constructive criticizm, etc?
Ima say this in a way that i am trying to be as least dick-ish as possible.
But some of the things that i seen in these threads over the years get gushing compliments and tons of thumbs up, "OMG that is AMAZING!" when to be totally honest, they really aint, and really need a LOT of work.
I aint knocking nobodys appreciation or comments. I am just saying that a lot of times when you have people who aint educated about art or who aint got artistic skills of their own commenting on other peoples art, they tend to think the most basic, mediocre beginners-skill level of sketch is a masterpiece.
Its nice to hear positive shit no doubt. But when a person does a sketch that is kind of crappy, and they hear how great and awesome it is, it can have a negative effect on their art becuz they think , well if im so great then i dont need to improve. That sketch i made was awesome and everyone thinks its spectacular, I am pretty damn good!
When in reality the perspective was totally fucked, the shading was all over the place an the general quality of it was at the level of a 12-year old "introduction to drawing" student.
(And i aint saying that about any particular picture in here, so dont get me wrong, i am just using a made up example so dont think "oh, is she talkin about me?" I woulnt be that rude.)
to grow as a artist you need to hear when your shit sucks so you can learn how to improve. and that way when you DO get a compliment, its a REAL one, that really means something. When a person thinks everything they see that is slightly more talented than a stick figure is super-great, they may be a positive nice person who is just spreadin the love, and there aint nothing wrong with that--but they think EVERYTHING is great, so saying that artist A's picture is awesome really aint a comment on the actual quality of his or her work, its just that you think any and all art is awesome. You feel me, its like when a kid sucks at singing, and her mom tells her that her voice is beautiful and she is a excellent singer. It dont mean nothing at all, becuz her mom aint got the slightest clue about singing and is totally biased becuz its her kid, of course she will think its great becuz its her kid whose doin it. the kind of compliment that comes from a person who is ignorant about the subject is nice to hear and it aint a bad thing, its just that if a person is really actually tryin to grow in their talent and improve their work, givin them praise that they dont actually deserve just inflates their ego for no reason and makes them less likely to work hard at gettin better.
I aint criticizing nobody in here becuz i know this AINT a thread that is suppose to be for critiquing art an its just to share it with people. thats why i asked if anybody would be intereste in a thread that IS for that....Where people coul post their shit and get HONEST replies that aint afraid to say, hey, listen....that really needs alot of work, and i can help offer you suggestions on how you can improve it if you want me to help.
It wouldnt have to be negative and full of haters or nothin like that. constructive criticizm is important when you are a artist. If you are totally satisfied with somethin you made and just wanna share it, post it in here and get some love...but if you are interested in tryin to improve and see other peoples real opinions on the shit you make, you could post it in this other thread. I never see one little suggestion in this thread, not the smallest thing like , hey thats great, have you ever considered doing so and so becuz it might add to it and make it look better, or nothing like that. even a very kind, helpful totally non mean comment. Its so full of PLUR that somebody could post a picture of a triangle in here and people would comment about how much they love it and think its amazing.
like i said...that kind of environment is good for people who just want encouragement and praise, or who just like showin their work to others and sharing it and like the good vibes and loving atmosphere.
But if there is any serious artists who would be interested in postin and commentin in a thread that is more about constructive criticizm and makin helpful suggestions and posting honest opinions whether or not they are "nice", post back and let me know and maybe we can make a thread like that. i aint gonna make one if there aint interest in it so i figured i would ask in here. Sorry to make a off topic post I am just curious how people feel about it?
would anybody in here be interested in a thread to post art, with constructive criticizm, etc?
Oh thank God, I'm not the only one.
I guess I'll have to start.... your eyebrows need more Sharpie.![]()
If constructive criticism is really wanted, then the artist should ask for it I reckon...