Bleaney
Bluelighter
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2021
- Messages
- 1,760
Fucking hell, this is scary, and happening already! People are going to like this shit.
Apparently already the only way to really tell if music is real or AI generated, is by using AI tools, and separating out the individual components, and listening to each track separately - guitars, drums, bass, vocals etc.
The tracks for the guitars and keyboards were very weak, messy, and fading in and out in this example. But everything else sounded OK.
On listening myself, despite myself I quite liked the track, and thought it sounded pretty good. It had all of the guitar ingredients that I like. Apart from the vocals, which didnt quite seem real somehow, or maybe that was just my imagination. That thought might never have crossed my mind, if I hadn't known the track is supected to be an AI creation.
Beato raises the question as to whether AI music creators should get paid the same as real musicians and songwriters. Interesting question, and imho, as long as the music is clearly labelled as created by AI, which it absolutely should be legally enforced to be, the producer should be paid just as much as any other songwriter or musician would for their creation, and the amount of sales or listens it generates. Even though they dont have the talent or skills or years of hard work that proper songwriters and musicians have to go through, as Beato argues.
Apparently already the only way to really tell if music is real or AI generated, is by using AI tools, and separating out the individual components, and listening to each track separately - guitars, drums, bass, vocals etc.
The tracks for the guitars and keyboards were very weak, messy, and fading in and out in this example. But everything else sounded OK.
On listening myself, despite myself I quite liked the track, and thought it sounded pretty good. It had all of the guitar ingredients that I like. Apart from the vocals, which didnt quite seem real somehow, or maybe that was just my imagination. That thought might never have crossed my mind, if I hadn't known the track is supected to be an AI creation.
Beato raises the question as to whether AI music creators should get paid the same as real musicians and songwriters. Interesting question, and imho, as long as the music is clearly labelled as created by AI, which it absolutely should be legally enforced to be, the producer should be paid just as much as any other songwriter or musician would for their creation, and the amount of sales or listens it generates. Even though they dont have the talent or skills or years of hard work that proper songwriters and musicians have to go through, as Beato argues.
Last edited:
.
I pray for this planet ( world ).
