UK - Alcohol: friend and foe

edgarshade

Bluelighter
Joined
Aug 31, 2010
Messages
1,954
Location
UK
Guardian

Dean Burnett
Tuesday 8 January 2013

With reader comments

People typically abstain from alcohol in January, sometimes getting sponsored for this. But it's possible that alcohol isn't as bad as is often made out. And how would we cope if alcohol were suddenly taken from us? Quite badly, as it turns out.

Alcohol is often demonised by a wide variety of people. It's a common tactic in the UK to try boosting revenue and political capital by suggesting raising the minimum price of alcohol, allegedly to tackle problem drinking. And when the topic of drug legislation comes up, you'll invariably hear about how alcohol is worse than most other drugs. Many argue that it's hypocritical to criminalise something like cannabis when a much more dangerous drug like alcohol is freely available.

It's hard not to concede the logic of this argument. For my job I have to teach about substance abuse and addiction, a subject which for the UK could be renamed "Alcohol (plus guests)" and still be accurate. Friends who work and study in the field of substance abuse tell similar stories about the scale of alcohol abuse. How can such a dangerous substance be so common?

But could it be possible that alcohol is so dangerous precisely because it is so common? In the UK I'd bet more people are injured by Jack Russells than tigers, but I know which I'd rather encounter when out walking alone. So is it fair to compare alcohol unfavourably to other substances when there is so much more opportunity for alcohol to do harm?

Would alcohol still look so bad if opium dens were as common today as they were in Victorian fiction? If there was such a thing as Cheese and Crack parties? If it was traditional at Christmas to have a nice glass of orange juice and amphetamines? A "Bucks Whizz", if you will.

More...
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/brain-flapping/2013/jan/08/alcohol-friend-foe-consequences-health
 
Would alcohol still look so bad if opium dens were as common today as they were in Victorian fiction? If there was such a thing as Cheese and Crack parties? If it was traditional at Christmas to have a nice glass of orange juice and amphetamines? A "Bucks Whizz", if you will.

Alcohol would still be worse. Ecstasy for example does not cause as much violence as alcohol. I heard about an owner of a marijuana cafe who said that he hasnt had a fight in his shop in 19 years.
 
Top