Push to ban alcohol in Indonesia

poledriver

Bluelighter
Joined
Jul 21, 2005
Messages
11,543
Push to ban alcohol in Indonesia

art-Schoolies-Bali-Club-20121220145232532519-620x349.jpg

Bali's alcohol-fuelled nightlife would be devastated by a ban on alcohol. Photo: Jason Childs

INDONESIA will consider banning all alcoholic beverages and putting drinkers in jail for two years.

The ban, which, if implemented, would decimate the night-life in tourist haven Bali, has been proposed and listed on Indonesia’s national parliamentary legislative agenda for next year.

The secretary of the Bali Hotel and Restaurant association, Perry Markus, said it would be “very odd and very bad” for Bali to try to market itself as an international tourist destination if it could not offer alcohol to guests.

Schoolies9-20121130135402934809-620x414.jpg

Hi, I'm drunk and I like zee pussay

The Bill for a Ban on Alcoholic Drinks was drafted by the Islamic-based United Development Party, a member of Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono’s governing coalition.

The strict ban would be “applied nationwide within the territory of the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia”, the bill says.

Those who produce alcoholic drinks would be subject to penalties of up to 10 years imprisonment and 10 billion rupiah ($1.05 million) in fines; there would be $520,000 in fines and five years in prison for those who distribute them,

and two years imprisonment and a $20,800 fine for those who consume alcohol.

Indonesia is a Muslim majority country, where most of the population refrains from drinking. But alcohol is freely available in nightclubs, bars and some cafes.

In regions like Bali, the economy relies heavily on tourism, which includes a heaving, alcohol-fuelled night life.

However, the ban is part of a heavy 2013 legislative agenda in a notoriously gridlocked and slow-moving parliament. It may never even be debated, let alone passed.

In 2008 a bid by Islamic politicians to ban the bikini was over-ruled after protests from the tourist industry.

The anti-alcohol law’s proponent, United Development Party MP Ahmad Kurdi Moekri, told Fairfax Media the proposal was “to safeguard the nation’s morals”.

“It is the mandate of our constitution, it’s about character building,” he said.

Mr Ahmad, a member of the national parliament’s Commission III overseeing legal affairs, said alcoholic drinks “have a greater negative impact on the nation than positive,

and anything negative to the nation is the nation’s enemy”.

But he warned outsiders not to interpret the legislation as an act of religious radicalism.

“We should not take the stance … that, since the bill was proposed by a party of certain religious background, that it might lead to turning the country into a religious-based state,” he said.

“It’s such a small-minded approach.”

The United Development Party (PPP) has 39 representatives, or 7 per cent of the seats in the 560-seat parliament.

Indonesian brewer, Bintang, maker of the favourite beer among Australians travelling in Bali, declined to comment, a spokeswoman saying it was a “very sensitive subject” for them.

Mr Markus said a few months ago supply constraints meant that some restaurants and hotels had trouble re-stocking their supplies of alcoholic drinks, and even that had shown up in a downturn in trade.

http://www.smh.com.au/travel/travel-news/push-to-ban-alcohol-in-indonesia-20121220-2boo0.html
 
When are governments going to realize that prohibition of any substance will never "work"?

Sadly probably never.
 
This is coming from a country who puts people on death row for drug trafficking. If they impose 2 year prison sentences for alcohol they'll just contribute more to their moral bakruptcy.

I don't like alcohol but I refuse to ever visit that country until it changes its backward politics.
 
What a backwards nation.... if push comes to shove people will just brew there own favorite beverage at home%)
 
Well, time to build a giant underground brewery in Indonesia and pay off the government.
 
When are governments going to realize that prohibition of any substance will never "work"?

Sadly probably never.
it "works" if your goal is the capability to spy on and/or imprison nearly anybody you want.
 
Last edited:
Alcohol is pretty unpopular in Indonesia, from what I've observed. Outside of Bali, it's not easy to find a vendor who sells it. I didn't get the sense the Hindu Balinese were big drinkers either. This law really wouldn't affect many people except tourists. And honestly, I don't think everyone in Indonesia is betting on tourism from abroad being a major part of the national economy in the future.

What I read between the lines here is that Indonesia is a rising player on the world stage, and less and less willing to pander to Westerners looking for a cheap and consequence-free party spot, especially as a Muslim-majority nation. I'm reminded of when the Indian state of Goa banned music playing at night, in a clear (and apparently successful) move to get rid of the psytrance scene, so that Goa could "image up" and cater to a more jetsetter clientele.

Backpackers from Western countries will always be looking for places they can fly to for cheap debauchery, where being polite to the locals is optional. But you must understand that pandering to this market is a great indignity to most nonwestern peoples with traditional values of honor, and in most cases tolerated only out of economic necessity. Some such places may try to give tourists the impression that the locals are laid back and party-loving folks too. But I think in many cases this is a facade to make the tourists feel more comfortable letting down their hair and opening their wallets.
 
Yeah, I guess it would be mostly Bali that would suffer if Indo was to ban alcohol. They do survive on tourism there to some extents apparently, with all the jobs created from the visitors and the money that rolls in from that. I recall after the terrorist nightclub bombing(s)? that their tourism dropped for a while and the media here reported for quite a while that they were very worried about their future if not nearly as many tourists wonted to go there. Indo's a huge place tho hey, I've only really been to Bali when I have been there a few times, and outlying areas.
 
Top