I appreciate your take on this myr, makes total sense to me. It would be great to see a reverse thread of "I still have the magic and this is how much and how often I use". But if a person is increasing their dosage over time to maintain those positive effects, that's gotta be a pretty good indication that the magic is looking for the exit door. And if one keeps going down that road, well you'll probably end up on this thread...
I felt like this about the entire Mdma & ED board, except about the topic of mdma depression and negative effects. Almost half of the topics altogether focus on depression, recovery and bad times but very few threads about good times and rolls. I understand that this is a harm reduction website, but the majority of negative posts are attributed to mdma use more than any other substance. While a lot of other substances have people raving about them constantly.
I get the reasons, but I feel like mdma is being put in a negative light more than it deserves. I'm assuming that the majority of people who take mdma do not suffer such negative effects as often as described here, at least not 50% of millions of users. Idk, is the depression from mdma use that bad? I'm just one person, and from those I know pretty well that's 30 users at most, but I just don't see it. I've felt way worse depression from the low times of life in general. Mdma-induced depression just seems so...mild.
I went on a ranting tear there, so excuse me for that. But your point had excited the thoughts that I had for this board this whole time.
On the topic of losing the magic, I think it's because there are a certain subset of users who have an "addictive personality" insofar as they binge on what they really enjoy. For my part, mdma was the best and most euphoric substance I have ever taken by far. Knowing myself, there was no way I would've taken it as sparingly as I was suppose to have done. Especially when a small group is binging together, and with one of them eventually becoming my SO, I couldn't refuse dropping so often and therefore lose the magic. I saw it coming. Probably the majority of the posters in this thread experienced something similar, as in trying to reach the same high level as before too often, whenever they planned to trip.
I also just think it's because of the thread title. So people relate to it. I'm sure if someone started a thread asking if people still have the magic, a lot of posters could respond favorably if they felt like it. But according to the late Shulgin, losing the magic of mdma is inevitable. When that may happen varies quite a bit, and it depends on many factors. Though it's good to note that that is simply what he thinks, not something that is written in stone.
Oh, and the reason why people don't quit at that point is because even though they've lost the magic, very strong rolls are still possible. Even at that level, it is still really fun and enjoyable. Plus the sociable side of mdma makes it hard for some people to say no for the purpose of preserving the magic. That's just my guess though. Great point, btw.