grimble crumble
Bluelighter
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2005
- Messages
- 1,008
^^^ I wish I could just "snip" someones entire arguement when they are making good points.
anyway it seems like were getting to a point in the season where we need to create a "best nba players" thread throw some players names in there and drag the debate to its new home.
but here are my last 2 cents for the best player in this thread
Best player/ best of era's
the most common arguements in support for coming up with these players is this:
1. Winning, specifically winning rings
2. phenominal offensive stats or accomplishments
3. Clutchness/ killer instinct
4. productivity himself and increasing the productivity of his team mates.
Now if you were to pick #1. Bill Russel is the greatest player of all time. if you were pick #2. Wilt chamberlin or Kobe Bryant or guys like elgin baylor are the greatest players of all time. If one goes with #3 than maybe MJ, Kobe, or someone like Jerry West or even Ray Allen is the greatest of all time. Finally if you were going to pick #4's logic that would make Magic Johnson, or John stockton or hell even charles Barkely or Karl Malone or reggie miller the greatest of all time.
Its safe to say that the overpowering majority of fans, players and nba experts would agree that Bill russell is not the greatest player of all time. the same is true of Wilt or john stockton.
so then no doubt it can not just be one or the other but a mix of all of them.
now lets just stick to arguing the best player of the recent era of the nba.
Kobe bryant is the only active player with 5 rings on his hand. He has also had offensive exhibitions that could be voted as the most prolific the leage has seen not just in the recent era but in all of nba history. He also shows a will to win and killer instinct time in and time out, as he ages it seems his productivity is going down, yet his career true shooting percentage is .55
Kobe is also the most well rounded player in the game who can score in literally any facet or form of offense
Kobe bryant is the best player of the recent era and ranks among the greats of all time. there is no other active player whose even in the discusion for all time greats.
anyway it seems like were getting to a point in the season where we need to create a "best nba players" thread throw some players names in there and drag the debate to its new home.
but here are my last 2 cents for the best player in this thread
Best player/ best of era's
the most common arguements in support for coming up with these players is this:
1. Winning, specifically winning rings
2. phenominal offensive stats or accomplishments
3. Clutchness/ killer instinct
4. productivity himself and increasing the productivity of his team mates.
Now if you were to pick #1. Bill Russel is the greatest player of all time. if you were pick #2. Wilt chamberlin or Kobe Bryant or guys like elgin baylor are the greatest players of all time. If one goes with #3 than maybe MJ, Kobe, or someone like Jerry West or even Ray Allen is the greatest of all time. Finally if you were going to pick #4's logic that would make Magic Johnson, or John stockton or hell even charles Barkely or Karl Malone or reggie miller the greatest of all time.
Its safe to say that the overpowering majority of fans, players and nba experts would agree that Bill russell is not the greatest player of all time. the same is true of Wilt or john stockton.
so then no doubt it can not just be one or the other but a mix of all of them.
now lets just stick to arguing the best player of the recent era of the nba.
Kobe bryant is the only active player with 5 rings on his hand. He has also had offensive exhibitions that could be voted as the most prolific the leage has seen not just in the recent era but in all of nba history. He also shows a will to win and killer instinct time in and time out, as he ages it seems his productivity is going down, yet his career true shooting percentage is .55
Kobe is also the most well rounded player in the game who can score in literally any facet or form of offense
Kobe bryant is the best player of the recent era and ranks among the greats of all time. there is no other active player whose even in the discusion for all time greats.
Last edited: