• 🇬🇧󠁿 🇸🇪 🇿🇦 🇮🇪 🇬🇭 🇩🇪 🇪🇺
    European & African
    Drug Discussion


    Welcome Guest!
    Posting Rules Bluelight Rules
  • EADD Moderators: Pissed_and_messed | Shinji Ikari

Why is there such a disconnect between European and American humor? In your opinion

Droppersneck

Bluelighter
Joined
Sep 15, 2010
Messages
35,138
Location
all posts made by the Bluelight username "Droppers
I read this forum sometimes and I see where people are being smitten with each other or very lightly giving each other a go. I do not understand what fuels the entertainment factor of this sub forum outside of sourcing which likely does not occur very much if at all. And I say this with no disrespect I love conversing with people from all over the world especially Europe. Usually I gain a very insightful perspective on a topic after consultation. Jeremy Clarkson is very funny imo but Al Murray just confuses me. There are very few cross overs from Europe into the lounge which is American humor in a nutshell. What is your thoughts/theories on this. I do not get offended by anything and I am a big fan in general; my dream is to make it to the UK so I can IRL troll europeans being a stereotypical redneck. JK I do badly want to visit being a history buff.
 
Hmmm I'd say humour wise there isn't so much of a difference in taste, al Murray I don't really get either so it's not jus you guys ;) , I guess british humour has always been a little more bitter than American humour, still I find American humour very in your face, it's definitely a subject I understand but would like to hear other people's views on especially some Americans that hate British humour
 
I read this forum sometimes and I see where people are being smitten with each other or very lightly giving each other a go. I do not understand what fuels the entertainment factor of this sub forum outside of sourcing which likely does not occur very much if at all. And I say this with no disrespect I love conversing with people from all over the world especially Europe. Usually I gain a very insightful perspective on a topic after consultation. Jeremy Clarkson is very funny imo but Al Murray just confuses me. There are very few cross overs from Europe into the lounge which is American humor in a nutshell. What is your thoughts/theories on this. I do not get offended by anything and I am a big fan in general; my dream is to make it to the UK so I can IRL troll europeans being a stereotypical redneck. JK I do badly want to visit being a history buff.

Interesting topic. I do not feel that there is a difference in humour between Europeans n that of Americans, although I did at one time think so. I once hung out on Yahoo chat with an IRL friend who had a similar sense of humour to that of Raasy. She was misunderstood on there because, we felt at the time that most of them were Americans n thus somehow didn't get the British sense of humour. They would think she was being nasty when she wasn't being.

So to take this example n the one you've illustrated (the lounge n EADD) it shows kind of opposites in maybe Europeans don't understand the American sense of humour. So I'd suggest it's simply a case of perception. I'm trying to think of the words bare with me here being on holiday I packed my brain away n for some reason can't remember where I packed it. Group identity n "area" may have affect. For instance, the Lounge is meant to be somewhere whete people don't take themselves seriously. It's known to be humourous n "piss-taking" (don't like that word but could not think of another), people go at each other in a jokingly, non-malicious sense n it's all meant in the spirit of fun. The majority of, but not all of the members, are Americans.

Meanwhile, EADD is obviously for people from Europeans areas, although we do openly accept n welcome people from outside of these, One Thousand Words being an example. Although this is the case, the sub-forum goes with the ethos of the site - harm reduction, drug discussion with social, non-drug discussion. The difference between EADD n the other sub-forums is that it caters for Europeans but is not limited to one drug group or a few drug groups or a specific topic only, as is the case for Electronic music discussion or Other Drugs. EADD differs from the Lounge as does every sub-forum on Bluelight for reasons I have stated above. The Lounge is based on non-drug discussion n light-hearted teasing n humour.

The way in which EADD is formed, there are going to be serious discussions here whether that be drug or non drug based. Things get taking seriously because people often come here for support, for advice, for information n for company. The advice given here can often make the difference from someone taking drugs safely n someone taking them recklessly n ODing maybe even ddying. It can be the difference from someone becoming an addict or maybe (this statement is probably controversial so let me explain. Once, a few months I think, a poster made a thread here asking about Heroin. He wanted to try it n he wanted to know how he want about doing iy. Most of the members here, especially Heroin addicts, explained why taking heroin was a bad idea. This, if I remember rightly, was done in a non-patronising n non-judgemental manner. The OP decided not to try Heroin after this due to the good advice people especially those who have had negative affects from Heroin, some have had their lives ruined n are picking back the pieces of their lives.

Do you have any other exemplars to illustrate your point, other than differentiating the humour of EADD posters with posters from The Lounge? I can't speak for all Europeans but you may find that British people have a good sense of humour n some even to that of the lounge.

Evey
 
Most British people don't get Al Murray either.

There's really not that much of a difference in humour these days. I have a few American work colleagues and we all get along fine, laugh at the same things, Watch the same TV shows, etc.

It's not all Monty Python and "Ooh Matron" in real life. :D
 
Well, we at least remembered how to spell "humour" ..... *ducks*

British humour tends to be drier, blacker and also to have a vein of tragedy running through it (think Bread and anything else by Carla Lane, the later series of Only Fools and Horses and The Royle Family, which teeter at times on the knife-edge between laughing and crying). And programmes such as The Office rely on a strong sense of separation between "my business" and "none of my business", which is a very British thing.
 
I'm fairly confident a British comedian from the 1970's called Bernard Manning would be to your tastes Droppers.
 
I read this forum sometimes and I see where people are being smitten with each other or very lightly giving each other a go. I do not understand what fuels the entertainment factor of this sub forum outside of sourcing which likely does not occur very much if at all. And I say this with no disrespect I love conversing with people from all over the world especially Europe. Usually I gain a very insightful perspective on a topic after consultation. Jeremy Clarkson is very funny imo but Al Murray just confuses me. There are very few cross overs from Europe into the lounge which is American humor in a nutshell. What is your thoughts/theories on this. I do not get offended by anything and I am a big fan in general; my dream is to make it to the UK so I can IRL troll europeans being a stereotypical redneck. JK I do badly want to visit being a history buff.

I don't understand your not getting brit humour. I'm an American living in the UK, always heard this was a "thing" of Americans not getting British humour. I laughed my ass off! Then again, I love Ricky Gervais and that bastard is dry as hell! Funny as fuck. I think people just find what tickles them and go with it. It's either funny or it's not. Personally, I like Al Murray. He's not the greatest of comedians but he can pull out a few belters. If I had to compare him to an American counterpart I'd put him in the region of Bill Hicks.
Hope you make it over here. You'd love it!

Well, we at least remembered how to spell "humour" ..... *ducks*

British humour tends to be drier, blacker and also to have a vein of tragedy running through it (think Bread and anything else by Carla Lane, the later series of Only Fools and Horses and The Royle Family, which teeter at times on the knife-edge between laughing and crying). And programmes such as The Office rely on a strong sense of separation between "my business" and "none of my business", which is a very British thing.


I tend to agree with you there. Also, it's as black as my soul and that's saying something! Never was a fan of only fools and horses or the royle family though.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I haven't watched enough Al Murray, virtually none because I find him as funny as a dose of Ebola but where are the parallels between him and Bill?
 
Maybe I haven't watched enough Al Murray, virtually none because I find him as funny as a dose of Ebola but where are the parallels between him and Bill?

Its the style I suppose. I've always thought there to be a comparison between the two. Perhaps it's the comedic over loyalty to ones nation, or other small similarities.

Must admit though, if asked to watch one or the other, sorry, it's Bill HANDS DOWN!
 
bill hicks, george carlin, lenny bruce all legends in my book but the one thing that most Americans dont get is irony,pathos and the ability to laugh at ones self there in lies some of the reasons that there is a mismatch. Also I find American humour very contrived in many cases but does have some great shows - Seinfield, Curb...uh cant think of any more at the moment but one other issue is that on shows from the uS there might be 20 writers where as here 1-2 maybe three.
 
Top