I was just comparing the expectations going into each film, not the two films themselves.
Well, comparing expectations of two films; concerns judging/comparing those two films ( if you lump them into one category); will conflate your assesment and feeling but I think I get where you are coming from.
I just completely disagree with your assessment of Lady Bird.
Good. Life would be unbearably boring otherwise.

True. Yet, success and merit are not synonymous, unfortunately.Every movie doesn’t have to drip with imagination or creative zeal in order to be successful.
What you are saying is paradoxical but I assume you are discussing 'edgyness'; which is predictabile fluff in film. However, I think your expectations may perhaps, be limited as you may be confusing homogeneity/creative variety with predictibility/unpredictibility - the unpredictible should make you percieve things differently/ not just present as empty novely.This day and age unpredictability has become pretty predictable.
Greta Gerwig was channeling her own experience through Saoirse Ronan and her character. When you are making a semi-autobiographical, light hearted indie film about a girl growing up in Sacramento is not the time to make too many overly artistic statements. Gerwig has plenty of time for those things...this was pretty much her directorial debut.
Yes, yes. Good for her. Hope she does well. Etc. ( *see commentary above)
Speaking of originality and creativity, what do do you think about all the plagiarism accusations swirling around Guillermo del Toro and The Shape of Water?
Del Toro denies ever having seen it although I find that hard to believe given how well versed he is in this particular genre...I mean, he admits the creature is directly inspired by the Creature from the Black Lagoon...but “inspired by” doesn’t really go far enough imo...
what did you mean by the Moonlight comment btw? I didn’t get that.
Well, I have read this and it seems like much was ripped (however, I haven't seen the short and am looking forward to seeing it.)
I also read that, the makers had no objection with Del Toro, so, they are either intimidated; or, colluding to cash in on the popularity that the SOW brings toward their short ( I hope it is the latter

With regard to The Creature from the Black Lagoon - this is an archytype and has meaning - so, if you are unaware of the meaning of archytypal charachters ( which in fantasy and horror is ubiquitous) I would urge you to look it up.
I am biast but I love subtext and Del Toro's socio-political subtext is beautifully communicated in his films. Again, I would suggest you look them up (not just on your tube)- if you haven't been immediately curious about it. Curioustiy makes the cat smarter.

Last edited: