The term is a pejorative/derogatory as the implication is that the argument is being overly simplistic and leads to misunderstanding and stereotyping while reducing otherwise important nuance and complexity. I didn't make this sense up. If you look up the definition, well:
"reductionist | rəˈdəkSHənəst | often derogatory, noun: a person who analyzes and describes a complex phenomenon in terms of its simple or fundamental constituents: a crude reductionist. adjective: analyzing and describing a complex phenomenon in terms of its simple or fundamental constituents: a reductionist approach that leads to stereotyping."
It is unwise and dismissive to treat complex issues as though they're simplistic. And there is a difference between things being "simple" – which is good – and things being "simplistic" – which can be insultingly bad.
Yes, it's definitely a myth. Also, by definition, humans are not capable of "superhuman" feats. Hence the term:
superhuman. It implies supernatural abilities. Look, my point is: not everyone realizes the hyperbole. People read this kinda shit and even though it's been explained that these sort of occurrences are very rare and not likely to happen, there are ppl out there who think that these are the
de facto effects of the drug, that if they or anyone happens to take PCP, there's no avoiding it – that person will definitely go crazy and fight cops, every single time, no question. This is obviously false, but it isn't obvious to everyone, especially when it gets mentioned EVERY TIME the drug is talked about, particularly by ppl who lack experience with the drug. Most ppl cannot even tell you what the effects of PCP are. They just have it tied into fighting the cops in their heads, and I'm here to say this is fucking stupid, willfully ignorant and irksome. Nothing against anyone personally, and I've heard smart ppl espouse this belief, mind you, I just mean that the argument itself is bereft of intelligence and lacks insight.
Sometimes, though not necessarily. Please don't think this is an unavoidable consequence… Also: this whole line of thinking stems from racism. It's why cocaine was made illegal. There is an old myth/legend about the "drug-crazed negro with a lust for white women who cannot be stopped with bullets." The fear started with cocaine and jazz musicians in Harlem circa the 1930s, and in time this fear spread to other drugs popular in Black communities. It's fear-mongering racism meant to control, oppress, and subdue minorities in the U.S. Don't fall for the propaganda.
They're used to PCP in certain neighborhoods, too. And the alcohol comment is true and only further proves my point that 95% of the fear tied to PCP is unwarranted.
Different strokes for different folks.
Regarding "reductionist" – do be aware that this term is not a compliment and it is considered to be a negative, derogatory term. I mean, I know what you're saying – I feel this way about the word "opportunist". They tell you when you're a teenager "you have to seize opportunities when they present themselves in life." So it's like, well then isn't being an "opportunist" a good thing? No, it's meant to convey someone who exploits and takes advantage of others for their own personal gain. It implies opportunities at others' expense. Reductionist means the argument is overly reductive and stereotyping.