BlueAdonis said:I see your points, Rocka. These are things that have been mentioned before on the board (and in MPC). Although you're gonna bust my balls for saying this, I think with each addition of non-drug discussion forums it takes away from this site's purpose and goal. Yes, you can aruge that Film & Television, Words, SLR, Second Opinion are not necessarily "drug related" but must the board fall further away from the topic?
I just dont see how much traffic a sports could possibly generate, also. How many sports topics are in the lounge, just a handful? A football thread, a baseball thread, a hockey thread, etc, etc... I just dont see the immediate need for a forum only for sports.
I lurk on a site that covers many of the things you listed: Gaming, Sports, Movies and Television, Athletics, and all sorts of cool techie computer shit. Basically everything minus the gambling. If you like, I'll give you the address to look at and post at if you like. Maybe watch the forums there and see how their sports forums barely survive. I rarely see a topic on gaming or gambling, maybe I've just missed the "ton" of posts on the matter.![]()
FoxyKel said:Are there enough current threads to warrant it, though? It might be worth your while to compile a list of threads that have been active in the past 14 days that would fall into the category.
It is unlikely that a new forum will be created because of the threads that could be started on the subject matter, they are generally created because of the topics that are or have been.
I'd be interested to see how many are out there, because S/O and the Lounge would be the two places I would most expect them to be started, and I've barely seen any in S/O.
JTNOLA5211 said:Take the College & University foruim for example......Im sure there were as many threads as say sports related stuff but since a forum was dedicated to it, it has encouraged more people to post about it.....
FoxyKel said:... and if you created a forum about how regularly people take a shit, it would probably encourage people to post about their bowel movements - what's your point?
TheLoveBandit said:^^take that with the knowledge that there is no set direction among the staff. Some want more 'community forums', others want less of them or at least a more re-focued approach to the drug side. I can't say which side is in the majority or the minority - simply that both sides of this directional desire exist among the staff as well as it does among the members.
You may have noticed the majority of forum changes over the past several months have been more of a suprise than a publicly announced transition. This is the result of the Admins guiding the forum offerings in the direction they see best benefitting the site. They state that they take into consideration the amount of threads on a certan topic and weight that against the desired purpose of BL and make decisions on what forums to add or not - so the message is to have more threads on a topic if you hope to generate a forum for it.
Show the need, and if it fits our direction, it will be met. But that is subject to the Admin's direction, which we aren' always privy to.
---
My own personal opinion? Most of these new requests are better answered by other sites or by the current forums. Would the Canadiens really care less about Aussie Football? Do the Europeans care at all about the NFL or the NBA? Sports are probably best left to their own current regional discussions. Liesure as well, since who in South America really plans on backpacking Europe or skiiing in Colorado? Again, those types of discussions can best be addressed regionally, and people who actually anticipate *travelling* to somewhere can post in those regional discussions for more info. As for gambling....I've not seen much of it in the forums I frequent. Perhaps there is a need, but it isn't glaringly obvious. But take all this with a grain of salt as well, since it is only the opinion of one man.
alasdairm said:Originally posted by miamistu
...but my bet is that if you added sports, it would quickly rise to the top 5 in traffic almost overnight.
perhaps. but two points:
1. it's not your bet. they're not your dice to roll.
iso240 said:Aren't you the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" guy? Is there a NEED for a leisure activities forum? But the real reason I'm commenting here is to say that we mods "who want nothing but drug forums" are not afraid that the sports forum will be "too successful," we're afraid that this entire site is going to continue "diversifying" to the point at which harm reduction and drugs are more of a sub-focus than a "mission" around here (assuming it's not already there).