ebola?
Bluelight Crew
MDAO said:What I want to know is, why is the OCEAN (a.k.a. Big Five) personality test fairly well accepted by the scientific community, but not the Myers-Briggs? Sure, it adds one more independent variable -- neuroticism. But the other four are basically the same: Openness = sensing/intuitive, Conscientiousness = perceiving/judging, Extroversion = E/I, and Agreeability = feeling/thinking, more or less.
I have never thought of this variable mapping, but it makes a great deal of sense. I believe that the big five is better accepted as a sort of knee-jerk reaction, as the big-five is empirically derived, from terms commonly used to describe people in English, while the Meyers-Briggs comes from Jung's theory of the constitution of the psyche.
Spunky Skunk said:Therefore, when it scores your 72 questions, it gives you a description of your "type" so loose that it really could describe anybody.
The conclusion to your test results may be furtherly enforced in your mind if you like what it says about you.
Well, I'm not sure if adding more questions to the test would help, particularly if the questions that are there point reliably to stable aspects of behavior. I would also look at a few profiles...the types are actually pretty specific. However, you are quite correct in that the Meyers-Briggs, and really most all personality theory, has a great deal of trouble dealing with situational variance in behavior and self-perception.
ebola