• ✍️ WORDS ✍️

    Welcome Guest!

  • Words Moderators: Shambles

NPR submission: This I Believe

wesmdow

Bluelighter
Joined
Dec 13, 2004
Messages
4,016
ive got to write an essay for NPR's 'this i believe' program. here is the final copy of my submission:

I have been raised agnostically. From this perspective, probably as close as one can come to neutrality on the subject of religion, I was able to make some observations that only a true outsider could see.

I remember elementary school, when no one I knew practiced any religion. When I was nine, I didn’t have to love Jesus to fit in. We were just kids and no one knew any better. This was soon to change, as kids began to hear about “youth groups.” The purpose a youth group is to instill the churches ideals into kids without seeming ‘boring,’ like conventional church. I don’t know what goes on in one of these groups. I haven’t ever gone to a meeting. I have seen what happens to someone after a few years in a youth group, though. Innocent little kids go in, and innocent little Christians come out.

I must have been eleven when my peer group started to inform me that I was going to Hell.

From that point, religion—particularly Christianity—played a much larger role in my life. I began to think about religion/God more often. I was curious about the traditions my friends followed.

I have always found it interesting, ironic maybe, the way people pray before they eat. My best friend’s mom, a single mother-of-two could work a 60-hour week, and still barely make ends meet. She would insist on having family dinner, but before eating the family prayed. She would thank Jesus for the food he provided them, and before the children could eat, they too had to thank Jesus. As a little kid, I wondered about Jesus, did he really give them food? I wondered if she ever wondered…

Humans often chide sheep for being stupid and incapable of individual thought. I remember watching my friend’s dad in church one of the few times I went. I remember the prayer they recited, “The Lord is my Shepherd.” I wondered if they all realized what they were saying.

Eventually, I asked. I learned that people are willing to make sacrifices and suffer humility in exchange for guidance. Religion is valued for moral fiber, and for some morality is so vague that they need guidance: religion’s specialty. Morality and religion are synonymous, in the eyes of many.

But, does morality have to be inseparable from religion? Do we need to suffer in order to receive moral guidance? Do we need moral guidance, even?

The answers seem all but obvious to me, but my religious views are not the subject of this essay. Each person needs to seek his or her own answers to these questions. Too few people have considered them. The world would be a better place if every person took a step back, examined what he or she believed, and why he or she believes it.


my goal was to keep this as non-offensive as possible, while still conveying my point in as positive a light as i could. does it do this effectively?

is it clear what i believe, without me having to say it directly?
 
Last edited:
We humans often chide sheep for being stupid and incapable of individual thought. I remember watching my friend’s dad in church one of the few times I went. I remember the prayer they recited, “The Lord is my Shepherd.” I wondered if they all realized what they were saying.

Preatty spot on but offensive none the less..

You make some great observations. However, I would consider re-wording some sentences so that less begin with the word "I".
peas
 
Yes. You believe that you do not need this guidance or morality because you are already satisfied with yours and it works well for you. I somewhat agree with you on this - many people look to religion for answers. If you are not lost, troubled, etc. you may not have the same inclination as another who is.

Do we need moral guidance, even?
The answer to this question is unclear; I lean towards yes.
People are not born with morals, but are basically spoonfed some sort of morals and at one point must decide for themselves.

If you are referring to the moral guidance derived from religious teaching, I would say yes. You cannot disagree if someone says that the world is a better place because of good morals, most of which derive from a religious teaching. The ten commandments and the 'golden rule' are all aimed at making society and human civilization better.

However, if you ask if the world is a better place with religion, the answers differ. Many millions of people have died because of religion. Perhaps mostly because religious leaders were not practicing what they preached.
 
I don't think there's a problem with the paragraph that Mehm quoted, as it makes a fair observation, but there's probably a cumulative effect across the whole piece that would certainly be offensive to some. I've not been exposed to NPR or this program, so I have no idea where they would draw the line.

You've probably explained what you don't believe more than what you believe, but I think the final paragraph just about makes up for it. The last few lines are convincing, and probably extinguish any doubt in the reader's mind about where you're coming from.

Also, in this sentence:

The idea behind a youth group is to instill the churches ideas into kids without seeming ‘boring,’ like conventional church.

"churches" should read "church's". Also you've used idea/ideas twice - perhaps you could replace one with another word to make the sentence read better?
 
Top