• Current Events & Politics
    Welcome Guest
    Please read before posting:
    Forum Guidelines Bluelight Rules
  • Current Events & Politics Moderators: deficiT | tryptakid | Foreigner

Israel is under attack

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm the one being ignorant?
Yes, you said "Ethnic cleansing has been the entire goal of Zionism from the beginning" when
"At the core of the Zionist ideology was the traditional aspiration for a Jewish national home through the re-establishment of Jewish sovereignty in Palestine,
Is the reality. That wiki quote hardly backs your claim. The removal of Palestinians was hardly the point. It was an effect.

I know the history, insofar as anyone who can read knows it. Herzl didn't promote Zionism out of a supremacist motivation but after witnessing the increase in pogroms in Eastern Europe and then things like the infamous Dreyfus affair in France. He realised that even in a secular Europe, the Jews would still always be the enemy.


In returning to the Holy Lands, The Jews of the era were highly motivated to simply disregard the local population. This wasn't a crusade aimed at dispossessing a people. It's not colonialism as the European Jews have nowhere to return to and the million Arabic Jews, who were expelled by hostile ansemitic governments, cannot even legally enter their old nations so that's a dead end too. The establishment of Israel was an attempt to find sanctuary in an increasingly hostile world. This was before the Holocaust. In light of that, can you truly claim the Zionists were wrong to seek refuge?

You can dislike Israel as much as you want, but if you don't contend with the historical contingencies that lead to its creation, you'll never truly understand why they defend their country so vigorously. 6 million in the ovens less than a hundred years ago, a explicitly and actively genocidal neighbour (among many genocidal neighbours), and Western liberal elite that once again chant for their eradication, and you imagine that the Jews are the aggressors and ethnic cleansers? Really?
 
Coming from the guy who consistently laps up every piece of Quatari/Iranian/Hamas/terrorist propaganda, you have to know how meaningless your statement is.
This is the big problem I'm seeing. People who lap up American/Israeli-backed mainstream media, getting fed lies and thinking that other people who are reporting truth and facts are always parroting "enemy" propaganda. It's just funny that Westerners are so quick to side with, and believe, the countries who are the ones consistently violating international law.

To everyone posting in this thread: Does the law mean anything to you? Should countries follow it? Should they be held accountable and prosecuted for violating it? If you can't agree to this then you have no moral high ground. And if you do agree then you would see who is the biggest culprit at this point.


Option 3 is that, as harsh as it sounds, is that the price to be paid to remove Hamas is the lives of some of the civilians Hamas themselves put at risk. It's awful to say it, because yeah, it means women, children, babies are dying. If I were Israeli, I would pull the trigger myself. History tells us what happens when the Jews are unable to fight back. Antizionists start stoking the crematoria.
There is so much wrong with this. "Price to be paid to remove Hamas" while ignoring the obvious fact that every civilian killed recruits MORE Hamas members to the cause. Once you've got job, no food, no hope for the future AND your little sister/cousin has just had her limbs blown off and then dies because they ALSO bomb a hospital - then what else would that person do? They'd fight the aggressor. This is obvious. Everyone knows this. The Israeli government knows this but they still bomb thousands of innocent people with the justification that it's "destroying Hamas". It's obvious propaganda.

If the Israeli government was genuinely serious about peace, the settlements would be dismantled (and would never have been built in the first place). They're illegal under international law. If they consistently break international law then how can they lecture anyone else about doing the wrong thing?

I'm half-Israeli, ethnically Jewish. The Israeli state does not represent me or Jewish people. People need to stop conflating the two. The founders of Israel and the leaders of Israel are not religious, they are atheists. So they get away with war crimes by claiming it's for the protection of the "only Jewish state". As an actual Jew, the only fear I have of collective action against my people is from the direct actions of the Israeli state, violating international law, terrorizing populations and murdering civilians. This time it's different. The entire world is watching and more people are waking up from the fog of Zionist propaganda daily (this was extremely difficult for me to wake up from and almost impossible for most Jews/Israelis and many westerners, as we can see in this thread).


The thing with your view though, my friend, and of many leftists, is that you keep complaining about Israel killing too many civilians- which I do partially agree with because even 1 is too many- but you were opposed to Israel even before the reprisals on Gaza. You're just shoehorning factoids into what is a emotional argument for you. So I don't really think you care about Palestinians inasmuch as you dislike the Jews because you're an antisem- sorry, antizionist.
"opposed to Israel" - which Israel? The original Israel approved the UN looks very different with smaller borders.
So are people against that or just against the seizure of more and more land?

PLEASE stop with the antisemitism/antizionist smears of people. It's so transparently pathetic at this point and is actually a desperate measure used by people suffering from cognitive dissonance. It is VERY difficult to morally defend thousands of babies getting their little bodies blown to pieces, so there MUST be some underlying jew/israeli hatred coming from the people who are arguing for the defense of innocent Palestinians. It's dishonest, its a distraction and it isn't based on truth.
 
Last edited:
'The Ten Dumbest Things We're Being Asked To Believe About Israel's War On Gaza'

Here are the ten dumbest things we’re being asked to believe about Israel’s war on Gaza, in no particular order:

1. That Israel had no idea what Hamas was up to prior to October 7, but ever since October 7 has known about every hospital, mosque, school, refugee camp and water tower that Hamas is hiding in.

2. That the blame for all of the deaths caused by Israeli weapons launched by Israel rests solely on Hamas.

3. That Hamas is using “human shields” — meaning Hamas bases are hidden amidst civilian populations — yet Israel is managing to kill thousands of civilians without doing any meaningful damage to Hamas.

4. That it would be perfectly fine to murder children by the thousands even if they were being used as “human shields” — as though resolving a hostage situation by mowing down thousands of child hostages would be regarded as reasonable and acceptable by the public if it happened in our own country.

5. That it is only by pure coincidence that Israel bombing “Hamas targets” in civilian infrastructure and residential buildings just so happens to look exactly the same as what you’d expect to see if Israel was simply bombing civilian infrastructure and residential buildings and lying about its reasons for doing so.

6. That satellite images of entire neighborhoods reduced to rubble in Gaza have been caused by “precision strikes” directed solely at Hamas and have been carried out with the greatest of care for human life, despite Israeli officials openly saying that “the emphasis is on damage and not on accuracy” in this assault and that “Gaza will eventually turn into a city of tents; there will be no buildings.”

7. That this bombing campaign has anything to do with freeing Israeli hostages — as though the bombing campaign itself has not killed dozens of hostages, and as though anyone believes Israel would stop bombing Gaza after the hostages are returned.

8. That the only reason anyone could possibly oppose the detonation of thousands of bombs on an open air prison full of children would be if they had very strong and hateful opinions toward the members of the religion of Judaism.

9. That Hamas attacked Israel entirely out of the blue and completely unprovoked, solely because they are evil and hate Jews.

10. That Washington is powerless to stop this genocide that it is directly funding and supplying.
 
The Israeli military doesn't get caught by surprise as they claim on October 7. And then doesn't respond for hours after? That's not logical or plausible.
This is also a difficult thing for some people to believe, that governments would allow or directly murder their own citizens in order to further their political goals. But once you accept this uncomfortable and distressing reality, then a lot more makes sense. Like why we have proof now of Israeli military directly killing their own hostages. "Bring back the hostages" while simultaneously conducting air strikes on a building containing hostages...

And now this has been doing the rounds on X
Like I said, things are different this time. And very soon a lot of people are going to wake up from the lies

 
This is the big problem I'm seeing. People who lap up American/Israeli-backed mainstream media, getting fed lies and thinking that other people who are reporting truth and facts are always parroting "enemy" propaganda. It's just funny that Westerners are so quick to side with, and believe, the countries who are the ones consistently violating international law.

To everyone posting in this thread: Does the law mean anything to you? Should countries follow it? Should they be held accountable and prosecuted for violating it? If you can't agree to this then you have no moral high ground. And if you do agree then you would see who is the biggest culprit at this point.



There is so much wrong with this. "Price to be paid to remove Hamas" while ignoring the obvious fact that every civilian killed recruits MORE Hamas members to the cause. Once you've got job, no food, no hope for the future AND your little sister/cousin has just had her limbs blown off and then dies because they ALSO bomb a hospital - then what else would that person do? They'd fight the aggressor. This is obvious. Everyone knows this. The Israeli government knows this but they still bomb thousands of innocent people with the justification that it's "destroying Hamas". It's obvious propaganda.

If the Israeli government was genuinely serious about peace, the settlements would be dismantled (and would never have been built in the first place). They're illegal under international law. If they consistently break international law then how can they lecture anyone else about doing the wrong thing?

I'm half-Israeli, ethnically Jewish. The Israeli state does not represent me or Jewish people. People need to stop conflating the two. The founders of Israel and the leaders of Israel are not religious, they are atheists. So they get away with war crimes by claiming it's for the protection of the "only Jewish state". As an actual Jew, the only fear I have of collective action against my people is from the direct actions of the Israeli state, violating international law, terrorizing populations and murdering civilians. This time it's different. The entire world is watching and more people are waking up from the fog of Zionist propaganda daily (this was extremely difficult for me to wake up from and almost impossible for most Jews/Israelis and many westerners, as we can see in this thread).



"opposed to Israel" - which Israel? The original Israel approved the UN looks very different with smaller borders.
So are people against that or just against the seizure of more and more land?

PLEASE stop with the antisemitism/antizionist smears of people. It's so transparently pathetic at this point and is actually a desperate measure used by people suffering from cognitive dissonance. It is VERY difficult to morally defend thousands of babies getting their little bodies blown to pieces, so there MUST be some underlying jew/israeli hatred coming from the people who are arguing for the defense of innocent Palestinians. It's dishonest, its a distraction and it isn't based on truth.
Oh great, you're here. 😵‍💫
 
the MSM has been overwhelmingly anti Israel. Fact.
I can't remember ever seeing the MSM do some in-depth investigation into the lives of people living in Gaza. There are literally Israelis right across the border who do not even know that Gazans have their food, water, electricity controlled and suspended at will. Van Jones was fired from CNN for simply speaking out about the plight of Palestinians. What you're saying is propaganda (and it's regarding the media, meta-propaganda).
 
The Israeli military doesn't get caught by surprise as they claim on October 7. And then doesn't respond for hours after? That's not logical or plausible.
This is also a difficult thing for some people to believe, that governments would allow or directly murder their own citizens in order to further their political goals. But once you accept this uncomfortable and distressing reality, then a lot more makes sense. Like why we have proof now of Israeli military directly killing their own hostages. "Bring back the hostages" while simultaneously conducting air strikes on a building containing hostages...

And now this has been doing the rounds on X
Like I said, things are different this time. And very soon a lot of people are going to wake up from the lies



And there it is... every opinion @JGrimez has is simply to further the advancement of his conspiracies.
 
The Israeli military doesn't get caught by surprise as they claim on October 7. And then doesn't respond for hours after? That's not logical or plausible.
This is also a difficult thing for some people to believe, that governments would allow or directly murder their own citizens in order to further their political goals. But once you accept this uncomfortable and distressing reality, then a lot more makes sense. Like why we have proof now of Israeli military directly killing their own hostages. "Bring back the hostages" while simultaneously conducting air strikes on a building containing hostages...

And now this has been doing the rounds on X
Like I said, things are different this time. And very soon a lot of people are going to wake up from the lies


Why would the dancing Israeli's, presuming they were directly involved, allow themselves to be caught dancing in public. Or how about Mr Silverstein and his infamous 'pull it' comments? These are so obviously planted breadcrumbs for the simple minded to follow - how is it that out of all the conspirators involved that only the Jewish persons get themselves framed up. Or how about wider afield, with Mr. Rothschild.

Come on dude. You're falling straight into the easy trap. We see clearly what the result of all this is, with the rising anti-Semitic currents all over the place. It's too easy. Someone is using the Jews as the scapegoats, abusing the history in the collective unconscious.. it's a worn groove, and easy to trigger - so is playing up to a good old witch-hunt.

Whether we're talking October 7th or 9/11, it's not as one-dimensional as just taking the target nation in question to be the main conspirator or that the sneaky Jews were the masterminds of it all. The intelligence world bleeds across all borders, and across all the big players in military, banking, corporations, royalty, and others. I'd be willing to bet money that in both instances the whole story is actually a lot more complicated than we think.
 

Palestinians in Gaza, West Bank strongly support Hamas, October 7 attack​

A total of 75% of respondents agreed with the October 7 attack and 74.7% agreed that they support a single Palestinian state “from the river to the sea.”​




link to the poll: https://www.awrad.org/files/server/... Poll - Gaza War 2023 - Tables of Results.pdf



and of course, reddit mods being reddit mods, deleted it:


Screenshot-2023-11-20-184430.png
 
what?
Sorry my bad, it was Marc Lamont Hill. I mixed up my CNN guys.
Marc Lamont Hill fired from CNN after his speech on Israel draws outrage (Dec 1, 2018)
"I do not support anti-Semitism, killing Jewish people, or any of the other things attributed to my speech," Hill wrote in a tweet afterward.


They've been weird for some time. Not sure I can handle more... What do you think is going to happen? Give me a few minutes to prepare the 🍿
We're seeing radical shift in global politics and a dying, desperate empire (USA/Israel) realizing that their global dominance is coming to an end (and they're really not happy about it).

In the media the line of defense that Israel/Zionism had enjoyed previously is kinda crumbling. People are starting to see what is really going on and tides are shifting bigtime. I just saw Charlie Kirk and Ben Shapiro doing damage control, talking about how some leftist Jews have funded open border and anti-white movements. That's the type of talk that was relegated to the tiki torch people, so to see them admitting that it's happening is unprecedented.

Trump will not go to prison.


He said the World was going to end in 2022 ... that prediction didn't exactly pan out :shrug:
I never said the world was going to end, you sir are a liar and dishonest (you'd be good at the Israeli propaganda).
I warned about upcoming food shortages, which still loom on the horizon (should be thankful I warned you advanced that far).

Food and gas may become unimaginably expensive very soon.
 
Why would the dancing Israeli's, presuming they were directly involved, allow themselves to be caught dancing in public. Or how about Mr Silverstein and his infamous 'pull it' comments? These are so obviously planted breadcrumbs for the simple minded to follow - how is it that out of all the conspirators involved that only the Jewish persons get themselves framed up. Or how about wider afield, with Mr. Rothschild.

Come on dude. You're falling straight into the easy trap. We see clearly what the result of all this is, with the rising anti-Semitic currents all over the place. It's too easy. Someone is using the Jews as the scapegoats, abusing the history in the collective unconscious.. it's a worn groove, and easy to trigger - so is playing up to a good old witch-hunt.

Whether we're talking October 7th or 9/11, it's not as one-dimensional as just taking the target nation in question to be the main conspirator or that the sneaky Jews were the masterminds of it all. The intelligence world bleeds across all borders, and across all the big players in military, banking, corporations, royalty, and others. I'd be willing to bet money that in both instances the whole story is actually a lot more complicated than we think.
They weren't "dancing", you obviously have never read the police reports (evidence) that detailed what happened that day.
They were celebrating, hugging and taking photos of each other after setting up at a vantage point to wait and watch the FIRST plane hit the tower (foreknowledge of the event).
The reason why they were so brazen to be celebrating in public is the same reason that they were quietly released by the FBI without charge a few weeks later - the institutional power that Israel enjoyed in the US.

The posts I'm reading above are just snide name-calling and avoiding the facts. October 7 was a military failure so unbelievable that the only real plausible explanation is that they let it happen on purpose. And now we're seeing reports of IDF soldiers being told in advance and to keep quiet, and also the IDF actually shooting civilians and attacking the cars of the partygoers.
 

Palestinians in Gaza, West Bank strongly support Hamas, October 7 attack​

A total of 75% of respondents agreed with the October 7 attack and 74.7% agreed that they support a single Palestinian state “from the river to the sea.”​




link to the poll: https://www.awrad.org/files/server/polls/polls2023/Public Opinion Poll - Gaza War 2023 - Tables of Results.pdf



and of course, reddit mods being reddit mods, deleted it:


Screenshot-2023-11-20-184430.png
I would dispute the results of that poll but even if it were true, does that somehow give justification to murder people?
All of the people who voted for Obama, are they responsible for his actions and deserving of capital punishment?
These types of polls are somehow used as propaganda to dehumanize innocents, minimize murder and justify collective punishment.
 
I never said the world was going to end, you sir are a liar and dishonest (you'd be good at the Israeli propaganda).
I warned about upcoming food shortages, which still loom on the horizon (should be thankful I warned you advanced that far).

Food and gas may become unimaginably expensive very soon.

the man you promoted in the thread said there would be "lockdowns like we've never seen" , "the implementation of digital currency by the powers that be", and catastrophic food shortages. before the end of 2022.

its almost 2024. 🤔
 
They weren't "dancing", you obviously have never read the police reports (evidence) that detailed what happened that day.
They were celebrating, hugging and taking photos of each other after setting up at a vantage point to wait and watch the FIRST plane hit the tower (foreknowledge of the event).
The reason why they were so brazen to be celebrating in public is the same reason that they were quietly released by the FBI without charge a few weeks later - the institutional power that Israel enjoyed in the US.

The posts I'm reading above are just snide name-calling and avoiding the facts. October 7 was a military failure so unbelievable that the only real plausible explanation is that they let it happen on purpose. And now we're seeing reports of IDF soldiers being told in advance and to keep quiet, and also the IDF actually shooting civilians and attacking the cars of the partygoers.

Dude you need to take your mad ravings/conspiracy talk to the Dive...

Sorry my bad, it was Marc Lamont Hill. I mixed up my CNN guys.
Marc Lamont Hill fired from CNN after his speech on Israel draws outrage (Dec 1, 2018)

Nice to see you are in lockstep with The Squad. From the river to the sea is widely used as a genocidal battle cry of Hamas and other terrorist sympathizers.

TranslateHate_Web-Riversea-InLine_200.png


Palestinian hijacker Leila Khaled (PFLP)

If I'm generous and say this is a phrase that can be interpreted different ways by different people, well that makes me think of things like the Confederate Flag in the US. I wonder though, why does Amazon allow one and not the other....
 
I would dispute the results of that poll but even if it were true, does that somehow give justification to murder people?
All of the people who voted for Obama, are they responsible for his actions and deserving of capital punishment?
These types of polls are somehow used as propaganda to dehumanize innocents, minimize murder and justify collective punishment.

so basically anyone who brings up Hamas suddenly supports murdering innocent people now?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top