• MDMA &
    Empathogenic
    Drugs

    Welcome Guest!
  • MDMA Moderators: Esperighanto

Impaired Tryptophan Metabolism Post-MDMA Usage

Zalo

Bluelighter
Joined
Oct 11, 2012
Messages
410
Location
Land of Glucose
Hey BlueLight,

I was looking at journal articles and came across an interesting one. The last paragraph summarized the article. (Note: T+ refers to the group that was given an amino acid drink that contained tryptophan)

Curran (2003) states that, "In summary, the major finding of this study was that men who had not taken MDMA for an average of 2.5 years showed elevated levels of plasma tryptophan following T+ which were strongly correlated with their performance on a prose recall task. Ex-users showing the poorest memory function at baseline were also those who metabolized least tryptophan. Ex-users showed enhanced sensitivity to tryptophan challenge and performed worse on several cognitive tests than current users or controls. There may be pre-existing differences in tryptophan metabolism in those who quit using this drug (compared with those who continue using it) and these may make them more vulnerable to the adverse effects of MDMA. At the same time, MDMA may have effects on 5-HT function and working and episodic memory that emerge after people stop using the drug and are evident for more than a year later."

So even after long term abstinence it seems as though tryptophan metabolism is less than base line levels leading to impairments in some domains in memory function. I also find it quite interesting that current users did better than ex-users after drinking the amino acid formula with tryptophan. It seems as if once you quit using MDMA you shouldn't get back into it. The ex-users had done MDMA more than 20 times within a year and current users had done MDMA more than 20 times within the past year. The frequency is definitely beyond harm reduction standards, but this kind of info turns me off from using MDMA. I'll still be doing MDMA next month, however, but I'm considering it being my last. If this so happens to be something already well known, then I'd feel rather silly, but it was news to me.

[Edit: The following paragraph was based on a retracted paper where methamphetamine was used instead of MDMA.] Another interesting tidbit I found as I was reading the discussion said that re-dosing may actually lead to dopaminergic neurotoxicity in addition to the serotonergic neurotoxicity. This was found in a different study where they gave non-human primates a 2mg/kg dose 3 times within 6 hours (Ricaurte et al. 2002).

References:

Curran, H. L. (2003). Altered response to tryptophan supplementation after long-term abstention from MDMA (ecstasy) is highly correlated with human memory function Tryptophan challenge and memory in MDMA users. Psychopharmacology, 169(1), 91.

Ricaurte, G. D. (2002). Severe Dopaminergic Neurotoxicity in Primates After a Common Recreational Dose Regimen of MDMA ('Ecstasy'). Science, 297(5590), 2260-2263.
 
Last edited:
That second paper was retracted because it was meth, not MDMA they used in the test. It started a huge uproar in the scientific community.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retracted_article_on_dopaminergic_neurotoxicity_of_MDMA

The tryptophan test is not surprising, however.

That said, this is still not a controlled test. Chances are that most of those ex-users had used MDA or methamphetamine or insert-chemical-here without realizing it and also ex-users probably used other drugs as well.
 
Wasn't Ricaurte the "scientist" that "accidently" gave monkeys methamphetamine instead of MDMA? His credibility is pretty much shot with me after that one, pretty obvious where his bias lies (pun intended)



It is known around here that the TPH enzyme is effected by MDMA in a very negative way, and that is the reasoning behind using 5-HTP actually. I don't think this is anything new though, more just confirms what we already know.. they're good studies though, so kudos for pulling them up.

I don't see this as a reason to stop using, just to be careful. As I remember you are pretty damn responsible with your dosing, I think if it were really such a worrying problem we would have heard much more about it by now.
 
The name Ricaurte did sound familiar.

I wanted to post this study because people, like myself, had believed that everything becomes fine and dandy after long term abstinence, which apparently isn't the case. Dosing 5-HTP works, but after reading this study it seems as though it's just a bandaid for a wound that will never heal. Also, after reading countless other studies the general consensus is that MDMA causes lasting memory and cognitive impairments albeit their MDMA using participants tend to fall in line with those that abuse MDMA. A few studies and meta-analyses I've read counted for confounding factors such as amphetamine, marijuana, and alcohol use and concluded that memory impairment is correlated with MDMA usage. Mood seems to go back to normal after taking a break though, so mood disorders are unfortunately the last thing to worry about after abuse. I'll probably be taking at least a 6 month break after my next usage if I do intend to do it again.

Here's to hoping for a study that uses participants that practice harm reduction.
 
Last edited:
The only way to truly conduct a legitimate study about the longterm effects of MDMA would be to dole out pharmaceutical grade MDMA and run the tests. Yet another situation where prohibition hampers legitimate scientific research, let alone harm reduction from usage.

I am definitely an example of a very heavy abuser of MDMA and I can confirm that I have definitely suffered cognitive deficits, particularly in terms of mathematical computation. I haven't touched the stuff in over two years and there are definite deficits but I've been improving. I should also note that most of my days of using "ecstasy" consisted of MDA, caffeine, and sometimes methamphetamine combination pills because we simply didn't have decent pills unless you paid a lot more and quite frankly, I enjoyed the MDA high more than MDMA until I started having panic attacks.

With all of that said, I have no doubt that responsible occasional use of MDMA will not cause lasting damage. Most of us had or have very unsafe practices. Redosing, massive doses, binging by going to after parties, stacking more drugs on top. I mean I mixed MDMA with just about everything that I knew wouldn't cause excessive stimulation or serotonin syndrome.
 
Top