Helping inmates break free

phr

Bluelighter
Joined
May 25, 2004
Messages
36,649
Location
St. Charles, IL
Helping inmates break free
Kelly Brewington
BALTIMORE SUN
4.13.09



BALTIMORE - Beyond the iron gate, the fence, and the razor wire, 10 inmates in maroon uniforms sit in stillness, listening to the serene sounds of sitar music. Eyes closed, hands folded, they await the tiny pricks of acupuncture needles inserted delicately into their ears.

Ancient Chinese medicine came to Baltimore's jail 16 years ago with the promise of curbing the cravings of drug addiction. Since then, acupuncture has been the centerpiece of a treatment program that serves nearly 700 inmates each year.

Modern science has not found solid evidence that it works. Nonetheless, the inmates contend that with acupuncture, all they crave are the meditative moments it brings. They say it soothes them and helps clear their cluttered minds so they can confront their addiction.

"I've done buprenorphine and methadone, but neither one of them could compare to those needles," says Derrick Brooks, 42, who has battled heroin addiction his entire adult life. "Those needles put you in touch with stuff that's within you that no pill or nothing else could do."

District Judge Jamey H. Hueston thinks every addict should try it. "I am a huge fan of acupuncture," says Hueston, who presides over the city's drug court. "I have sent people in there kicking and screaming, resentful and scowling at me. And later they say, 'Judge, thank you.' "

In the 1970s, doctors in a New York hospital began trying the ancient technique to treat heroin addiction. Since then, hundreds of clinics have popped up around the world. Acupuncture has also become part of drug-treatment programs, though even supporters say it should be combined with counseling.

Acupuncture is by no means universal for prisoners. Pennsylvania and New Jersey state prisons, for example, do not provide acupuncture for inmates, spokesmen said last week.

Acupuncture is the key element of the drug-abuse program administered by the Baltimore drug court. Beginning for women in 1993 and for men three years later, the program steers nonviolent offenders to a rigorous 45-day behind-bars regimen in lieu of a longer prison term.

In addition to 25 acupuncture sessions, inmates receive group and individual counseling, GED training, and life-skills classes. Recently, the program added a family-mediation option for addicts who long ago burned family bridges but want to mend them.

Participants reside in a separate dorm at the city detention center, away from the general population, and are encouraged to rely on one another for support.

The theory behind the acupuncture treatment is that it releases naturally occurring chemicals in the body that ease the symptoms of drug withdrawal and help users fight their addiction.

An acupuncturist places superfine stainless-steel needles in five points in the outer ear, each one designed to evoke a particular feeling, from calming the spirit to acceptance to reminding a person of his will power. The recipient then sits quietly for 30 to 40 minutes. Lights are dimmed, and soft music plays to promote meditation.

Eastern-medicine experts say that what is at work is not just New Age wishful thinking.

The treatment causes the body to release feel-good chemicals called endorphins, which go to the same receptors in the brain that are turned on when someone takes drugs, says Dr. Lixing Lao, director of the traditional Chinese medicine program at the University of Maryland's Center for Integrative Medicine.

The technique works to treat pain in the same way, says Lao, who also treats patients who have been critically injured.

"The concept is very obvious," he says. "If acupuncture works for pain, it should work for heroin addiction."

At a cost of $40,000 a year for all 688 inmates, the acupuncture portion of the Baltimore jail program is cheap by most treatment standards. But its supporters stress that, to be effective, it must be used with counseling and other services.

The state Division of Correction does not track inmates after they complete the program and does not keep data on whether addicts stay clean. A 2002 Yale study also failed to support earlier research suggesting a benefit.

But Mohammad Riaz Ahmad, the program's director, points to studies that suggest acupuncture's effectiveness. A 2001 study of an acupuncture program at Baltimore's Penn North Neighborhood Center found that nearly one-third of patients stayed in the program for at least 30 sessions, or about three months, and that their rate of being arrested and charged decreased.

"We are not saying it's curing addiction - there is no cure for addiction," says Dave Wurzel, a certified acupuncturist whose firm does the jail's treatments. "Just like there is no cure for heart disease or diabetes. All we are doing in addiction treatment is lowering the risk factor that this person will die today of his or her addiction."

Officials with the jail program say the big problem comes when it's time for participants to be released.

About 80 percent of inmates who complete the program need the structured support of a residential treatment facility for as long as a year afterward, officials say. But demand for such treatment is so great that the facilities don't bother to keep a waiting list, says Gregory C. Warren, who heads Baltimore Substance Abuse Systems, the quasi-governmental agency that oversees drug treatment in the city.

Graduates of the acupuncture program often are referred to outpatient programs instead of residential centers. If those slots are full, the inmates sometimes must be held in the general prison population for up to several weeks until a treatment space opens up.

"If it's one day, it's bad," says Danny McCoy, the detention center's assistant warden. "Back inside the institution, they are encountering all the things and people that would defeat the purpose of all they have learned in the treatment process."

The lure of the street is even worse, says Brooks, who took part in the jail's acupuncture program a decade ago. He stayed clean for six years.

He had started selling drugs at age 12, the same year his mother moved in with her boyfriend and left him to largely fend for himself. At 17, he snorted heroin for the first time.

But after his first stint in the acupuncture program, he felt transformed. He fell in love, got married and had a baby boy. Brooks worked two jobs, and lived with his family in a rented house they hoped to buy.

Eventually, though, he started hanging out with old friends in the drug game and stopped going to church and to Narcotics Anonymous meetings. One day, he tried a "tester" of heroin being hawked on a corner. Just one hit, he thought. By the time he was arrested last year, he was doing $200 a day worth of dope.

"I gave back six years in three seconds," he says, wiping away tears. "Why? Please don't ask me that. That's why I'm here now, trying to figure out why."

Brooks graduated last month, complete with a cap, gown, and celebration. But he doesn't want any accolades. He knows his biggest accomplishment lies ahead.

"When I get back in society, that's when the real test comes," he says. "This is nothing compared to what I got to do."

Link!
 
Accupuncture sure has a great angle on our society. No matter how many studies prove no technique effects its effectiveness, and that any placebo treatment works just as well, people can't get enough of it.

I'd even do accupuncture if I trusted the guy had clean shit. Well maybe.
 
^^ I have used accupuncture for recurring headaches and definitely felt results. It seems to me like something that is a complete sham wouldn't last thousands of years and be used in a variety of cultures.
 
^^ I have used accupuncture for recurring headaches and definitely felt results. It seems to me like something that is a complete sham wouldn't last thousands of years and be used in a variety of cultures.

Just like organized religion and sacrifices!
 
District Judge Jamey H. Hueston thinks every addict should try it. "I am a huge fan of acupuncture," says Hueston, who presides over the city's drug court. "I have sent people in there kicking and screaming, resentful and scowling at me. And later they say, 'Judge, thank you.' "



8o
 
I had a fucked back a few years ago that a year of physio didn't fix, tried acupuncture going 2 or 3 times a month, few months later the pain was totally gone and throughout the period I noticed the pain constantly diminishing until it was gone. Still a bit skeptical about treating drug addiction though. I read somewhere the reason its effective for pain is that it stimulates bloodflow to places that don't get as much (like my back for instance) to help it heal, that theory certainly wouldn't apply to addiction though.
 
^^ I have used accupuncture for recurring headaches and definitely felt results. It seems to me like something that is a complete sham wouldn't last thousands of years and be used in a variety of cultures.

If Eastern medicine was truly superior there would have been no need for Western medicine to develop. They would have just copied the Chinese. That being said, if one believes in acupuncture and it helps contain their addiction then go with that.
 
If Eastern medicine was truly superior there would have been no need for Western medicine to develop. They would have just copied the Chinese. That being said, if one believes in acupuncture and it helps contain their addiction then go with that.

Western medicine is based on knowing why something works (science), eastern medicine is about results. Western medicine allows us to tackle things like cancer and aids, things eastern medicine couldn't touch. But one should not assume just because our medicine is more advanced these day, that older medicine is somehow less effective.

No experience with acupuncture, but heard lots of good things. Its certainly worth a shot before going on pain meds.
 
Western medicine is based on knowing why something works (science), eastern medicine is about results. Western medicine allows us to tackle things like cancer and aids, things eastern medicine couldn't touch. But one should not assume just because our medicine is more advanced these day, that older medicine is somehow less effective.

No experience with acupuncture, but heard lots of good things. Its certainly worth a shot before going on pain meds.

No, one should assume older medicine is less effective based off of empirical data. Western medicine is just as much about results as Eastern medicine, except that Western medicine must stand up to testing to be declared valid.
I will never understand why people can't grasp the scientific method.
 
No, one should assume older medicine is less effective based off of empirical data. Western medicine is just as much about results as Eastern medicine, except that Western medicine must stand up to testing to be declared valid.
I will never understand why people can't grasp the scientific method.

Lots of things are still a mystery about the body though.

Take the post by drug_mentor talking about his back, which there isn't yet a complete understanding of as far as treating back pain. He could have gone to a chiropractor or physical therapy for a long time and only seen some positive results. In his case, he got a better result from an alternative practice like accupuncture.


I've never had it done, but my mom has gotten it many times and she says it definitely has a positive effect for her. Makes her tired the day she gets it done though.
 
Lots of things are still a mystery about the body though.

Take the post by drug_mentor talking about his back, which there isn't yet a complete understanding of as far as treating back pain. He could have gone to a chiropractor or physical therapy for a long time and only seen some positive results. In his case, he got a better result from an alternative practice like accupuncture.


I've never had it done, but my mom has gotten it many times and she says it definitely has a positive effect for her. Makes her tired the day she gets it done though.

Chiropractic medicine is an alternative medicine, it is not recognized by the AMA.

Just because your mom has positive effects doesen't mean it is a valid treatment. It means that your mom is experiencing the placebo effect, something all too many bluelighters swear by when they look down upon generics.

That is why actual testing is needed, and that is where acupuncture falls short. Studies have shown it to be completely ineffective, and have attributed situations like your mom's to the placebo effect. That is the beauty of Western Medicine, you know, actual results.
 
She hasn't gotten any ACTUAL results from western medicine though.

Maybe drug_mentor could have just been on pain management for the rest of his life, I'm sure that would be dandy.



Whatever, Western medicine knows everything, it's so great. Happy?
 
She hasn't gotten any ACTUAL results from western medicine though.

Maybe drug_mentor could have just been on pain management for the rest of his life, I'm sure that would be dandy.



Whatever, Western medicine knows everything, it's so great. Happy?

So you abandon good methodology because it hasn't produced a cure yet? Not a lot of logic there.

I never stated Western medicince knows everything, I stated that it is the only reliable method to try and determine all the answers. No need to get pissy because all you have is anecdotal evidence that amounts to placebo effects, just get educated.
 
Enlitx, I am not a big proponent of eastern medicine and whatnot, and I generally believe western medicine to be superior. However, I think that you are being pretty narrowminded, I mean I saw it on a show that said its good for back pain, I had a year of physio and it was no better so figured what do I have to lose by trying it. I was a fucking skeptic but when I started going to acupuncture it cleared up within months and has hardly bothered me since, by that I mean I may notice a slight pinching sort of feeling there every few months when I move funny but nothing that impacts on my day to day life.

You may consider my experience to be a placebo, but I am curious what you base that on other than "no scientific studies have proven it to be true", there are plenty of things that are not substantiated by science that are regarded as fact by a large percentage of people. There are plenty of things that we now consider to be common knowledge that at one point in history were not substantiated by science, does that mean our current facts were not true then because nobody had proved it?

Enlitx, do you have any explanation why acupuncture would have a placebo effect that western medicine did not? If both treatments were undergone why would the acupuncture have this effect when western medicine did not? It seems especially strange for people like me who expected western treatment to work and were skeptical of acupuncture, if one would expect any of them to have a positive placebo effect wouldn't you think it would be the western methods? Scientists and doctors aren't even close to fully understanding backs and back injury for example, so how can you presume they fully understand how to treat it?
 
Top