Well first when I say "beta blocker" I'm refering mainly to inderal. There are beta blockers like toprol that don't do shit and are mainly prescribed for high blood pressure.
Ocean: You are right klonopin DOES do *something* for physical anxiety. But in cases where physical anxiety is the main component of anxiety, doctors usually prescribe inderal. Klonopin is more of a "head med", its stronger than xanax at relaxing the body I'll give it that, but in comparison to how a strong betablocker works a betablocker is less likely to leave "gaps" where physical anxiety can still manifest. Even when I told my doctor the klonopin didn't do shit for keeping my body in check he said it was normal and thats why a lot of times he stacks inderal with it. And when I say "didn't do shit" YES I felt how it calms the body... but it was still largely a joke. I'd walk into social situations on 6mg of that crap and my heart would slow down a whole 2 beats a minute.
I'm not trying to trash klonopin, its a great drug, but it doesn't quite do it for people with extreme physical anxiety.
Legerity: What beta blocker did you take and how much? The whole thing with betablockers is you will NOT notice you're on them untill you are exposed to a trigger.
If you take 60mg of inderal, and stand in front of an approaching train, I don't care who you are you heart is not going to skip a beat. Only a very tiny amount of people who take inderal report it not doing anything for them.
Read askapatient.com and you'll see like 95% of the people on there praising it. Go read about klonopin and see how many people trash talk it for not doing shit for physical anxiety.
Klonopin has an effect where you can "feel" it slowing down your body w/out actually being triggered. Thats because it works more on your brain. But if someone points a gun at you on klonopin, theres a good chance your heart is still going to race, klonopin doesn't do a single thing to modify adrenaline. Your heart can NOT race unless there is a prior surge of adrenaline in your blood. I don't think people understand this basic fact. Thats why if you wanna chill your heart out, and your entire body, take inderal.
Let me explain briefly how anxiety tends to work:
You're exposed to a trigger, your head produces an initial anxious thought, your body RESPONDS to the thought by triggering adrenaline.
That adrenaline floods your blood, makes your heart race, speeds up your breathing, makes you sweaty, makes you shake, makes you stutter (which then turns into a feedback loop often).
Klonopin "stops" this by attaching to receptors in smooth muscles and basically just relaxes your heart. If you take A LOT of klonopin, it will work A LOT better obviously, but it still not doing anything for adrenaline which is the core. It works indirectly through the CNS.
What that means is in order to achieve the same depressed affect, on the heart specifically, the amount of klonopin you have to actually take can make you sick. It works indirectly/inefficiently.
Strong betablockers attach directly the your adrenal receptors. There is NO WAY your heart is racing on them. On klonopin in order to have the same effect you'd prob have to take like 10mg. And you'll wind up passing out/falling asleep.
The whole point of inderal is its more effective, and will not do shit to your brain so your a slurring zombie when it comes time to face your triggers... w/e they are.
And like I said before, if the main component of your anxiety is you can't control your thoughts, than inderal will be a waste of time.