Only found this thread through RP, which is probably a sign I should get around more than I do. There's some interesting stuff here in SO.
Strangely enough, last year I was finally persuaded (by my most recent ex, who is still my one of my closest friends) to take out a pair of earrings which had been bought for me by a girl I split up with back in early 2005.
Her excuse was because they were gold they made me look like a 'scally / chav' (apologies for UK culturally-based colloquialisms, but I can't think of a direct international equivalent) but it was maybe a mildly possessive thing as well as a fashion tip.
I still keep them and may wear them occasionally but I've grown used to myself without them. The ironic thing is that I'd actually almost forgotten their association with the girl who purchased them, yet occasionally I'll find other things like a bookmark she made for me, and maybe sigh and reminisce. At one time it would've choked me up, but it would appear time has healed, as the well-worn saying goes.
So I answered 'maybe' but I can see why anyone would either throw every trace of their ex away, or in certain circumstances hang on to something, especially if the person in question died. Or even if the jewellery's just especially nice.
