• N&PD Moderators: Skorpio

Clearify please!

These data provide evidence that 6 months after MDMA-induced damage serotonergic axons show recovery in most brain areas, but serotonergic functions to challenges with SSRIs including anxiety and aggression remain altered.

Time is the major factor in MDMA recovery - 6 months is enough to heal most structural damage (in rats, after huge doses of MDMA injected intraperitoneally (into the body cavity)), but response to SSRI medications (versus rats who have never done MDMA) was still altered.
 
It's on the effects of POST treatment of SSRIs after MDMA nuerotoxic dose, and no not to prevent toxicity, but a 6 month course for repair!

Also should point out the paper is not about using SSRI's to help repair MDMA damage (I wish it was, more research, or should i say some research, needs to be done on this). They just use rats that were treated with high dose MDMA 6 months prior verse rats that were not to determine how SSRI's function in a MDMA 'recovered' rat brain. They concluded that SSRI's reduced anxiety inducing ability in social tests were likely due to reduced SERT density.
 
I'd advise against this. You need things that will actually help your brain to restore it's balance. Fucking with your serotonin receptors even more is going to hinder your progress, and get you dependent on other chemicals.

I just went through 7 days of SNRI-related withdrawal. It's certainly worse than any benzo/depressant withdrawal I've experienced. Living hell and back, with full-on out of this world vivid nightmares. It's just now started to let up a little, but still prevalent.

Exercise, eat properly, and maybe take some 5-htp. You'll be back to your old self in no time.
 
^^ it's been 8 months for me already, almost nine (if you don't consider a slip up about 2 months ago where I rolled once) and I'm still having sleep problems, ED problems, which is depressing in of itself. Depression too I must admit, thinking problems, and I seem to be lacking frontal lobe functions, especially when it comes to socializing, I can't "feel" anyone emotionally, I'm flat.

What about this;

"Our results demonstrate that the serotonin reuptake inhibitor fluoxetine increases the density of serotonin innervation of cortical and limbic forebrain areas shown by both 5-HT and SERT ICC, for reasons unrelated to the regulation of TPH-2 or SERT in serotonin cell bodies of projection neurons in dorsal and median raphe. Similar effects were seen with the serotonin reuptake enhancer tianeptine. Serotonergic antidepressants that target non-serotonin amines, such as desipramine, do not share the effects of fluoxetine and tianeptine on serotonin fiber density. It is possible that the effects of neurotransmitter-specific antidepressants on monoamine fiber density are selective to their cognate neurotransmitter system, as also suggested by a study on 6-OHDA lesioned rats in which desipramine was shown to promote sprouting of central catecholaminergic fibers visualized with glyoxylic acid-induced fluorescence (Nakamura 1990). It should be emphasized, however, that all these effects must be demonstrated in normal animals, because lesioned monoamine systems may be primed to the restorative effects of antidepressants or trophic peptides (Koliatsos et al. 2000).



Under the experimental conditions of this study, serotonin antidepressants increased the density of 5-HT-immunoreactive axons without a parallel increase in the mRNA expression of the 5-HT-synthesizing enzyme TPH-2. They also increased SERT fiber density without significant effects in SERT mRNA expression in the raphe complex. Both patterns would argue against a mere effect of serotonergic compounds on 5-HT and SERT content of serotonin fibers and would support the idea of a structural effect of these compounds on serotonin axons, i.e. sprouting. However, this straightforward interpretation is applicable primarily to the case of SERT. TPH-2 activity, i.e. the rate-limiting step in 5-HT biosynthesis, is under complex regulation not only by levels of TPH-2 mRNA, but also a number of post-transcriptional factors, including brain levels of tryptophan (Neckers et al. 1977; Fernstrom 1982; Gartside et al. 1992) and phosphorylation of the enzyme by protein kinases (Stenfors and Ross 2002). Although, in the present study, we did not directly examine whether serotonin antidepressant treatments increased tryptophan levels or TPH-2 phosphorylation in the brain, several pharmacological studies have shown decreased brain levels of tryptophan (Neckers et al. 1977; Nakayama et al. 2003) and 5-HT (Durand et al. 1999; Stenfors et al. 2001; Yamane et al. 2001; Nakayama et al. 2003) after chronic administration of a number of serotonin reuptake inhibitors including chlomipramine, sertraline, paroxetine and citalopram.



Our three-dimensional analysis of anterogradely filled dorsal raphe terminals shows increased branching of these terminals in the index site of piriform cortex in fluoxetine-treated animals. This finding lends further support to the idea that serotonin antidepressants cause structural, as opposed to biochemical, changes in serotonin axons. A number of neurotoxic models of serotonin injury suggest that serotonin terminals may be especially prone to regenerative sprouting (Fischer et al. 1995; Mamounas et al. 1995; Mamounas et al. 2000) and we propose that this phenomenon, which is limited to terminal axons, may be the key structural effect of serotonin antidepressants.



The brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), a robust trophic signal for serotonin neurons (Mamounas et al. 1995; Lyons et al. 1999; Madhav et al. 2001), is a prime candidate for causing serotonin fiber sprouting (Mamounas et al. 1995; Lyons et al. 1999; Mattson et al. 2004). BDNF itself is regulated by levels of synaptically available 5-HT and subsequent 5-HT signaling (Nibuya et al. 1995; Zetterstrom et al. 1999). In some studies, BDNF and its transducing receptor element trkB have been found to be up-regulated by chronic treatment with antidepressants, including serotonin reuptake inhibitors (Nibuya et al. 1995). In unpublished experiments, we have not found significant differences in BDNF or trkB mRNA expression in neocortex and neostriatum between animals treated with fluoxetine and liposyn by northern blotting and RT–PCR; however, BDNF in situ hybridization and ICC show increased mRNA and protein signal in layer V pyramids and pyramidal neurons in layer II of piriform cortex in animals treated with fluoxetine (Koliatsos V. E., Bora S. H. and Zhou L., personal observations). Together, these findings indicate that, if BDNF up-regulation and increased BDNF signaling is part of the mechanism of serotonin axon changes we observed in this study, these trophic events are likely to be limited to circumscribed forebrain sites and specific cortical layers.



A precisely localized, trophic mechanism of sprouting is also a plausible explanation for the concordant effects of fluoxetine and tianeptine, i.e. two antidepressant compounds with opposite pharmacological effects on serotonin reuptake. In general, the relationships between brain 5-HT concentrations and BDNF expression are very complex, e.g. acute increases in 5-HT with p-chloroamphetamine, or with the monoamine oxidase inhibitor tranylcypromine, or the combined administration of tranylcypromine and l-tryptophan, lower BDNF expression in some brain areas such as dentate gyrus, but increase BDNF mRNA expression in medial frontal cortex (Zetterstrom et al. 1999). Interestingly, 5-HT depletion with high-dose p-chloroamphetamine can also result in BDNF mRNA increases in the parietal and frontal cortex (Zetterstrom et al. 1999). Therefore, both higher (such as caused by serotonin reuptake inhibitors) and lower (such as effected by tianeptine) concentrations of extracellular 5-HT may induce BDNF expression in areas studied in this paper, such as the fronto-parietal cortex. Caution with this hypothesis is advised by a previous study showing no correlation between tianeptine treatment and BDNF mRNA level in various hippocampal subfields with in situ hybridization (Kuroda and McEwen 1998); however, the enormously complex regulation of BDNF by antidepressants in this brain area (Nibuya et al. 1995; Zetterstrom et al. 1999) warrants further investigations with quantitative PCR in carefully microdissected preparations of hippocampal subfields.



Cortical laminae IV-V and the shell region of accumbens, i.e. sites in which the effects of serotonin antidepressants on serotonin fiber density are especially obvious, are also prime targets for 5-HT-induced activation of the forebrain after treatment with dexfenfluramine (Lyons et al. 1999). Thus, it appears that increases in serotonin fiber density correlate, at least on the basis of pharmacological and anatomical evidence, with increased postsynaptic effects of serotonin. A local up-regulation of BDNF induced by certain antidepressants may provide a possible link between increased serotonin neurotransmission and fiber sprouting. For example, in the case of the neocortex, agonism at the major postsynaptic serotonin site 5-HT2A which is especially concentrated in upper layer V (Blue et al. 1988) appears to cause a selective induction of BDNF in that cortical layer (Vaidya et al. 1997). However, the BDNF action site and BDNF induction site may be different, given the avid anterograde transport of this neurotrophin (Conner et al. 1997), and the exact local regulation and transduction of this neurotrophin with antidepressant treatments must be studied in considerable anatomical detail. In concert, our findings suggest that serotonin antidepressants may cause very selective structural effects on central 5-HT axons and invite further studies on the role of neurotrophins as mediators of these effects."


This almost seems to mediate that SSRIs can sprout axons in regions MDMA damages.

I was thinking a short term treatment, as in between 4-6 months, NO longer.
 
1. These studies are in healthy, non-"damaged" rats, whos' brains are taken apart after the study and examined with a microscope. You wouldn't like that very much

2. Structural changes mean very little if they aren't correlated to behavior or some other observable factor

3. You very likely are assuming the presence of "brain damage" in yourself, which is a very vague term, and a risky assumption. I apologize if you had an MRI done both pre- and post- MDMA usage, but the simple fact is I have yet to see anyone who has.
3b. By the time your frontal lobe is fucked, you're too late to realize it.
3c. 8 months is a long time for your brain to remodel itself. It's also a long time to psychologically imprint yourself with the idea you are "damaged", and put your lifestyle into a depressive spin.

4. There is a modicum of evidence pointing towards most SSRI drugs being no more than placebo and highly disruptive when initiating and terminating therapy.
4b. This study only noted changes with the use of tianeptine and fluoxetine.
4c. There's also a suggestion that 5-HT2a agonists would be useful, but I haven't heard anyone claiming LSD/2c-E/psilocin will fix your "brain damage".

5. The average American lives a lifestyle saturated with automation, bueracracy, sloth, crushing levels of stress, and a deficit of fresh colorful greens and vegetables. Enriched cereals and "low-fat" foods only go so far, and stress levels are often through the roof while people steadfastly refuse to take a vacation and instead live their repetitive working day over and over. Depression and ED can be stress-linked.
5b. Depression and ED can be genetically linked, too.

My personal suggestion (take it with a grain of salt, I'm not a psyhciatrist, just a drug user) is to talk to your doctor and evaluate your lifestyle. Are you really happy with yourself? Do you live where you want to live? Are you working for someone you don't know doing something you don't like all day? Do you eat McDonalds 5 days a week? Do you even eat breakfast? Do you drink 5 cups of coffee a day? Are you a chain smoker? Do you prefer a stimulating or a calm environment? There's too many factors to keep track of, but they all contribute. Personally I think that most of these problems ascribed to "brain damage" and "HPPD" are internal signs to the person experiencing them that it's time for a lifestyle change.

Pain doesn't exist for no reason. It's a sign you have to change something because it's not working out for you. Masking it doesn't help anything.
 
^ some good advice from sekio. I just want to add - my mom works with young people with brain damage (as well as old people suffering from neurodegenerative disorders) There is no way you have damaged your frontal lobes, because if you did, you wouldn't be aware that you had. It deals with consciousness, forward planning and awareness - all three things your posts clearly demonstrate. I don't want to patronize you by claiming it's all in your head, because some of it may well not be - but seriously, if TBI patients have a good short and long term memory and can form logical sentences and reason it is usually a very good sign of potential recovery. I would stay away from the SSRI's though - big pharma are behind alot of the research (google ben goldacre). Hope you get well soon.
 
Last edited:
1. These studies are in healthy, non-"damaged" rats, whos' brains are taken apart after the study and examined with a microscope. You wouldn't like that very much

2. Structural changes mean very little if they aren't correlated to behavior or some other observable factor

3. You very likely are assuming the presence of "brain damage" in yourself, which is a very vague term, and a risky assumption. I apologize if you had an MRI done both pre- and post- MDMA usage, but the simple fact is I have yet to see anyone who has.
3b. By the time your frontal lobe is fucked, you're too late to realize it.
3c. 8 months is a long time for your brain to remodel itself. It's also a long time to psychologically imprint yourself with the idea you are "damaged", and put your lifestyle into a depressive spin.

4. There is a modicum of evidence pointing towards most SSRI drugs being no more than placebo and highly disruptive when initiating and terminating therapy.
4b. This study only noted changes with the use of tianeptine and fluoxetine.
4c. There's also a suggestion that 5-HT2a agonists would be useful, but I haven't heard anyone claiming LSD/2c-E/psilocin will fix your "brain damage".

5. The average American lives a lifestyle saturated with automation, bueracracy, sloth, crushing levels of stress, and a deficit of fresh colorful greens and vegetables. Enriched cereals and "low-fat" foods only go so far, and stress levels are often through the roof while people steadfastly refuse to take a vacation and instead live their repetitive working day over and over. Depression and ED can be stress-linked.
5b. Depression and ED can be genetically linked, too.

My personal suggestion (take it with a grain of salt, I'm not a psyhciatrist, just a drug user) is to talk to your doctor and evaluate your lifestyle. Are you really happy with yourself? Do you live where you want to live? Are you working for someone you don't know doing something you don't like all day? Do you eat McDonalds 5 days a week? Do you even eat breakfast? Do you drink 5 cups of coffee a day? Are you a chain smoker? Do you prefer a stimulating or a calm environment? There's too many factors to keep track of, but they all contribute. Personally I think that most of these problems ascribed to "brain damage" and "HPPD" are internal signs to the person experiencing them that it's time for a lifestyle change.

Pain doesn't exist for no reason. It's a sign you have to change something because it's not working out for you. Masking it doesn't help anything.

I pretty much agree with most of these notions. I am not a psychiatrist, but any decent physician in the western world must be a de facto psychiatrist (I consider myself decent).

Before my residency, I gave little credence to symptomology that I considered to be "insignificant" or a product of some sort of somatization disorder. But, after being exposed to all manners of suffering, it has been harder to discount these complaints. A somatoform disorder is, regardless of basis, a form of suffering.

As to MDMA........I have seen a few deaths, most which involved massive doses and other drugs. There was a young woman who survived a hypertensive crisis caused by a large amount of DXM, MDMA and MDA. She did have a rather nasty recovery, exhibiting neurological impairment in speech and motor control. Yes, extensive imaging did show apparent damage caused presumably by the very high body temp (it was over 106F upon intake). She eventually regained much of the speech, cognitive and motor control, but did not recover fully. Strangely, she, to my knowledge, did not complain of depression or mood alteration. These cases are rather rare.

Point being, some '6-month' recovery notion does not seem to based on any credible data (to my knowledge). As mentioned by the quoted post, the prevalence of disorders such as HPPD are pervasive in 'e-patients' , there is even a term for this phenomena: Cyberchondriasis......
 
1. These studies are in healthy, non-"damaged" rats, whos' brains are taken apart after the study and examined with a microscope. You wouldn't like that very much

2. Structural changes mean very little if they aren't correlated to behavior or some other observable factor

3. You very likely are assuming the presence of "brain damage" in yourself, which is a very vague term, and a risky assumption. I apologize if you had an MRI done both pre- and post- MDMA usage, but the simple fact is I have yet to see anyone who has.
3b. By the time your frontal lobe is fucked, you're too late to realize it.
3c. 8 months is a long time for your brain to remodel itself. It's also a long time to psychologically imprint yourself with the idea you are "damaged", and put your lifestyle into a depressive spin.

4. There is a modicum of evidence pointing towards most SSRI drugs being no more than placebo and highly disruptive when initiating and terminating therapy.
4b. This study only noted changes with the use of tianeptine and fluoxetine.
4c. There's also a suggestion that 5-HT2a agonists would be useful, but I haven't heard anyone claiming LSD/2c-E/psilocin will fix your "brain damage".

5. The average American lives a lifestyle saturated with automation, bueracracy, sloth, crushing levels of stress, and a deficit of fresh colorful greens and vegetables. Enriched cereals and "low-fat" foods only go so far, and stress levels are often through the roof while people steadfastly refuse to take a vacation and instead live their repetitive working day over and over. Depression and ED can be stress-linked.
5b. Depression and ED can be genetically linked, too.

My personal suggestion (take it with a grain of salt, I'm not a psyhciatrist, just a drug user) is to talk to your doctor and evaluate your lifestyle. Are you really happy with yourself? Do you live where you want to live? Are you working for someone you don't know doing something you don't like all day? Do you eat McDonalds 5 days a week? Do you even eat breakfast? Do you drink 5 cups of coffee a day? Are you a chain smoker? Do you prefer a stimulating or a calm environment? There's too many factors to keep track of, but they all contribute. Personally I think that most of these problems ascribed to "brain damage" and "HPPD" are internal signs to the person experiencing them that it's time for a lifestyle change.

Pain doesn't exist for no reason. It's a sign you have to change something because it's not working out for you. Masking it doesn't help anything.

Brilliant post. I had a feeling giving up the ADs was was the right choice. Thanks for the affirmation.
 
Top