I bought a 4 pack on sale $10 & change so your doing good.
If I recall your relatively local mind if I ask where you acquired Erie Monster at that price?

I agree it was less hoppy than I figured but the other flavors really rounded it out imho.
I see you mentioned Southern Tier Un*Earthly is it worth going out of the way to try?
I'm actually making my way through a Southern Tier pack of Pales variety pack as I type this.
I'm thinking I'll also have to try the Weyerbacher you mentioned.
I've had there Hops Infusion IPA & there Blithering Idiot (A personal favorite) but never ran into there Double Simcoe IPA.
For a slightly different take on an IPA I found Flying Dog's Raging Bitch to be interesting.
In general I've found Flying Dog to be decent & as a Hunter/Ralph fan they get a few bonus points from me on that note.