it was good, but not fantastic, and a bit uninspiring with two many eye-rolling moments
I have some problems with this movie. first off, Batman would NEVER quit for 8 years. not for a woman, and not because of the mess the Joker and Two-Face left in their wake. Batman doesn't have super powers, he gets by because of his immense WILL. I know there are more variations to Batman's character than an MKULTRA victim (from Adam West to Superfriends to Tim Burton's or Paul Dini's Batman to name a few) - but the Bats DOESN'T QUIT. it's who he is and it's what makes him such a strong character. Gotham City needs Batman and Batman needs Gotham City. this fact from the movie almost killed it for me
Nolan tied off his trilogy decently enough by using Jonathan Crane (the Scarecrow) well and by pushing the Ra's-al-Ghul and his League of Shadows envelope back into the fold. I also liked how Batman's past array of jaw-dropping vehicles made their way into this final installment. however, there were more than a few very campy reveals that felt cheap and forced. Talia-al-Ghul's injection into the story was an eye-roller, only to have her you-know-what shortly after
Bane was a good bad-guy, but a little too Lord Humungus for me. I didn't have a problem with Bane's voice (
check out this kewl article to read/hear about the gypsy bare-knuckle boxer that served as the vocal inspiration) and I hated how they degraded Nolan's Bane into basically Joel Schumaker's Bane by that once-again absurd reveal that made him to be pictured once again as nothing more than a one-dimensional guard dog. and I was a little pissed that Bane wasn't from South America, just some random spot half-way around the world (plot-hole)
BUT Nolan completely gave us a "meh" moment when Bane "broke" the Batman. this is a HUGE moment in the mythos of the Bats, and it came across as uninspiring
overall it seems like Nolan didn't know what to do after the untimely demise of Heath Ledger potentially ruined his film's final vision. Christopher Nolan comes across as the smartest kid in the classroom, but the kinda guy that isn't the most interesting to have a conversation with. it seemed like he wasn't having enough fun with Batman and Gotham City. in retrospect, I think I should have placed even more value on the performance of Heath Ledger's Joker in film before
and if you thought the Return of the King had a problem with multiple endings - holy shit, wait till you see this movie
I did enjoy the film. I just had a lot of problems with it - namely the drab breaking of the Bat scene and the fact that Nolan's Batman is a quitter... but these two problematic intricacies PALE in comparison to the "big Robin reveal" at the end. what an eye roller!