When people who are not in need of these meds use them, it is, in my opinion, cheating - don't get me wrong, I used ritalin for an exam (once) and got an A without a single hour of studying (I was expecting an E).
I cheated, and felt so shit I never did it again.
I disagree. It's not like writing the answers on your hand, and if you don't know the answer, then the adderall, ritalin, or whatever stimulant you've taken won't magically put the answer into your head.
It increases one's ability to focus, and any stimulant, caffeine even, will do the same thing; so is the student who chugged an energy drink before studying for the exam somehow cheating? In fact, you don't even need a stimulant to increase your ability to focus. The next time that you study for an exam, put your feet into a bucket and fill it with ice and ice-cold water. They've found that this level of discomfort actually increases an individual's ability to retain information. So is "ice bucketing" now cheating as well?
And if what you're saying is that it increases's an individual's actual performance on the exam, well, I know that I perform much better on exams when I eat a good meal and go to sleep early, and many others find this to be true as well. Again, energy drinks are also a viable option.
It's unfortunate because I
do understand what you're saying in that these are things that are not available to every student; not every student is fortunate enough to have an adderall prescription, but, then again, not every student is fortunate enough to have a home life that's conducive to their studies. It's hard to eat a good meal and go to bed early when your father's a deadbeat, your mother works nights, and you have to look after your brothers and sisters. (I had a student where this was the case, actually, and he didn't perform well on... on any task, actually.)
It's sad, really sad, but again, I don't think that it's "cheating" exactly. I wouldn't say that stimulants are to academics what steroids are to weight-lifting or sports; I would say that stimulants are to academics what protein powder, vitamins and whatever else are to weight-lifting and sports. Do you see what I'm saying?
Because it's not like adderall = knowledge. Again, if you don't know the answer, adderall won't put the answer into your head. You don't pop an adderall and suddenly you know quantum physics. It increases one's ability to focus which in turn increases their ability to study and learn and attain greater knowledge. (They can just as easily go ahead and jerk off for four hours and learn absolutely nothing and bomb the test.)
Taking steroids however, actually results in greater muscle mass and whatever, and so one actually does grow stronger. Protein powder and vitamins and whatever else will just help you to develop the muscle, but you still need to hit the fucking gym. See what I mean?