I get where you're coming from Robot but obviously none of us knows what it feels like to really be dying so that's just a meaningless turn of phrase to start with.
We can argue the terminology for this experience but it doesn't matter, this happens to plenty of people.
I think the terminology is important tho - like using the word "dying" - you arn't "dying" when you're on psychedelics. You might feel a bit uncomfortable and that's about it. Obviously saying "I was, like, DYING dude.." sounds a lot more dramatic when you're telling your pals about the trip you had at the weekend so that's why you'll hear people saying it. It sounds better than saying "I felt a bit uncomfortable". It doesn't prove there's such a thing as the ego-death.
well technically 'you' are dying on psychedelics. The 'you', the individual is becoming one with everything. Freud's theories are just bullshit because they can't be proven, he could very well be right about everything. But Freud aside, have you not had one of these experiences? I use the words dying, ego because it's easier for others to understand what I am talking about, I don't get hung up on the words, the experience is ineffable in itself, best i can describe it as is losing individuality. It's not feeling a bit uncomfortable, there's no 'you' to feel uncomfortable. I forget that i had ever even been a person, just no memory of life whatsoever.
I'm not using the words 'dying' for dramatic effect, and especially not to boast. I imagine that dying is somewhat like what I experience, of course i do not know but the loss of a sense of self, or individuality, the questions that i have like "fuck, did i die?", that is what gives me the inclination to describe the experience as ego death. This isn't a dick measuring contest, it's something that actually happens whether you agree or not, have you not experienced this?
You aren't exactly disproving ego death either or that there is no ego, brain scans aren't going to show it one way or another. It's not all about Freud either, he'd probably attribute ego death in relation to some sort of latent sexual desire for your parents or something, what we are talking about is different. Ego = that thing that desires physical things like food/comfort/water/protection (or the 'I' part of thinking as mentioned above). During a hard psychedelic trip for some reason these desires and the sense of 'I' are destroyed, thus being described as ego death - the loss of physical desires or sense of self. That's pretty clear imo and does not involve Freud.
Perhaps if you didn't think about it in Freudeian terms then it'd be easier to grasp without your bullshit alarm going off. But really you have to experience this state to know what it is about, if you think it's 'a bit uncomfortable' then i don't think that you have been there, you wouldn't describe it as uncomfortable, as you wouldn't have any feelings. If someone has a near death experience people don't usually question them and ask them how they even know what death was like. NDEs are almost exactly the same experience as ego death.