Premier Colin Barnett 'harsh' on drug death girl
Article from: The Australian
Debbie Guest
February 04, 2009 07:02am
PREMIER Colin Barnett has been accused of being harsh and unsympathetic about a teenager's overdose death on Sunday.
Mr Barnett yesterday defended police and their use of drug detection dogs at the Big Day Out event, saying that, although the death of 17-year-old Gemma Thoms was a "very sad situation", the only solution was for young people to "say no" to drugs.
Friends of the apprentice hairdresser believe Gemma had already taken one ecstasy tablet and was waiting to enter the music festival when she panicked at the possibility of being detected and swallowed two other ecstasy tablets in her pocket.
After entering the Claremont Showgrounds, she collapsed and was taken to hospital, where she later died. Police said yesterday the sniffer dogs were used only at the showground's train station and, because Gemma was dropped off, she would not have even seen the dogs.
New South Wales Greens MP Sylvia Hale said the use of sniffer dogs at such events was simply a PR exercise.
She said a 2006 NSW Ombudsman's report identified the problems associated with the use of sniffer dogs and the potential for young people to engage in risky behaviour.
She said Mr Barnett's reaction to Gemma's death had been unsympathetic.
"It's an extraordinarily harsh reaction," Ms Hale said.
"Here we have a death, and a death that was predicted as a possible outcome, for the Premier now to say this is acceptable, I find unacceptable."
Ms Hale said a zero-tolerance approach to drugs had consistently failed.
Council for Civil Liberties in Western Australia president Peter Weygers said Mr Barnett had shown a lack of understanding.
"The Premier's being most unsympathetic to the fact that, here's a young person, immature, probably influenced by a peer group ... has felt the need to take these so-called recreational drugs and then she's panicked when she thought she was going to get caught because she knows the consequences, and it's a tragedy," Mr Weygers said.
Mr Barnett was unapologetic and said police had a responsibility to restrict and stop the use of drugs.
"I will support their actions and continue to have inspections and sniffer dogs at public events," he said.
"The only solution I say to young people is don't use drugs, don't put toxic chemicals into your body, that's not a cool look, that's not a good outcome and we saw that tragedy happen."
Police Commissioner Karl O'Callaghan rejected claims that police were in any way responsible for Gemma's death.
"Some of their propositions are quite frankly absurd and suggest that police should turn a blind eye, do nothing about drug possession, and ignore the state's laws regarding illegal drugs," Mr O'Callaghan said.
Bree Fazioli, a friend and colleague of Gemma, was not at the Big Day Out, but said: "You can't blame police, they've potentially stopped this happening with other people. We would rather that she had been caught and was in court and not at the morgue."
Police seized almost 130 ecstasy tablets at the event and charged four people with possession of drugs with intent to sell or supply, including one man for possessing 20 ecstasy tablets.
A report is being prepared for the Coroner.
Perth Now